Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Forward То the Маякет Есоио

Socialist Organiser no. 517, 19 March 1992 · scan p. 7 · about 731 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

contradictions, ones which are completely unknown to us. We are learning at first hand the meaning of hyper-inflation, the collapse of production, and economic dependency. In reality we are changing into an ordinary der wipine diference that in the majority of such countries people have become accustomed to these problems and have learnt to cope - albeit with difficulty - with them, whereas we are completely unadapted to our new situation and, above all, the majority of us were reckoning on something completely different.

The well-known Moscow journalist Anatoly Baranbov has written: "You have the impression that the country is governed by professors who have specialised in describing the horrors of capitalism and who Boris Kagarlitsky speaks in Los Angeles daddies in the world with sufficient capital revive our economy."

unpleasant aspects result from "various mistakes" or from "incompetence" on the part of this or that leader.

In fact, the situation is much more tragic. The course being followed in pursuit of the creation of a market-capitalist model of the economy which has been chosen not only by the leadership in Russia but also by ractically all the states of the ormer Eastern Bloc - this course cannot, in general, lead these countries to economic growth and prosperity.

You can spend hours talking about the success of Western demanded to the centuries in Lee cousines order to form - at a price of scarcely conceivable hardships and upheavals - a system of more or less civilised market relations on a capitalist basis, in order to rear the contemporary industrialist, and in order to guarantee social stability.

The majority of other capitalist countries of Asia, Africa and Latin America, which lagged behinder the a develone or penina in tneir development lounder in a whirlpool ol poverty and social cataclysms.

And there is no point in fooling oneself with fancy fairy tales about the "South Korean miracle" brought about by intelligent bureaucrats with the assistance of Western loans and completely traditional "five-year plans". There is not a sufficiently large number of sugar-daddies in the world with sufficient capital to revive our economy.

But the main point is that those who have free capital at their disposal have totally different ideas. Not that they are particularly 1ll-willed towards us. it is simply that they have completely different tasks and priorities. The recently lashionable discussions about "democratic privatisations" or "privatisation to the benefit of the labour collective" are utterly devoid of content. Factories which are handed over to the workforce without a system of supply and sale having been established and without reliable sources of capital investments will end up in a lamentable situation.

The best that we can expect if marked out dy ahe liberals is that of "joining up with the majority", which suffers from hunger, backwardness, civil wars and dependency. there will be Sooner or later, the dream of Western prosperity will, of course, become reality. But not for all. Those who promised us abundance will indeed achieve it. For themselves. The hardships of the country will turn out to be hardships tor only a part of the country's citizens.

Somebody will still live in Moscow, just as somebody will still live in Paris (but perhaps such people will simply live in Paris, and Moscow). For this to occur, the majority will have to live in the most backward and poverty-stricken countries of the Third world.

Already today the industrial basis of the country is seriously undermined. Instead of movement towards the market, we have the destruction of the basic economic links between enterprises. Whilst newspapers argue about who to transfer property to, production is becoming so uncontrollable thai there will soon be nothing left to privatise.

Any hope of strengthening democracy in such a situation is nonsensical. There cannot be political equality of rights and political freedom in a country of the hungry where one part of the population plunders the other, revenge, preparing a bloodbath for the rich.

The rulers of Russia can call themselves democrats as much as they want, but the very logic of their policies is inevitably and unavoidably leading the country to a brutal authoritarian dictatorship.

Boris Kagarlitsky is author of The Thinking Reed, Dialectics of Change, and Beyond Perestroika. He was a political prisoner under Brezhnev. (Translated and from Pravda)

----- pull-quotes -----

DARI organizat

"Production is becoming so uncontrollable

nothing left to privatise."

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 517

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →