Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Why campaign will use courts

Socialist Organiser no. 517, 19 March 1992 · scan pp. 9–10 · about 1,328 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

Student unions have had to fight long and hard to defend as much autonomy as they can against Tory attacks. Now the NUS leadership wants to tame NUS mand decent grants and planning to send a ion, try to persuade them ise. If they are definate ten try to persuade them one person, because this in that at least the card i be used. ake copious notes and ill information back to Franklin, NUS officer. I Franklin is a Labour official, the "NUS of the National sation of Labour s. He is not an official S, and has not been I by students to run let this fax shows him sing the drive for a lown On NUS acy in minute detail!

Campaign for racy in NUS was set up eginning of this term by i in Tyne-Tees. It now i students from all over intry. The Campaign fighting to save Winter ence. It will organise in eges, putting maximum e on the NUS leaders to wn. It will mobilise for ng conference, just a. t mobilised for the ency" Conference, and vote down any tial Ruling which says the "Emergency" nce was in order and vote should be revised a two-thirds majority. itself. A National Union of Students, longside its agitation inside the the Campaign for Democracy in NUS is also pursuing legal action against the NUS leadership.

Why? The abolition of Winter Conference would be a big blow to NUS democracy, and deprive the NUS left of its major national platform. It would be a big, possibly decisive, step in transforming NUS from a campaigning union into a bureaucratic student-services and parliamentary-lobbying agency (a transformation which is already well under way in some University student unions).

The NUS leaders have repeatedly fiddled, flouted and overridden the democratic processes within NUS through which the abolition of Winter Conference could be stopped. Once the abolition is an accomplished fact, to reverse it will be a difficult and slow business. Realistically, in the medium term, it will be impossible.

Despite the general bias of the bourgeois courts, so blatant are the NUS leaders' breaches of their own constitution that there is an excellent chance that a court will stop them going ahead with abolition. And if a court does stop them, then it will be some time before they are able to try again.

Marxists are generally against using the bourgeois courts in the internal affairs of the labour movement. The student movement is not the labour movement - NUS is indirectly state-funded, and much of it is a student-services business rather than a trade-union-type body - but we want to keep the courts out there as much as possible, too. Supporters of Socialist Organiser and the Alliance for Workers' Liberty argue for the main focus on the campaign to be agitation inside the student unions, and against any reliance on the courts.

However, the principle of not using the courts can not be the absolute, always-overriding principle. Other principles have weight, too! INTO THE 1990g We fight to get disputes settled within the labour movement (or the student movement) rather than by the courts because we value the independence and democracy of the movement. To let that independence be extinguished, and socialists be sidelined, by bureaucratic dirty tricks, without using every means available to resist, is turning the principle into nonsense.

It is no part of Marxist principle to be gallant losers. We are against "It is no part of Marxist principle to be gallant losers. We are against violence - but we will use violence rather than submit quietly to a military coup. We are against using the courts - but rather use the courts than quietly abandon the struggle.

violence - but we will use violence rather than submit quietly to a military coup. We are against using the courts - but rather use the courts than quietly abandon the struggle.

Yes, often using the courts is often counter-productive. Often, probably usually, when leftists appeal to the courts on issues within the labour movement, the politics of the appeal are opportunist - putting calculated short-term gain (maybe falsely calculated at that) above longterm interests.

Socialist Organiser's editors rejected the advice we had from many on the Labour left to take the Labour NEC to court when they banned our paper in 1990. We criticised Militant's repeated use of the courts after 1982 to try to stop themselves being purged from the Labour Party, and their recourse to the courts in 1986 to try to get John Macreadie installed as general secretary of the civil service union Why was the use of the courts wrong in those cases, and others like them, and why is the current issue in NUS different? We can tabulate the arguments which condemn use of the courts, and check off the current case against them.

Often the legal action contradicts, detracts, or diverts from political campaigning and mobilisation within the movement, by taking decisions out of the movement - where the democratic channels, though imperfect, have not been exhausted - and in to the courts, or by alienating members who sympathise on the issue but resent the use of the counts.

Or the courts are unlikely to find in our favour. Or, if they do find in our favour, their ruling can do nothing decisive against what we find objectionable, because it can not change an adverse balance of political forces in the movement.

Or, if the court ruling might help us, still, the financial cost of going to court is so huge that money-raising to meet it will inevitably divert from and undermine campaigning within the movement, to a degree which outweighs any likely advantage.

Or, the costs of legal action, in giving the courts and judges an opportunity to mess around and interfere in a movement which had previously kept some robust independence, are so great as to outweigh any short-term gains.

Check off the current case against this list of objections: none of them apply. The democratic processes inside NUS are being pursued to the full, but effectively overridden by an entrenched leadership. The issue is so sharply and narrowly defined that it will prevent a difficult-to-reverse shift in the balance of forces in the movement; the financial cost will not be crippling.

The NUS is already so enmeshed with the state that it makes no sense to object to legal action as a major weakening of its independence. The court action can not override or harm NUS democracy, but may well help preserve it. And the legal action plainly is not undermining the direct political campaign in the student unions.

In the run-up to the Emergency Conference, Left Unity and the Campaign for Democracy in NUS were not standing aside from the mobilisation of delegates, and telling students to look to the courts; they were campaigning to such • good effect that a conference specially rigged up for the purpose by the NUS leaders failed to repeat the two-thirds majority that they got on the "re-vote" at the Winter Conference.

That is why support for the Campaign for Democracy in NUS, and for its willingness to use the courts, is so strong across a very broad range of student union activists.

die NES-leaders' clamm -abolition of Wine Contertaice gode tre-th* maicuity at tre Emergent a merence sullergda-big tback at the - te wiser commitee seeli -Thursdav 12 Under the Need constipzios makes tae initiai Istetten ine cect cOtt Be role, thoth i could e lenged at Spon Conference.

theRE has- three-tw ¡yore ol haprime support rectioh; bal by the the committee meeting finished at 2am, they were so unsure of their ground that they made no official decision, and instead referred the issue for a 'Presidential Ruling"

Scan page 10

Jani

----- pull-quotes -----

TUE TORIES deal De N cist Wer AnTSE ¡TU- tAll OCIALIS

OUR NioN

a court ruling in our favour is likely; STOP BAKER STOP DUSTERS

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 517

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →