Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Science at the Crossroads

Socialist Organiser no. 518, 26 March 1992 · scan p. 15 · about 569 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 15 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 15

COLUIVIN

Just over 60 years ago, the Second International Congress of the History of Science and Technology was held in London.

It was made notable by the delegation of scientists from the USSR which attended, led by Nikolai Bukharin. Their contributions, published under the title Science at the Crossroads in 1931 and reprinted in 1971, make interesting reading, not least as a historical document.

The decision to attend was a sudden one, judging by the haste with which delegates left Moscow. Bukharin discovered on the plane that he had left the text of his speech behind The members of the delegation included some very prominent scientists. Vavilov, who spoke on the origins of the world's agriculture, was President of the Lenin Academy of Agricultural Sciences. Boris Hessen, who gave the most interesting contribution, was a prominent physicist and defender of Einsteinian theories. Professor Ernest Kol'man was a renowned mathematician who died only recently, and Abram Joffe was the doyen of USSR physics until his death in 1960, The fate of some of the delegates is a tragic comment on the degeneration of the USSR. Bukharin, though he had been expelled from the Politburo for "Right deviationism" in 1929, was still an influential figure in industrial research and scientific development at the time of the Congress. Only seven years later, he was shot on ludicrous charges of working for both the Trotskyists and the Nazis!

Kol'man spent many years in prison under Stalin. Hessen simply disappeared in about 1934, presumably in some anonymous prison ecutioner's cell.

Vavilov's fate is particularly illuminating. The bogus genetic theories of one Lysenko, though devoid of validity, fitted in with the "pulling oneself up by one's bootstraps" ethos of Stalin's "socialism in one country"

Vavilov clung to "bourgeois" Mendelian genetics and was deprived of his job and his freedom. He died of cold, hunger, and illness in prison in 1942.

essen's contribution to Bed The Economic and Social Roots of Newton's Principia.

It was a brash Marxist challenge to the conventional view that Newton was an example of fortuitous genius. As Alexander Pope put it, Nature and nature's laws lay hid in night; God said 'Let Newton be!' and all was light.

It was generally accepted that modern civilisation owed much to the accident of the birth of Newton (and of other geniuses, like Galileo). Hessen preferred to look at the society that had produced Newton and set him problems to exercise his mind.

The growth of trade and industry had led to the need for waterways and improvement in the capacity and safety of vessels. The sciences of hydrostatics and dynamics grew. The growth of mining led to demand for machinery capable of lifting great weights, pumping out water, ventilating the mines, etc. Mechanics, hydro- and aerostatics developed further. The development of artillery led to the growth of the science of ballistics.

Newton's Principia contained the mathematical bases of motion under applied forces, friction, hydrostatics, buoyancy, gas pressure, behaviour of pendulums in air, movement of liquids, trajectory of thrown objects, movement of planets, variations in gravity and so on. All of these were problems with practical applications to do with navigation, accurate timing, etc.

Even Newton's alchemical investigations had a practical end, in that they were aimed at overcoming the shortage of copper needed for production of guns.

Newton was a genius, but even geniuses need real problems to focus their minds.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 518

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →