Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The left's verdict on

Socialist Organiser no. 518, 26 March 1992 · scan pp. 10–11 · Martin Thomas · about 2,718 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Was August 1991 a capitalist counter-revolu 91 a capitalist counter-revolution against a workers' state?

Ukrainian miners demand smashing up of CP and redistribution of its assets Part One of this article (SO 517) showed that many Trotskyists responded to the dilemma posed the August coup in the USSR by pretending that the movement behind Yeltsin was not pro-capitalist but pushing for socialist democracy.

the other end ot a spectrum of responses, the German fortnightly iozialistische Zeitung combined upport for the resistance to the oup with a grimly sober assessnent of prospects.

Under the headline, "The people vin", Manuel Kellner wrote:

*The political position of the utschists had nothing in the least o do with a 'defence of socialism'. These men of the control centres of n important part of the old ureaucratic power wanted nothing ther than the market economy ut with the maintenance of the ISSR as a world power and by reans of the dictatorial liquidation fall the democratic rights and reedoms granted and gained since he beginning of the glasnost era...

"The inner disintegration of the rembers - numbering tens of rillions — of the old ruling aparatus of nower and adminstration rade it possible for the resistance SET SOFA f a few hundred thousand people, t whose head Boris Yeltsin placed imself, to finish off the spectre in hort time.

"Nothing is as before. The fate I the CPSU is sealed... its discredit omplete. From an emancipatory oint of view no tears are to be shed or this political machine for rganising careers and politically rs' state? expropriating the the population...

"The accelerated disintegration of the USSR and its end as a world power are irreversible...

*Once again the world situation has changed in favour of capital and the rich western states... When the Tsarist flags waved outside the Russian White House it had to be clear, if it was not before, that here too reactionary mass sentiments are spreading... " (29.8.91)

"Do bad perspectives threaten? In spite of all that, through the latest events the democratic free space and the possibilities for free political self-activity for the peoples of the Soviet Union have become lastingly greater, and that is essential in view of all the difficulties that they will be facing. " (Article by E. Laurent)

As to the basic questions about the nature of the old Stalinist system, however, Sozialistische Zeitung offered only cryptic comment:

"Economic historians may in more peaceful times, nostalgically sipping a glass of Gorbachev vodka, have out the argument about what it once was: the economy of a deformed workers' state, that of a non-capitalist society sui generis, or a state-capitalist society. And the question of the character of the rulers of this coun try - caste, class, "new bourgeoisie" — is secondary today. In the light of concrete events (it) seems to me proven way the soviet name to annan Solandlala Canad economy after the military putsch is moving into a breathtakingly fast process of transformation, at the end of which lies a private capitalist society of the type of the Third World countries..." (Article by W. Wolf).

Most Trotskyist publications took a rather evasive middle way: on the one hand Yeltsin's triumph created dangers, on the other hand there are new possibilities gress.

Thus Socialist Outlook:

*The defeat of the attempted Stalinist coup is a tremendous victory for the workers throughout the Soviet Union. If the coup had been successful, the democratic gains won during the years of glasnost would have been savagely eliminated.

*The coup finally crumbled because of divisions within the army and KGB leadership. These divisions were in part a product of the defiance by politicians like Yeltsin, but above all because of the mass mobilisations to defend democracy.

*Perhaps the workers' mobilisations were not large enough to be absolutely decisive; but they showed what would have been necessary to make the coup stick - mass slaughter, new rebellions, probably civil war. All that was too much to stomach for more far-sighted leaders of the army high command.

*The defeat of the plotters creates a massive potential for deepening democracy and advancing working class interests. But there are formidable obstacles to realising that potential. " (14.9.91)

And the Fourth Internationalist Tendency (USA):

"The defeat of the coup was a genuine victory for the Soviet peoples. The active intervention of the masses in this situation creates important opportunities for the forces of democracy and socialism...

*Those who favor an all-out restoration of capitalism will obviously be strengthened and emboidened. To the extent that "economic reforms" are advanced at the expense of the masses, however, elements among the working class can be expected to utilize any and all democratic freedoms to struggle for defense of their economic interests and the rights won in 1917. Mass action against "We can't go on like this" - Moscow protest the antidemocratic coup may pave the way for mass actions in the direction of genuine socialism." (8.9.91)

And Workers' Press:

"1) The coup was the last stroke of Stalinism, dying and in agony. We must definitely finish off the remains of the totalitarian regime. Demand the KGB be disbanded!

...4) The coup was put down, in the end by the actions of the ordinary people - massive demonstrations and strikes. We must not allow forces that are against the people to profit from the fruits of the people's victory.

*Today, the leading 'democrats' proclaim themselves sole 'victors over dictatorship'. They think the nation has accepted in advance their policies, including wide-spread privatisation, anti-trade union laws, etc. But this policy leads to massive unemployment, hyperinflation, and in the end, to a new dictatorship..." (7.9.91)

The implications?

"Trotsky's definition of this state was that potentially it can be used by the workers: this because the nationalised property is a great gain. He speaks of the bureaucracy protecting the state structure with its own methods — but now we can't speak of this anymore.

"It is attacking the structure relentlessly. Now we are in a transitional period. The workers' state is not liquidated: a bourgeois state has not yet taken its place. " (Workers' Press, 14.9.91)

Workers' Power put more stress on the dangers, while still allowing its instincts to outweigh its theory and bring it out against the coup. depicted as a secona "evolution" "Yeltsin's seizure in the western media, nothing more than a pro-capitalist counter"This opens up an enormous opportunity for capitalism.

*No one should mourn Stalinism's inglorious death. It was a system doomed in the historie short term. Not even a successful and bloody coup could have saved it in the long run.

"But no one should be jumping for joy at the rise to power of a Thatcherite, Russian chauvinist.

...We must defend what is left of the social gains ushered in by the October Revolution 1917 "..At the same time it means being the most resolute fighters for the real democratic rights of the masses, even where the masses have Illusions in the form of the parliamentary "democracy" used to con us in the west into endorsing the rule of the profiteers." (September 1991)

he British Militant and the French weekly tutte Ouvriere clearly registered facts which shattered the idea that the old USSR was a "workers' state"

Yet they combined their assessment of the lack of any live working-class element in the Stalinist "workers' state" with a refusal to reconsider the "workers' state" formula.

Thus Militant:

"Leon Trotsky warned half a century ago of the tendencies towards capitalist restoration among these parasites who had usurped the political rule of the working people. What restrained them was fear of the workers' commitment to the principles of the planned economy.

"But that was a mere generation on from the October socialist revolution. Today, 50 more years of accumulated resentment of the privileged bureaucrats and the dead stop to which they have brought the Soviet economy, have for now undermined that commitment among the majority of the working 19-21 August marked a turn towards capitalism:

"The collapse of the 60-hour coup represents a decisive turn for the Soviet Union. It will have a decisive effect in Eastern Europe, hastening the move to the market.

"It will have a decisive impact on world relations, confirming US imperialism's current dominant world position. " (30.8.91)

Militant had no illusion that a revolution for socialist democracy was underway: it proposed as an immediate perspective, not the "political revolution" but only the building of "a genuine workers' party". Nevertheless it weicomed the defeat of the coup.

Lutte Ouvrière's leaflet on 19 August declared:

The putschists... to go by their statements, have intervened to

Scan page 11

Striking miners in Siberia save the USS which is weakened and threatened with dismantlement by centrifugal forces... The installation of a military-police regime in the USSR would weigh heavily on the soviet workers, who could be once again muzzled for years...

*But the soviet workers could seize the opportunity to intervene in the current test of force, by opposing the coup on their own account, on condition that they do not put themselves at the tail of people like Yeltsin, who is as much an enemy of the working classes as the military and KGB men.

"This outcome is, unfortunately, not the most likely one, because since the beginning of perestroika we have not seen the workers taking advantage of the measures of political liberalisation to create their own political organisations, and it is never easy to improvise...

"We can only hope that the soviet working class surprise us...

On 23 August Lutte Ouvrière noted:

"...There is the common affirmation, made (albeit with nuances) by the majority if not all the currents expressing themselves at the top of the bureaucracy, of the necessity of a return to the capitalist market. But none of them, whether they call themselves democrats' or not, really dare think or say that this capitalist restoration can be done peacefully, without the aid of a strong or even dictatorial government 95 Then on 30 August it hedged its bets further:

*The reiterated affirmation of the necessity of going fast along the road of reforms and the reestablishment of the market is witness to the complexity of the problems. Now... (i.e. after the coup's collapse] the enormity of the economic and social problems is going to appear more cruelly..

*This social phenomenon which is the USSR, both the outcome of the first workers' revolution and deformed by the Stalinist degeneration, remains a problem without precedent and its future may well give rise to a situation as unprecedented as its past has been... "workers' state" formula, and concluded that the USSR was a variant of state-capitalism, or a formation parallel to capitalism, there was no difficulty in principle about recognising the Yeltsinite anti-coup movement as bourgeois and yet welcoming it, as (for now) bourgeois-democratic. The Solidarity group in the USA (which includes some "workers' statists", but in its majority reckoned the USSR to be neither a workers' state nor capitalist) declared:

"The destruction of the power of the Communist Party is all to the good. Now what will replace it? What we are saying is that we see not one, but two processes underway in the USSR, both dramatically accelerated by the attempted Stalinist coup and its failure. One is the process of democracy, initiated 'from above' by Gorbachev and now open to the masses to expand from below. The other is the attempt to 'marketize' the economy from above and from outside. This would inevitably create a capitalism with enormous inequalities, prosperity alongside incredible misery and huge indebtedness to western banks. In other words, it would be the kind of capitalism that exists in Brazil, not western Europe.

*We see these two processes as being on a collision course - not immediately, but perhaps in the not too distant future."

Socialist Worker had long rejected the "workers' state" formula. Yet its response was curiously confused - partly, it seems, because of its habitual indifference to questions of political democracy, and partly because of its habitual glorification of militancy of any sort.

Socialist Worker proved unable to support the anti-coup movement without painting it up in the manner of Informations Ouvrières: the movement was, Socialist Worker suggested, quasi-socialist, or at least likely to become socialist if it became more intense.

"The fight against the coup is part of the fight for a new society, quite different to either Stalinist state capitalism or the market described the coup tempt to restore the The coup leaders, it declared (23 August), "are the living embodinent of the Stalinist regime that screwed workers' living standards for the last 60 years while the rulers lived in luxury.

*Whatever they say, coup leaders want a return those days." rather evasive middle way: on ti were now possibilities progress Socialist Organiser issued leaflet on 19 August against the coup:

"Any claim that the new regime defends 'communism' or 'socialism' is a sham. In reality it is almost certain to continue Gorbachev's course of converting to capitalist market economics and reintegrating the USSR into world trade; only it will seek stronger, more brutal control over the working class and the oppressed nationalities during the process.

"Even if the new regime should restore more centralised control over the Soviet economy, that would never justify' suppressing and crushing of the working class. Exploitation of the working class by a privileged bureaucracy through a centralised command economy is in capitalist market economics, to think, to debate, to organise, and to work out their own future.

"The Soviet working class, the new trade unions, and the oppressed nationalities, will resist the new regime. Western socialists should support the resistance...

In a broadsheet dated 20 August Socialist Organiser commented:

*If the neo-Stalinist, quasifascist backlash now triggers a deep popular revolution, it may not end quite as Yeltsin and the Russian neo-bourgeoisie want.

"Socialists in Britain must give their unqualified support to the resistance to the neo-Stalinist dictatorship. Long live the Russian Revolution!"

And after the defeat of the Socialist Organiser added:

"There has not yet been that deep popular revolution. Far from it. Much of the state apparatus remains intact, the army high in prestige. The economy of the USSR spirals downwards daily into hyperinflation and probable famine.

"Yeltsin will now have to take responsibility. He will not work miracles.

*The army has, by its shotgun divorce from the CP, been rendered a more credible contender for the Third World army role of providing a military scaffolding when the bourgeoisie is weak and the society in chronic crisis.

"Last week's failed coup and the radical backlash it licensed tumbled the system Stalin built into history's dustbin. It may also have decided what kind of authoritarianismone controlled by the vacillating Easteri Socialist Organiser no.518 page Gorbachevite apparatus-men or one controlled by the radicals — will be imposed in the period ahead.

The headline of our broadsheet last week remains true: 'Only revolution - that is, the destruction of the state apparatus, including the army — can secure liberty'. " (29 August).

We defined what was happening:

What we are witnessing in the USSR is a bourgeois revolution. The leaders of the anti-Stalinist revolution and their ideas; the ideas in the heads of the mass of the people (including the working class); the West European and US social models they look to — all define it as a bourgeois revolution...

*It faces tremendous difficulties. But they are material, practical, technical difficulties — the lack of markets and of an entrepreneurial bourgeoisie, the tremendous weight of the bureaucracy even after it is certifiably brain dead, etc - not difficulties arising from the resistance of the working class, or by the coherent resistance of any other class". (29 August).

And we drew conclusions:

"Socialists in the USSR should be the most vigorous advocates of revolutionary measures against the old order, competing with the Yeltsinites for the leadership of the democratic revolution, while countering their pro-capitalist ideas and trying to organise the working class as an independent force. Their model should be the Bosheviks, who before 1917 competed with the "Cadet" bourgeoisie for the leadership of the masses in the fight against Tsarism. " (3 October)

EASTERN

----- pull-quotes -----

"Most Trotskyist publications took

one hand Yeltsin triumph created dangers, on the other hand there

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 518

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →