Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Stalin's great crime abroad

Socialist Organiser no. 516, 13 February 1992 · scan p. 12 · about 1,681 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 12

TIDE Matgamna n Spain in July 1936 the so-called "Popular Front", a loose coalition of left and not-so-left parties, won the general election. Spanish society was sharply polarised already, five years after the dismissal of the king and the declaration of a Republic. Now it flew apart. The army, airforce and navy mutinied, led by a junta of Fascist generals, the most important of whom turned out to be Francisco Franco, an army general.

The weak-kneed leaders of the Popular Front were at first inclined to surrender to them. But then the Spanish working class took a stand. They broke open the arsenals in cities like Madrid and Barcelona, disarmed the reactionaries, and erected barricades to defend themselves and their Republic against the advancing fascist armies. "No Pasaran!" they shouted - they shall not pass!

They did not pass. The fascist advances were halted, amidst bitter fighting. The bourgeoisie, the powerful Catholic church, and much of the petit-bourgeoisie rallied solidly around the fascist armies; only their "shadow" - an individual here and there — remained in the Republican-controlled areas, as Trotsky pictured it at the time.

This meant that half of Spain was in the hands of the working class and their peasant allies — armed, mobilised, the undisputed power! Fascism and right-wing authoritarian governments had been spreading throughout Europe like a plague: Italy, Germany, Hungary, Poland, Austria (where the Vienna workers had fought on the barricades in 1934, and lost). Its advance was stopped now in Spain. The tide could be turned!

If the workers and peasants had done what was done in Russia after 1917, then the fascist armies would have fallen apart; then peasant soldiers would have been won over to a programme of agrarian revolution; Franco's Moorish troops, from Spanish colonial Morocco, would have been won over had the Spanish Republic liberated Morocco. The socialist revolution would have spread north, to France and beyond, into Germany.

And the workers and peasants already had control of the Republican areas! But, tragically, they did not consolidate but lost that power, and they were then overrun by the fascists. There were two reasons for this: the political confusion and ineptitude of the various groupings on the left, and the activities in Spain of gangster Stalinism.

The biggest revolutionary force in Spain was the anarchist trade union movement, the CNT. Not believing in the legitimacy of any state, the revolutionary anarchists, some of whom, like the famous Durutti, led the armed resistance to Franco, refused to build a working class state. The less revolutionary anarchists became convinced that some state was after all necessary if the fascists were to be beaten and backed the popular front government! Some of these "anarchists" became ministers in it, and stayed ministers even when the government turned on their comrades!

The best big left group, the POUM, joined the Republican government in Catalonia (around Barcelona) in conditions where they had responsibility but no control, thus crippling themselves.

This confusion alone might well have ruined the Spanish revolution. The activities of the Stalinists made ruin a certainty.

A smallish party in 1936, the Spanish Communist Party (PCE) grew because of its policies and because the Republic, undermined by the subtle hostility of countries like Britain, and facing the armed intervention of Fascist chief General (centre) flanked by Cavalcanti German and Italian fascist armies and aircraft on the side of the fascists, came to depend on Stalin's Russia for arms and equipment (for which it paid in gold). The PCE was the party of the USSR.

Stalinists poured into Spain; they organised international support, and sent international brigades of soldiers to fight for the Republic; and they sent in legions of Stalin's secret police, the GPU, to take control in the Republican areas.

Their political "line" was that socialism must wait. This was no socialist revolution but the "defence of - bourgeois -democracy". What Stalin was really up to was trying to convince the European bourgeoisie that they did not need fascism to control the working class: Stalin would do it for them, in return for certain concessions.

With this policy, the Stalinists became the substitute for the shadow-like bourgeoisie, most of whom were physically in Franco's camp, defending their interests. They did the work in the Republican areas which the fascists did in theirs! They drove peasants off the land they seized, and beat down the revolutionary workers, and those anarchists, POUMists and Trotskyists who championed their interests.

Soon there was a Stalinist reign of terror in the Republic, modelled on what was going on in Russia. Socialists like POUM leader Andres Nin were kidnapped, tortured and killed in the GPU's Spanish prisons. The working class was held in an iron - Stalinist - grip. The revolution was ruined.

The arteries of the revolution thus drained from within the Republic, the Republic, ruled by the Stalinists in the name of the bourgeoisie, could not even defend itself. The peasants and soldiers in the fascist-held areas did not revolt. The military balance tipped against the Republic. The fascists overran Spain, clinching their victory in March 1939, six months before the outbreak of World War 2 - which could perhaps have been averted by a socialist victory in Spain.

After the destruction of the Russian revolution itself, what they did in Spain is the single greatest crime of the Stalin gang.

For us today the important thing to tell the labour movement, and young people interested in socialism, is that the working class in Spain did revolt, did save the Republic in 1936 and '37, did seize control of society in Republican Spain, and could have made a socialist revolution if it had not been betrayed by the Stalinists within its own ranks.

*The Spanish Civil War: the view from the left" (Revolutionary History, Vol 4, Nos. 1 & 2) is a priceless dossier of pamphlets, memoirs and biographies mainly written in the '30s, about the defeated Spanish Revolution.

"From the left" means, here, from people to the left of the PCE. In fact, this covers a very wide spectrum indeed.

Trotsky, looking back just before he died, pointed out that compared with the full-blown Stalinism of the mid-'30s, even the right wing of the old Bolshevik Party. Bukharin, etc., whom Trotsky considered pro-capitalist in the 1920s, were on the left. So it was in Spain, with the "right wing communist" followers of Bukharin and Brandler. At the end, the Stalinists in Spain were at the extreme right wing of bourgeois politics; even some of the vague socialists and left liberals who had formed the early governments in Republican Spain were, as Trotsky pointed out, to their left.

"The Stalinists could do what they did because characteristics would no alone have allowed then to win. The mistakes of the left - in the sense used in this book's title -were an essential part of For that reason, l teel this volume is somewhat ill-conceived. For understanding the Spanish Revolution the differences within the left are far more important than their common "leftism" vis-a-vis the Stalinists.

Suppose the Russian right had won in 1917-1918, then the impulse to defend and vindicate "the left" against their murderers would be honourable and understandable. And yet for understanding how the right came to triumph and for learning lessons for the future, the differences within the left between, say, the Kamenev-Stalin wing of Bolshevism in April 1917 and Trotsky and Lenin then would be far more important than their common "leftism". As Marx analysed and criticised the various "left" groups which operated in Paris in 1848 and '49, and on that criticism laid the foundation for a new left-wing movement in the future, so we would have to relate to 1917, had things gone against us.

And so too, we must relate to Spain.

The Stalinists could do what they did because they were a powerful, rich, unscrupulous, military-police-led organisation. But those characteristics would not alone have allowed them to win. The mistakes of the left - in the sense used in this book's title - were an essential part of their victory - and of the victory of fascism.

And not just the mistakes they made after July 1936. Some of the decisive mistakes were made earlier. The Stalinist party gained much of its strength because it won over the bulk of the Socialist Party's youth in 1934.

They were given a clear field to do this because the Spanish Trotskyists felt themselves too pure to join the Socialist Party, as Trotsky urged them to. This was, they felt, the party of the "traitor socialists" , who had to be fought, the party of the International to which belonged "the murderers of Rosa Luxemburg", as indeed it was.

The Marxists had broken with them long ago and that was that. Independence was now a principle. Erecting such "principle" into an icon outside of time and circumstances, confusing political independence with formal organisational independence, they abstained from the real politics of this movement. The Stalinists gained, and what they gained was turned to deadly use against the Spanish working class, including the Trotskyists.

It is in the analysis of such stages on the road to the victory, first of Stalinism in Spain, and then of fascism, that precepts for revolutionary practice now will be found.

This work, done at the time by Trotsky, can be found in the Pathfinder Press volume, Leon Trotsky on the Spanish Revolution. Some of the material in "The Spanish Civil War: the view from the left" expounds Trotsky's point of view. The justification for such a collection is that it allows those who want to study it, clearly to know, directly, and compare the nuances on the left, and this is no small advantage.

• "The Spanish Civil War: the view from the left", Revolutionary History, Volume 4, Nos. 1 & 2, £12.95. Order from 111, Riverside Close, Mount Pleasant Hill, London ES 9SS.

----- pull-quotes -----

they were a powerful, rich, unscrupulous, military-police-led organisation. But those

their victory - and of the victory of fascism. "

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 516

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →