Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

GEC strike: rank and file draw the lessons

Socialist Organiser no. 518, 26 March 1992 · scan pp. 7–8 · Dave Barter · about 1,761 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

Wednesday | 19th Openshaw marched back to work. After just one day short of seven weeks of strike the return to work was united and defiant, but without agreement. The jobs fight had been betrayed; mass sackings are now expected.

With the Tory recession deeper than ever huge numbers of redundancies are being announced. Workers at Fords, Jaguar, British Telecom and Hotpoint have all been hit. The seven week strike at GEC Alsthom in Openshaw, East Manchester was the first stand against the bosses jobs offensive, a rallying point for the whole trade union movement. That stand was defeated - the whole movement must draw the lessons.

Rick Hesketh MSF branch chair, explained to Socialist Organiser how the strike ended:

"The strike ended essentially through a pincer movement from the employers and the unions' national officials. The national officers' role was primarily to undermine our organisation and to demonstrate that they were prepared to see the plant close and be associated with the closure and mass sackings.

"The role of the officials was appalling. Essentially they played for and got the decision. We had heard on the Friday (February 14) the meeting in Birmingham was going to be loaded. Officials fully expected to convince our negotiating committee that they should recommend a return to work. The stance they took at the mass meeting (on February 18th) was heavily nuanced, despite the illusion of appearing to sit on the fence. "The instant announcement of John Dougherty to the "Manchester Evening News" after the meeting was that the decision to return to work was a sensible one - implying that to continue the strike would have been idiotic. "Similarly, press statements released prior to the mass meeting were equally loaded. They were speaking of "common sense prevailing" and the action UEL DPENSE SIRENCH not being taken in the first place had the officials realised the magnitude of the job-loss. Evidently 12 was seen as winnable, 157 wasn't.

John Byrne, AEU member at Openshaw, takes up the story:

"At the mass meeting it was spelt out in quite graphic detail that the officials thought we had absolutely no chance of winning. People had in their hands letters stating that if they did not return to work the following day they would be dismissed and sent their P45s. The fact that the national officials put up absolutely no stance of opposing the potential closure and sackings weighed quite heavily with the workers.

"The strike leadership didn't expect it to be quite as blatant. A select committee of the house of Commons had interviewed Weinstock (GEC boss) and two of the local MPs had discussed with him. His attitude was 'if you don't get back to work I'll close the plant'. National union officials were given the same message at another meeting. Unfortunately the leaders both Parliamentary and trade union accepted that ! No argument about 'where would you move the work?'. , ' we organise resistance against the move?' None of those challenges were put down to GEC management. Without the challenges coming from national level then I think the middle ground within the strike could have won the strike."

Rick Hesketh MSF felt we were onto a loser, and that it was a matter of salvaging what we could."

The initially supportive attitude of the union officials changed when GEC made its threat of mass sackings of the strikers. Just as the union's should have upped the stakes and transformed the strike into a national issue, they collapsed and looked to persuading the strikers to return to work. Kick Hesketh explains: "The main problem was not having a response to the ultimate threat. We managed to up the stakes every time except the last one. You don't blame the membership, because they gave us seven weeks to sort it out. Its quite simple: the national officers actually finished the strike, undermined our organisation." John Byrne again: "If the strike at GEC Openshaw was to be successful then at least the national union leadership would have had to do things that On the picket line involved breaking the law and getting effective solidarity action in trades union terms from other groups of workers. Unfortunately the history we've gone through of "new realism" has just accepted that the Tories and the capitalists can do just what the hell they want.

"It would have been absolutely necessary to get in touch with other GEC plants to ensure that work was not going to be transferred from Openshaw and that machinery was not going to be transferred. We would probably have come into some sort of conflict with the law. We would have had to visit other GEC factories and do a lot of work within the labour movement to ensure that we got support. Sooner or later we would have had to organise a meeting - which the national officials should have been doing - of stewards within GEC to fight redundancies."

The Tory anti-trades union laws undoubtedly had an effect on the strike. Whilst no action was taken against the mass pickets - regularly 50 or 60, not the legal six - there undoubtedly would have been if management made a serious attempt to move anything through the line.

As Rick Hesketh explains, the main effect of the law was on solidarity: " solidarity was excel lent in terms of moral and financial support but it was fundamentally weakened legislation. We were reticent to ask.

As far as the Labour Party is concerned, it clearly demonstrates the need for a framework positive rights to take industrial action, and rights to information, consultation and co-decision, particularly where multi-nationals are concerned. The obvious weakness was our lack of immunity to the effect of mass dismissals. if the first lesson of this strike is the need for positive rights in law for workers' action, the second is the need to build rank and file organisations in he unions to prevent sell outs by union officials like the one we saw at Openshaw. John Byrne again: "What shook people was the speed with which the union officials pulled the rug. We would have expected possibly some formula to be reached that at least has some face-saving for the officials, but we didn't expect total surrender. We need to get genuine broad lefts within the unions tied to policies of rejection of new realism. We need a fight for a programme within the unions that is in the interest of the membership and to ensure that the officials carry out that programme. I don't mean a narrow organisation controlled by this group or that group but one where people on the left would be able to come together and democratically hammer things out. There is a real dearth of leadership on the left - I think its going to have to come from below"

The effect of lack of national leadership in the Openshaw dispute should not be underestimated. At a strike mass meeting on February 12th the danger of mass sackings had already been aired. Strikers voted to continue knowing they could be sacked. The difference the following week was the attitude taken by the officials. Everyone in Manchester knows the story could have been different if John Tocher- who died last year - had "At the mass meeting it was spelt out in quite graphic detail that the officals thought we had absolutely no chance of winning™ John Byrne still been at the helm of the AEU District in Manchester. The official who engineered the sell out -in the first place John Allen of the AEU and Larry Brooks of MSF - should be held to account by their unions' membership.

A third lesson is the importance of mobilising solidarity. An enormous amount of money was raised for the strike and on the evening of the Tuesday the strike was called off the Manchester Trades Council had a special meeting to discuss launching a support group. But still, more could have been made of it.

The fourth lesson - and one of the most positive developments in the strike - is the practical struggle to build workers' international links. Rick Hesketh has been pioneering GEC workers' links across Europe from the Openshaw plant: " If the links had been made three years ago it could have won the strike. The objective is effective organisation throughout Europe with the bottom line that we could call and that call be reciprocated in the event of a dispute of considerable significance in any member plant. I would be looking at some sort of elected joint council to deal with claims for action. I'm talking about strike levies. blacking. You'd be looking to maintain your employment levels and not take work from elsewhere.

Of course, we'll have to extend to the Third World which could be a problem. We're going to organise a French link-up (GEC Alsthom is based in France). We've got a comprehensive list of plants and we're looking for contacts, a dialogue".

Rick wrote Socialist Organiser on January 30th: "The dispute has given our relations with the French CGT an immediacy and intensity which otherwise might have taken years to cement. These links acknowledge a recognition both side of the Channel that multinational capital can only be effectively addressed by multinational labour."

Since the strike ended the Tories have called the General Election and some former strikers have been out canvassing for Labour on the doorstep. Organised delegations from the Openshaw plant could increase the number going out and be part of a process of recruiting former strikers into the Labour Party to fight for the sort of policies on trades union laws this strike has shown to be necessary. John Byrne: "There are enough of us who are members of the Labour Party to take that up on site and look into some the marginal constituencies. A real sense of camaraderie was built up in the strike the idea of us going out canvassing as a group would make more sense now".

Whatever happens in the election the union organisation at GEC Openshaw will live to fight another day. The joint union leadership on site conducted itself with dignity and principle throughout the dispute, and has maintained the respect and unity of the workforce. The tragedy is that they were stabbed in the back by the union officials. That. is a lesson the movement must learn.

Scan page 8

SOCIALIST Vote Labour ORGANISER

----- pull-quotes -----

*If the links had been made three years ago

GEC OPENSHAW LESC ITY VGTH

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 518

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →