Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The left's verdict on t

Socialist Organiser no. 517, 19 March 1992 · scan pp. 10–11 · about 1,615 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Moscow demonstrators topple the statue of Dzherzhinsky In the new Workers' Liberty magazine, a wide range of socialists offer their resonses to Romarole of officious bureaucrats.

the collapse of the USSR. This article by Martin Thomas (part 1 this week, part 2 next) surveys the responses from a narrower hoped for this collapse... spectrum of the left, the Trotskyists.

Leon Trotsky, right up to his death in 1940, reckoned that the USSR was a "degenerated political pluralism can develop. workers' state". . Some Trotskyists - the Alliance for Workers' Liberty and others - believe that events since 1940 have shown that the Stalinist restoration of capitalism. states have been class systems of exploitation parallel, not superior, to capitalism. Most Trotskyists, however, continued to apply the description "degenerated workers' state" the drive to capitalism. Yet -the USSR, and extended it, calling China, Eastern Europe, and so on, "deformed workers' states".

After the attempted Moscow coup of 19-21 August, some ol these Trotskyists frankly recognised that their theories must be reassessed, others so twisted their description of Workers' Vanguard 27.9.91). events as to try to make it appear that there was an emerging mass socialist movement behind Yeltsin. defending the workers' states"

Is the French socialist weekly Rouge put it (12 September), the attempted coup of 19-21 August 1991 in the USSR posed Vanguard 30.8.91). many questions for all those Marxists who still considered the most of the Trotskyist factions USSR to be a "degenerated workers' state" "We used to believe that from a sharp crisis of these regimes defeat of the coup. would arise forces - significant, at least, if not commanding a majority - capable of opposing the road of a self-managed socialist democracy to that of capitalist restoration. In fact such currents are marginal today.

"We used to think that in spite of the confiscation of power by a parasitic bureaucracy, the chopping block... existence of non-capitalist social relations arising from the revolution of 1917 represented gains in the eyes of the workers, who would mobilise to defend them.

"In fact, it appears not so at all.

Primarily, the workers see in their miserable living standards the expression of a productivity gap which has widened again between not mobilise the workers. the rich Western countries and (Workers' Vanguard 30.8.91.) the Eastern bloc.

*That does not exclude vigorous movements tomorrow of resistance to the consequences of privatisation, but as of now the facts are sufficient to render necessary a critical re-examination of the analysis and of their consequences for practical activity.

Rouge's first comment on coup (5 September) had been:

...No nostalgia! No regrets! We Brezhnevite bureaucrats will shed no tears for the monstrous edifice which combined the ferocious dictatorship of a party-state with the incompetent management of a long revolutionaries, opponents of Stalinism from the start, have "In the coming turmoil a movement of workers' and people's self-organisation can begin to develop, trade unions and other groups can multiply, "Incontestably, all that will take time. A lot of time... the Stalinist abomination.. has destroyed the conquests of October, and the road iS now open to the The strict logic of the "degenerated workers' state" formula should imply. some support for the coup, as the only visible attempt to check or halt far as I know - only one tiny splinter of the Trotskyist movement drew that conclusion clearly. The *Bolshevik agreed that the coup-makers did Spartacist League, assessed the Tendency" a splinter from the not differ fundamentally on economic policy from Gorbachev? coup as an attempt by "a section Some groups evaded this of the rapidly disintegrating question by flatly asserting that Stalinist bureaucracy. to strike the anti-coup movement against the principal forces of represented the start of a "political capitalist restoration. (Quoted in revolution" that would lead not to capitalism but to socialist The Spartacist League itself - a democracy. Thus the "Lambertist" small group, but representing the French weekly Informations fraction of the "Trotskyist" Ouvrieres (21.8.91): spectrum most fervent about "The chaos of the present situation in the USSR marks the remonstrated that the coup bankruptcy of all those, legatees programme "comes down to of the Stalinist bureaucratic perestroika minus glasnost: the system, who have acted in recent introduction of the market but not years to dismantle social property so fast, and shut up. " (Workers" and to deliver the country to the pillage and colonisation of the That assessment - shared by system of private property of the means of production. It, is the would imply opposition to the collapse of all the factions of the coup. But in fact the Spartacist bureaucracy... Gorbachev... League was distressed at the Yanayev and Pavlov... Yeltsin and Shevardnadze...

"August 27 The working "Through the bankruptcy of people of the Soviet Union, and those who want to re-establish indeed the workers of the world. capitalism, the dramatic situation have suffered an unparalleled in the USSR expresses the disaster.. Soviet workers are bankruptcy of capitalism itself..." facing a disaster of catastrophic proportions: every gain for which "All the layers and factions of they, their parents and the bureaucracy have linked their grandparents sacrificed is on the fate to the restoration of capitalism. Between the economic As the crowd of yuppies, programme of Yeltsin, that of students and assorted Russian Gorbachev, and that of Yanayev nationalists, including fascists and and Pavlov, there is not enough priests, gathered at the start of the difference to slide a cigarette coup outside the Russian paper between them... Ponse na call on Moscow Yeltsin's "White "[And yet the coup...] The explanation of this apparent workers to clean out this paradox lies in the impossibility in counterrevolutionary rabble was present conditions in the USSR of in order. Yet the coup plotters did restoring anything like capitalism... because the capitalism of 1991 is to the ll other would-be Trotskyist capitalism of the early 19th exceptions, as we shall see - agony is to the robust adolescent. opposed the coup. They then The capitalism of 1830 was the faced a dilemma: didn't support carrier of industrialisation, that of for the anti-coup movement 1991 only generates mean support for a counter- deindustrialisation... land because revolution which was destroying of the resistance of the workers." the "workers' state" and replacing (Article by D. Gluckstein). it by capitalism? And why did the And after the defeat of the coup "workers" state" have no (28.8.91): defenders but a ragged crew of old "The conditions [for developing diali today than before one maybe not even them, since most coup attempt. Through the openings created by the collapse of the bureaucratic apparatus, the masses have begun to surge... A real workers' revolution is just. beginning... The defence of social property is merged with the vorkers and peasants' fight for survival". (D. Gluckstein). Although Informations Ouvrieres welcomed the anti-coup movement so enthusiastically, it did not specifically oppose the coup. Its issue of 21 August which went to press before the collapse of the coup, expressed no support for resistance to the coup as distinct from resistance to "the bureaucracy" in general. Its nearest thing to a positive slogan was: "Against the dismantling of "The would-be Trotskyists faced dilemma. Didn't support for a counter revolution? And why did the "workers' state" have no defenders but crew of old Brezhnevite whole industries, against poverty and famine, for the defence of the workers' rights and conquests and of social property: one and the same struggle unites the workers of the world.

The other Trotskyist group which did not come out against the coup was the British Socialist Action, which refused to make any comment at all until their irregular magazine appeared in late October or early November. By then, of course, there was no percentage from any viewpoint in supporting Yanayev and his gang. Socialist Action did not enthuse about the coup - "an attempt to put the clock back towards the Brezhnevist past " -but that was basically the same assessment as the Bolshevik Tendency, and Socialist Action made it clear that "the Brezhnevist past" was preferable, for them, to a victory of the pro-capitalist democratic movement in the USSR: "If the Russian Revolution were to fall, that is if capitalism were to be restored.. it would open a period of the most extreme international reaction... any sectarianism would be unforgivable... to currents emerging from the old CPSU who want to defend the socialised base of the USSR."

Socialist Action denounced the Filoche minority in the French LCR (Rouge) as having "passed out of the political framework of Mandel as consed, but Braised the Morning Star ("perspective... entirely correct and justified").

he US Militant had the same TOWN Informations Ouvrieres, but combined with opposition to the coup.

"Soviet workers win great victory by defeating coup, " it headlined (6.9.91). "Working people in the Soviet Union won a giant victory when their resistance toppled the August 19 coup.

"Class conflicts that will sharpen as the crisis deepens will end up in the working class organising a political revolution to sweep away the parasitic social layer that now holds the reins of power in the workers' state.

"As they deepen their resistance they will reach out to struggles around the world and be influenced by revolutionaries and communists - from Malcolm X to the leaders of the Cuban revolution. "

Other headlines included:

"Protest of coup is example of why workers defend nationalised P's imperialism lost id wha war.

Scan page 11

e USSR The collapse of the Stalinist dictatorship has opened up space for political debate. Yet the dominant mood is anti-socialist. Organiser

----- pull-quotes -----

A groups - with two bizarre century what the old man in

support for the anti- coup movement mea

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 517

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →