Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Why Glasgow girls carry knives

Socialist Organiser no. 517, 19 March 1992 · scan pp. 6–7 · about 957 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

for Labour rally. Well, I suppose we should invite Dav Nellist, a well-known membel of SocialistsNot Particularly fi Labour.

At this month's meeting somebody, asks about the Socialists for Labour rally. Er 10, afraid it's off. Why? Well none of the left MPs will shar a platform with Nellist.

And then the finale: a speaker gravely warns the meeting that February's decision to support Dave Nellist must be kept secret, since toe suicide openly for would be Dave Nellist: to in secret? WOMEN'S EYE A were two well- few months ago there publicised legal cases running concurrently in Edinburgh and Glasgow. They were both cases involving violence but couldn't have been more different.

The Glasgow case involved the fatal stabbing of a teenage girl by a fellow pupil in the school playground. The Edinburgh case involved the horrifically violent rape and attempted murder of a young woman of a similar age.

The story which won most space on the front pages was the playground murder. When the trials wound up and the sentencing was done, the sentences seemed as disparate as the coverage given to the cases by the media.

A 15 year old schoolgirl was detained indefinitely for the stabbing of a fellow pupil, and the rapist was given a 16 year sentence which most probably will not be served in full.

But I don't want to go over the familiar ground regarding the hypocritical leniency of the legal system when it comes to crimes against women by men, where often severe jail sentences are seen as a solution to the attitudes which bring men to rape women. What made an impression on me was how the playground killing was generally seen to be so much more shocking than any other crime.

Knife attacks are nothing new to Glasgow, but this case of violence did not fit into the stereotypes of male on female or adult on child violence. This violence involved two young women.

At first glance it may seem difficult to imagine what provokes a teenager to take a knife to school with the purpose of threatening a fellow pupil. Far from being unusual, it is reputedly quite common practice for teenagers to carry weapons.

Recent studies have found that many teenagers now carry weapons in order to defend themselves. With violent crimes committed by adult men on children soaring above many other crimes, many young people perceive a need for self-defence and the carrying of weapons is not, for them, an aggressive act.

The same research found that a large percentage of the girls and young women taking part were, in the space of their research being carried out, victims of a violent/sexual crime committed by a man, ranging from rape to "flashing".

crimes which not conform to stereotypical pattern as all the more serious."

Many of these young women did not report these crimes and this was not only because of the obvious reasons of not being taken seriously but because they did not want to lose any of the freedoms their parents granted them. Determined not to become imprisoned by the violent society we live in, they look to themselves.

When you see young women growing up in a society which seems intent on making them victims, a society where every day we hear more reports of vicious attacks on women, both of a physical and economic nature, the relation between this state of affairs and the nature of capitalist society becomes all the more clear.

But, on the other hand, it's all too easy to create a response which makes a theory of the hostility which many women quite rightly feel towards men, a theory which divides society solely along lines of sex and letting capitalism off the hook.

Capitalist society judges crimes which do not conform to a stereotypical pattern as all the more serious, so you get women who murder their husbands getting more severely punished than men who murder their wives. The socialist society we struggle for will not bring overnight end to the violence which women are subjected to.

Only socialism will liberate both men and women from sexual stereotypes and when we win, the struggle for the emancipation of the working class I, for one, will feel that the world will be safer for

Scan page 7

madness out the economic catastrophe facing the workers of the ex-USSR "ven quite recently I would have found it difficult to mimagine that I would wnte an article for Pravda. Two years ago Pravda would not have printed anything by me under any circumstances, and one year ago I would hardly have agreed to an article of mine being published in this paper.

changed, somech so much has mixed up and confused, that the events of the period of "early perestroika" are already regarded as belonging to history, as "the Regents or on pas ancient affairs of davs long past. the times"

Society has come up against completely new problems and now, after declaring themselves democrats, have set about creating such horrors"

People are showing a miraculous amount of patience in the hope that the promised prosperity of the market is not far off, and that only modest exertions are required in order to reach the sacred goal described in such picturesque terms by liberal writers. Many still see visions of mountains of cheap imported goods spilling over the shelves in shops.

And even those who today criticise the government (and often even call themselves leftwing not intrequently continue to believe in the market utopias "proving" that in general the course being followed is the correct one, and that all "There is not a Organiser

----- pull-quotes -----

"Capitalist society judges

in Boris Kagarlitsky

sufficiently large number of sugar

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 517

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →