"New Left Review" goes Lib-Lab
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-03-26Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
and Jim Davidson.
Unfortunately they have been erroneously listed as comedians.
Branson: shy - and retiring t is often said that student politics is divorced from the "real world". The antics of Paul Hewitt, the recently elected rightwing chair of the National Organisation of Labour Students (NOLS), would tend to support that view Hewitt's first act after the NOLS elections wa to canvass for a candidate against the Labour Club in an election at Kent Jniversity. To ensure victory, ne got the support of local Tories and Liberals. In return, Hewitt's right wing clique supported a Tory for another position. In a further twist to the plot, the Tories were out canvassing for a (right wing) Labour restating conservative values and not mincing her words. No more Mister Nice-Guy? We live in hope. T went on the wo sets of mystics campaign trail last week. The first were the "Natural Law Party", led by the guru Maharishi Yogi. They published newspaper adverts of a series of equations which, they claimed, showed the scientific case for a theory of everything (connected to super-string theory).
However, scientific opinion found very little convincing in the adverts.
The other mystics, known as the "Law and Order Party", went on the vote trail, led now by a lesser prophet, (a heretic, many claim,) Majorishi, who is trying to take on the mantle of the guru, Thatcherami. Their theory of everything they chant as a mantra, "Labour will increase taxes for everyone", believing that, if they chant it for the next three weeks, victory be their s. Scientific opinion is not convinced.
coording to Robin New Left Review (NLR)
and previously for many years a Trotskyist, we should vote Liberal in many constituencies on 9 April!
"In England", so he writes in NLR 191, "it will make sense to vote Labour or Liberal Democrat depending on which candidate is better placed to defeat the Conservative, with some allowance made for the individual's stance on democratisation"
He argues that a straight Labour administration would be less good than a Lib-Lab coalition government, because "less likely to introduce proportional representation, While in all other respects just as moderate" . And he wants proportional representatior because it "would enable a New Left formation at some future date to measure its support in He should have been listening to Paddy Ashdown on 22 March, when Ashdown laid down conditions for a Lib-Lab alliance Of course the Liberals want proportional represen tation. But their further demands are nothing to with "democratisation"!
Ashdown said he would insist that: • Labour must drop its small tax increases on the well-off. These "would drive out of a proper economy exactly those people who we are going to depend on to get ourselves out of recession". • Labour must drop the minimum wage - "exactly contrary to what this country must now create, which is a flexible labour market" For the Liberals, a bit more income tax on the well-off is an intolerable offence Important People, while minimum wage is outrageous generosity to surly proletarians who should be more "flexible"
• Labour must drop all ideas of renationalisation.
• Labour must support making the Bank of England independent of political control; that is, Labour must agree that ke areas of state economic policy should be decided by bankers without any pretence of democratic accountability.
"PR 'would a New Left formation to True, the Labour leaders themselves are already dropping renationalisation. But, at the very least, alliance with the Liberals would give Neil Kinnock a convenient excuse; and on some issues it could drive Labour further right than even Neil Kinnock would wish.
Even support portional representation -and there are good reasons for doing so though not for seeing it as the be-all and end-all of democratic reform - to pay that price for it is grotesque.
To say that alliance with the Liberals would not make a Labour Government less responsive to working-class demands is to say that the current depressed state of the labour movement is fixed and unchangeable. It is to say that the trade unions and the labour movement would not and could not put serious pressure on that Labour Government. It is out-andout defeatism!
To make fiddling with the electoral system in order to get a couple of left MPs ou central concern is to give up on the battle within the trade unions and the Labour Party, and to collapse into "parliamentary cretinism".
And, in any case, who is to say that the Liberal MPs elected with the votes of Robin Blackburn and his friends will not choose to give us a Lib-Tory coalition government instead of a Lib-Lab one?
Scan page 7
iser
----- pull-quotes -----
EVE=ON THE LEFF
measure its support in elections'. "