Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Sectarian lessons from afar

Socialist Organiser no. 517, 19 March 1992 · scan pp. 11–12 · about 1,404 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 11

Cate discredited by decades of Statist abuses workers having democratic control, or see the USA almost everyone looks to free-market economics; the Kagarlitsky favours privatisation of small shops and suchlike, but the transformation of big enterprises into fortunately-placed comrades in the West, is that we t a "social sector" under workers' management. When to understand, to help, to criticise constructively. Yet wildcat rip-off privatisation by the old bureaucrats, but making clear that he does not denounce small private conservative in Britain, but in Russia, where people's Kagarlitsky's new Russian Party of Labour - "civilised lives are dominated by very uncivilised markets, it is forms of market" - to sneer, "That's a good slogan for not so feeble. "Market wages for market prices" is an On 21 February Militant followed in similar style. Ar For Russian socialists to say "we demand planning article supposedly reporting on "new left wing parties in Russia" gave half its space to the Party of Labour - counterproductive. Planning by whom? By the old bureaucrats? By the workers? But the workers are Rabochaya Democratiya - but claimed that the PL workers' movement was turning towards class-struggle * The Party of Labour does have support from the declaration that: "We believe that we shall, by this Moscow Federation of Trade Unions, which embraces means [agitation for factory laws and general suffrage] the new independent unions as well as formerly statecontrolled unions, but this counts for nothing since the promptly and more thoroughly than if we were to stand leaders of the Federation are "old union apparatchiks' and "a well-known anarcho-syndicalist"; it "has caller waiting until Mother Revolution should deign to come for strikes", but, so Militant claims, is "scared stiff of If Socialist Worker and Militant had been around to * The Party of Labour identifies with "the traditions comment then, they would have been denouncing the of Kinnock - a few MPs but no democratic debate or * HE's pro-market. Kagalisky said in November he opposed 'bad privatisation'. The slogan they use is...

* "Two professors" within the Party of Labour find "their model for workers' democracy" in the USA. "The idea that workers should have democratic control of the state is a million miles from their approach".

Trotskyist or a Leninist. As Workers' Liberty pointed Kagarlitsky's group as the be-all and end-all of the East European left, "Kagarlitsky is a sort of left social democrat. In my view', he writes, Martov and Allend were right, not Lenin'. He seeks a 'middle way' to a Kagarlitsky's current advocacy of "left Keynesianism"

Yeltsin's free-market programme, though we should do so with some understanding of the difficulties that lead him to try such formulas as a way to get a hearing and escape being marginalised. We can suggest the championed by Solidarnose in Poland in 1980-1) and supervision of prices by committees of workers and housewives (as proposed by Trotsky in the 1930s).

Socialist Worker are exaggerated or downright stupid If the initial group of socialists are mostly universitybased, it is good for them to seek alliances with leftmoving old union apparatchiks and with influential The American group Socialist Action offered a more moderate version of the same perspective. It quoted Trotsky:

The political prognosis has an alternative character: either the bureaucracy, becoming ever more the organ of the world bourgeoisie in the workers' state, will overthrow the new forms of property and plunge the country back into capitalism; or the working class will crush the bureaucracy and open the way to socialism.

And it commented:

"The political prognosis Trotsky poses is not for the far off future, but is the stark choice facing the USSR and the Eastern European countries Socialist Action assessed the coup attempt as follows:

"The difference between the opposed bureaucratic layers was whether it was possible to conținue the process of capitalist restoration by political/parliamentary means. or whether an iron-fisted dictatorship was necessary to im pose the anti-working class measures necessary to achieve the same end. "

And its defeat:

"The mobilisation of the Soviet people in opposition to the coup was the central reason for its failure... the bourgeois analysts who have focussed on the alleged "ineptitude" of the plotters as a major cause of their defeat have widely missed the mark. " (Theses on the The "Morenist" faction - a sizable force in Latin America, especially - took a similar line. Its Argentine paper, Solidaridad Socialista, declared on 23 August that the defeat of the coup was: "A workers' and popular victory which will have big repercussions around the world favourable to all workers and the oppressed. It shows once more that when the people mobilise they can impose their "Bush, Menem, Chris Reynolds democratic regulation of the economy... selfmanagement and a strong authority of people's representatives". It may be that their democratic enuine socialists in Russia face hard times. All demands are not precise or clear enough, but it is plainly slanderous to claim that they oppose the Jare discredited by decades of Stalinist abuse; a model. working-class movement is extremely weak.

The least they can ask from us, their more The opposes "bad privatisation", he is denouncing the two biggest socialist newspapers in Britain, Socialist Worker and Militant, are offering the Russian socialists only peevish and arbitrary shops and workshops. denunciations.

Socialist Worker, in September last year, seized "A civilised form of market" sounds feeble and phrase from the founding statement of Boris restoration of capitalism, to Gorbachev all want the manifesto". Neil Kinnock's (or indeed John Major's) election answer to Yeltsin's policy of letting prices rip but holding down wages. liquidate the great socialist conquests of the Russian workers, instead of the market" would be pointless or and to convert the USSR into a kind of big Argentina, with an the other groups it mentioned were the Stalinist economy ruled by the IMF. retreads and Militant's own Moscow grouplet, organised, and do not yet want to plan. Therefore they all also want to Writing to Marx on 23 February 1877, Frederick preserve the KGB and the represented nothing outside "the cosy rooms of Engels joyfully cited, as evidence that the Italian has been strengthened by this oppressive soviet army- But the Soviet working class Moscow State University". Militant went on to claim: socialism and away from anarchist phrases, a great victory. The miners, for example, who have founded their independent union and have achieve the emancipation of the proletariat more already organised three big strikes against Gorbachev, this time went for years and generations baying at the moon and on strike against the putschists.

"It is a great revolution on the and break the workers' chains". march, in which the mobilised people learn day by day. We call strikes". on the Soviet workers to destroy the KGB and the oppressive Italian workers, and probably Engels too. Soviet state and to union, strike committees - and to 'Market wages for market prices'." More from ore from Socialist support the workers of Europe and all the world to end exploitation and capitalist- Organiser imperialist oppression. This is the only way to save the USSR from imperialist colonisation. " Now Boris Kagarlitsky has never claimed to be a The German fortnightly Sozialisti sche Zeitung, in contrast, out in 1990, when Socialist Worker was boosting was as firmly realistic as Rouge, or more so; but most of the 'workers statists" took a rather evasive middle way. Opposing the coup, they side-stepped hard questions by side-stepping any clear new society, between reform and revolution". definition of current events (was it a Western Marxists can reasonably criticise capitalist counter-revolution?) and instead focusing on future or "New Deal" economics as his alternative to possibilities (the current situation, indeterminate in itself, might turn into capitalist counter-revolution or EASTERN working-class socialist revolution).

ideas of workers' control of food distribution (as the responses of two "workers' statist" groups, Militant (Britain) or workers' liberty?

But many of the criticisms from Militant and and Lutte Ouvriere, which raised devastating criticisms of the "workers'-statist" thesis without пст 60 pence drawing conclusions; and the arguments of those Trotskyists who had already, before 1991, rejected the workers. anarcho-syndicalists in order to find a path to the Ip plus 18p postage from S cial "workers" state" thesis. The Party for ganiser, P O Box 823, Lonc

Scan page 12

Organiser

----- pull-quotes -----

themselves with thei overn organisations - like the miners

EUROPE Part 2 will survey those responses;

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 517

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →