Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

South Africa after the white referendum

Socialist Organiser no. 518, 26 March 1992 · scan pp. 5–6 · about 2,363 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

Recce" crack troops of the state's 'Special Felix Isaias Ndimene a Mozambican pressTom Rigby ast week everyone, outside of South Africa's far right, seemed to be momentarily united in celebrating FW De Klerk's victory in the whites-only referendum on change.

The Financial Times, the Economist, Business Week and the Wall Street Journal were delirious. The Johannesburg Stock Exchange was "buoyant". And the African National Congress, long battered and repressed by the Pretoria regime, also welcomed the Socialists and genuine, thoroughgoing democrats have no reason to celebrate.

The referendum was simply a vote of confidence in De Klerk from the white electorate. The result of this pigmentocratic plebiscite, in which only members of the privilegec white "community" could vote, gives De Klerk a mandate to continue on his present course of introducing reforms "from above" whilst waging civil war on the black majority "from below", , or, rather, from the shadows.

Last Tuesday's vote did nothing to remove the real obstacles to democratic change, like De Klerk's murderous apparatus of repression. On the contrary. "De Klerk's killing machine" , as Nelson Mandela has called it, continues in place. 26 people died after the massacre on the Soweto comuter train in September 1990.

ganged into the South African army has confirmed that this was the work of "Fire Over the last two decades, the apartheid military/police apparatus has laid waste to huge areas of the subcontinent, wrecking the lives of millions of people, and has waged low-intensity civil war against the inhabitants of South Africa's black townships.

Since "peace" was officially declared, with the release of Mandela and the unbanning of the ANC in February 1990, the death rate in the townships from "unrest-related violence" has increased massively.

It is just not possible to separate De Klerk's negotiating strategy from the security forces' overt and covert attempts to fan the flames of township violence. A De Klerk intends to let s well as negotiating, loose his stormtroopers, who will bomb, shoot, rape, batter and burn their way to the new South Africa.

This is not random violence. It is deliberate and purposeful.

De Klerk doesn't need to be the evil mastermind behind every "unrest" incident for the activities of the state-supported death squads to dovetail with his overall policy.

In recent years, the military top brass, working first through the shadowy Directorate of Military Intelligence (DMI) and later, after the formal disbanding of the DMI, through other forms, have pursued a sophisticated military/ political strategy.

abated. De Klerk caletrates They have sought to combine violence against black people, both indiscriminate and selective, with calculated attempts to change the political climate. These "Psychological Operations" (PsyOps) are known within South Africa's secret state as WHAM - Winning Hearts and Minds.

When the "Inkathagate" scandal broke last year, former DMI agent Nicco Basson (General Magnus Malan's chauffeur in Angola, later Assistant Director of the South African Broadcasting Corporation) spelled out the meaning of WHAM and its relation to the politics of negotiations.

"It was only now, when apartheid was going and 'non-racial' elections were in the offing, that SADE strategists were beginning to see the prospect of a comForces'. 3,000 people were killed between February '90 and April 91 without a single conviction. since then the violence has not prehensive WHAM success.

The end of the violence [in the townships, orchestrated by the SADF] has not been to destroy property or to kill -that has only been a means. The political objectives have all been directed towards the eventual goal of securing white control in the post-apartheid set-up...

The end goal is a divided and undermined ANC, and an alliance of the ruling National Party, Inkatha, and other 'moderate' black organi a tiegitimately will power, with the SADE's own power structure remaining intact".

This is the model of controlled reform or democratisation from above that has been used in Latin America over the last decade. It works on the same principle as the contra war against the people of Nicaragua: a war designed to make the people vote for "peace" by voting the Sandinistas out of office. The aim is controlled terror against the black majority so as to "de-politicise" them, combined with concessions to their leaders.

here can be no celebration of a "new dawn" in South Africa while the instruments of this policy are firmly in place.

On the contrary, the mass movement must link the demand for immediate elections to a constituent assembly with the call for the breaking up of "De Klerk's killing However, De Klerk is not in total control of the situation. Firstly, the token purge of the fascist AWB which is likely to come in the wake of the referendum result could turn the lower levels of the YES white police and army against the top of the hierarchy.

Secondly, if the National Party opts for an electoral alliance with the ANC as opposed to a bloc with Inkatha and other conservative black forces, then the existing state machine could start to crack up. Homeland leaders like Buthelezi in KwaZula and Mangope in Bophutatswana will seek to defend the military/bureaucratic base of their own privilege against the central state.

De Klerk's post-referendum negotiating agenda gives us a glimpse of just how truncated the democracy of the "new South Africa" is going to be. De Klerk is ruling out anything other than token committees to "oversee" the security apparatus, and the National Party is demanding: • Equal representation for all parties in the second house of the regional legislatures. (This is a kind of built-in white veto). • Only parties with over 15% of the vote should have seats in the main parliament. (This would keep out the smaller, non-ANC, anti-apartheid forces). • A constitutional guarantee to block anything approaching genuine majority rule until the year 2000, and to entrench "power-sharing" (whatever that may be). Ping director of SASOL. aul Kruger, the managthe country's biggest fuel and chemicals company (which unleased murderous vigilantes against strikers in 1987), knows the real significance of last week's He told Times:

*The electorate [sic] has now been satisfied that the state president is not willing to give everything away, that he has certain economic bottom lines".

The message is simple: apartheid may have gone, but the market can do roughly the same job by keeping the vast majority of blacks out of the white suburbs, schools, and swimming pools. Most black people simply can not afford them. The few that can will be used to hold down the struggles of those that can not.

The problem for South Africa's rulers is that the country's working class -the biggest and most powerful on the continent - could well prove somewhat stronger than the thin layer of trade union officials and ANC activists who now seek to channel their democratic and socialist aspirations through the narrow channels of top-down negotiations.

The vote has not made South Africa a more stable place. If anything, the country will become more unstable. After all, the black workers are going to expect more from Nelson Mandela — who could be titular president within a year - than they would from De Klerk. The fuse still burns...

STOP PRESS: De Klerk's representatives in CODESA, negotiating forum, have now announced that there will be no interim government until the ANC disbands its armed wing Umkhonto we Sizwe. The government has also announced that it is bringing back state lynchings after a 20 month freeze. Welcome to the Deep

Scan page 6

The tabloids strive - impotently as yet - to get the Socialist Organiser No. 518 page 6 GRAFFITI t's a cruel world - when you're down, all your fair weather friends claim never to have known you. Acquaintances cross the street rather than be seen with you. One by one, names are crossed out in your address book. This is what the Tories are finding - nobody popular wants to be seen hanging around with these pariahs.

So many celebs were jumping onto the Labour election bandwagon that the Tories were panicked into publishing a list of 84 stars of their own, prepared by the Kurds' favourite Jeffrey "where's the money gone?" Archer. It seems that Archer bought all his literary skill to bear on the list - that is to say it was a badly written fiction.

A queue formed of people asking to be taken off -firstly. Richard Branson of Virgin who didn't want the publicity, a Conservative spokesperson said. Is this the same man who raced speedboats across the Atlantic and flew back in a hot air balloon, each time in a near blinding blaze of self publicity?

Of the original 84, 14 have left: that's 1 in 6.

Others who were co-opted to the Tories' side by the Tory press have also been fighting back: "Botham bats for Major" ran a Sun headline last week. This week's headlines will run "Botham sues for malicious falsehood"

The Tories still have Bob Monkhouse, Jimmy Tarbuck candidate for So, who won Independents!

To add insult to injury Hewitt's obsession with Kent University elections meant that he failed to take either himself or his supporters in Kent to the extraordinary NUS Conference, which no doubt ensured the Kinnockites' failure to. get a a clear two-thirds majority for their reform proposals.

The murmurings from Walworth Rd are that Hewitt isn't up to leading Labour's student section and that funding is to be cut as a direct result his election.

*he Tory campaign thus far has to be the worst, most miserable, uncentred and confused, mess-up I've ever seen". Interesting comment because it comes, not from a Labour politician pointing to the Tories' weaknesses, but from arch-Tory. Michael Winner, director of films such as Death Wish, a nasty little film about a gun-toting vigilante, famed for its glib and voyeuristic view of violence towards women.

Winner continues "I'm absolutely fed up with hearing how 'nice' Mr Major is. Nice is not necessarily an asset. | looked up nice in my dictionary. The first definitions were: "Foolishly simple, wanton, coy. over-particular Yeah, that'll bring in votes".

Winner is at this moment working on Death Wish Ill: the election campaign is taken over by Thatcher PRESIS-GANG Denham "verything might have -changed by the time you read this, but the consensus at the end of week one of the election campaign seems to be that Labour is winning the propaganda war, if only on points.

This is pretty remarkable, when you consider the overwhelming advantages that the Tory Party enjoys in terms of superior finances and sympathetic newspapers. Add to this the fact that Week One was dominated by the economy - which is traditionally a good Conservative pitch -and Labour's continuing lead in the opinion polls begins to look like more than just a flash in the pan.

Of course, the unemployment figures, and the string ot other poor "economic indicators" announced last week, ought to have put Labour even further ahead, but we are not playing on an even field (to use the fashionable parlance) when it comes to press coverage. Monday's London Evening Standard, for instance, Tory message across greeted the latest balance of payments figures with the front-page headline: "Major buoyant as trade gap narrows"; tucked away in the business section of the same paper was the headline: "Trade gap worse than feared at £750 million"

Nevertheless, the Tories are clearly rattled. John Major's PR advisors have told him to shed his "nice guy" image and to go onto the offensive against Kinnock personally. I do hope that Mr. Major follows this advice: not only is there plenty of evidence that the electorate are thoroughly turned-oft by "negative campaigning" but also being attacked by the Grey Man must surely rank alongside (in the immortal words of Denis Healey about Geoffrey Howe) being savaged by a dead sheep.

Another sign of Tory desperation is the decision to wheel out Mrs. Thatcher Polls put and to "unleash" Norman Tebbit, to "beef up" their campaign. About the only thing Major has ever had going for him is the fact that he is not Mrs. Thatcher. These two unguided missiles can only serve to remind people of thirteen years of greed, selfishness and corruption. Mrs. T.'s first outing of the campaign resulted in her being assaulted with a bunch of daffodils brandished by an outraged citizen. I very much hope that no-one takes it upon themselves to head-butt Mr. Tebbit.

Conventional wisdom has it that the "Fergie Factor" worked in favour of the Tories last week, by keeping the unemployment figures off the front pages. I doubt this. Given the bias of the tabloids, the net result of the Royal Marriage Crisis has surely been several days in which blatant Tory propaganda did not dominate the front pages of the popular press.

And I have a sneaking feeling that coverage like "Duchess could get £75,000 with just one trip to shops" (Today) and "Fergie can expect a f10 million lump sum and an annual payment of £500,000" (Daily Star) might just be of benefit to the party that advocates a £3.40 minimum wage.

Hats off to Anthony Bevins, Political Editor of the Independent. The scene was the Tories' Monday morning press conference. The speaker was John Major. The theme was Labour's secret plan to "raise taxes savagely in every budget, year after year"

Mr. Bevins simply asked Major to give a pledge that he would not increase the overall tax burden in the next Parliament. The Grey Man blustered, twisted and turned but finally admitted that he could not give a "categorical assurance"

Bevins then pointed out that the tax burden' had risen since 1979: more bluster from Mr. Major to the effect that Labour had artificially deflated taxation with high-level borrowing. Bevins replied: "Your borrowing requirement is now bigger than you inherited from Labour" and backed this up with figures from an official Treasury Budget briefing note. Major was reduced to bleating, "I have answered that question" Imagine what the Sun, Mail, Express etc. would have made of a comparable routing of Neil Kinnock or John Smith.

----- pull-quotes -----

REE XONEL THE HEAT

Dailyt Mail LABOUR TO

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 518

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →