Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Anti-Toryism is not enough in every constituency

Socialist Organiser no. 517, 19 March 1992 · scan pp. 3–4 · about 1,224 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

The labour movement's fight to rebuild the NHS demands fighting for a Labour Government. Photo: Stefano Cagnoni Laurel was dying. The he great comedian Stan said: "How are you?"

"As you'd expect" he replied.

"but I'd rather be skiing" Ah" liked to ski, did you? you she said sympathetically, Stan Laurel replied, , "T've never skied in my lite. Stupid business.

But I'd rather be skiing"

In fact Laurel borrowed the joke from W C Fields, who.having made jokes all his professional life about how much he hated a certain city -said on his death-bed, "Id rather be in Philadelphia" In the spirit of Fields and Laurel, a large part of the left could truthfully reply to the question how they feel about voting Labour on 9 April: I'd rather be skiing, .

Philadelphia! Some might say: I'd rather be dead!

Take socialist, the paper of the Socialist Movement. The last conference of the Socialist Movement decided by a democratic majority that it would advocate a vote for Labour in every constituency at the General Election. But the Socialist Movement is not a democratic organisation. Its paper is run by a clique who cannot see why a majority at the conference of the movement which finances and circulates the paper should have authority for gentry such as they.

Advisory Editorial Board Graham Basha vadimin Derer Henrystagleton Latin heria (Laborank Black SectionsIR Dorothy MaCErN ner Marino boney Uroy John Nicholson Peter latchell d cross section of the who are opposed to the pur Party's witch-hunt ist Socialist Organiser.

as expressed in articles the responsibility of the ors and not of the sory Editorial Board.

SIRFNA

Vote Labour? They would rather be in the bourgeois Scottish National Party! They would rather back "independent"

ocialists like Dave Nellist, Terry 'ields, and Tommy Sheridan -who are not, untortunately, independent of the Militant organisation.

heir feeling of revulsion at the Knockite Labour Party is understandable. It does them credit. We share it wholeheartedly.

It is their political thinking we have difficulty following. Labour is the only possible alternative to the Tories based on the working-class movement. That is the only serious argument for socialists voting Labour in this election. It is not. and cannot be, compatible with advocating a partial Labour vote.

If you say, *vote Labour sometimes", then the question is begged: why? Sheer catch-penny in with the politically conscious opportunism - the desire to keep workers who will be voting NUPE says!

Labour - is the only possible answer, the answer of Socialist Worker, for example. It is not serious politics. It is the same approach, defining politics by public relations, that the Kinnockites pursue.

Socialist tries to get around its difficulties by focusing on that good old standby of all those on the left who want to evade clarity: general anti-Toryism. But, comrades, the basic reason why you gag on the idea of voting Labour everywhere is that the Kinnockites are politically very close to the Tories.

Vague anti-Toryism dissolves all real politics. The Tories must be kicked out and replaced by a Labour Government, a trade union movement. It is, in government of the labour and present circumstances, only by doing this that the Tory hegemony established over 13 years can be shattered and dispelled; it is only by way of this political victory that the labour movement will begin to get its confidence back and socialist. A new voice for the left irresponsible.

begin to throw off the paralysis which long Tory rule and the seemingly endless succession of Tory victories has laid on the working class.

For that reason - though the regrowth of labour movement confidence and militancy may take a long time: we can not know - a Labour victory would be a working class victory, a victory for the working-class movement, despite Kinnock's pink-Tory politics and despite Kinnock's declared intention of keeping most of the Tory anti-union laws on the statute book.

With Labour in power, pressure for change will build up, even from the trade union bosses whose backing has allowed Kinnock to smash the Labour Party left over recent years.

Those are the political reasons for voting. Labour, the reasons which make sense in terms of the development of the mass labour movement from where it is now to a better condition. The promotion of that development is an irreplaceable core concern of socialists who base themselves on the working class. Otherwise all we have is vague, speculative, limp, gripless, perspectiveless anti-lory splutterings, combined with giving up on the political struggle as circumstances pose it for us now.

You have the flaccid hope that after the election there will be a Labour Government at Westminster. On the other hand, you may want to vote Tartanrory with a lettist face for the moment) in Scotland, or for the Stalinoid sect Militant in Liverpool, Glasgow, or Coventry!

Indeed, the anti-Lory poster published by socialist is so vague that it could reasonably be construed as advocating a Liberal-Democratic tactical vote in some constituencies - as is ace eX- CP Democratic LeSS, and, very surprisingly, the editor of New Left Review. Most of the people who put the socialisi package together will not mean that, but it is typical of the whole "public relations" style that you in Street London he we let Or BanSru can not be sure that there not some of them who may mean it after all.

In so far as there are arguments in the circles around socialist for all this rudderless picking and choosing, they are about as well thought out as the conclusions they reach. Proportional representation, they tell you, is coming, and it will change everything - as if you can determine what to do now by calculations about a different situation in the future, or, more crazily, determine your tactics for one situation by what might be possible or appropriate for another, future, situation.

Voting SNP in Scotland is simply incompatible with fighting for a Labour Government, the goal without which voting Labour anywhere makes little sense. Backing a few independent socialist candidates might not be, all other things being equal. Arguments about the need to back "good socialists" like Dave Nellist, Terry Fields, and Tommy Sheridan might make sense - if they were not members or close associates of Militant, which is structured like a Stalinist sect and has for decades had Stalinoid politics (enthusiastically backing the Stalinist empire's "Vietnam war"

Turn to page 4 atuh Lamincwoni oristkiordade.

Karl Marx PEDUn Organiser PDLBws2I kondom SE15 4NA Newvsw esk: 1071H669 7965 Zaresf watewornreports wVonday Leo tom JohnıU Mahony bus edloy Deplicn ens Ltd PO Box 823 London SE15 4NA Printed by Tridant Press, Edenbridge Retis teredes newsp d dLk PosiOhficel and arta osena draanisen butelmse sared

Scan page 4

bour NEC dumps 1987's most successfu Lol Duffy speaks out against one-faction part Organiser BRITISH AEROSPACE In 1987 Lol Duffy stood as abourísilen lamentary Candidate in Wallasey. appu sivote increases n 39ro, and fory Minister LyndalChalkers me ho mty was reduced from 6,708 services and many other areas. and I'm not going to Only yes-men

----- pull-quotes -----

Members of the Advisory nittee are drawn from a

BEFORE PROFIT

DAY JUSTICE FOR

socialist of Tory politias Who'S doing Thatcher's Who'

The emapcipa ton of thet «dupany dose i aso ta emapearg all human wemnos

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 517

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →