Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Where now for the left in the unions?

Socialist Organiser no. 516, 13 February 1992 · scan pp. 10–11 · about 2,523 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Saltley Gates Bi i h atmosphere would not affect their determination. pickets when the time came, arresting them by the following week, in an amazing wave of solidarity.

Committee of the AEUW call for a strike, 40,000 Arthur Scargill, at that time a minor local leader downed tools on the Thursday. On that morning, thousands on the picket line. It was nothing less gates. A roar passed down the streets outside as Hundreds of workers from Fort Dunlop marched on the depot chanting 'Close the gates! Close the line breakers, turned many away. The first days gates!' On hearing that the gates were closed they brought many frustrations. Messages of support changed their chant to 'Open the gates! Open the from other areas of the NUM were received, but outside the gates, claimed the Saltley Gate closure to be a major victory for the working class in this country. And despite TUC codes of conduct and mass pickets by trade union and Labour leaders, flying pickets were firmly established at Saltley in Sheila Cohen, editor Trade Union News think it's important for socialists in the unions not to get too carried away with internal union politics, in terms of trying to win positions on national union executives, and trying to put resolutions through conferences.

In the workshop on trade union bureaucracy, we discussed how, through the activities of many "he picket of Saltley Gate in February of 1972 was an event of historical importance for the British trade union movement.

Like virtually all innovations of working class struggle, the flying mass pickets of the miners' strike, of which Saltley was the most dramatic, came from rank and file initiative.

The major core of the pickets from the Yorkshire Area were under the leadership of The first few days brought small numbers of miners from other areas. The determination of the pickets, numbering a few hundred at that time, to stop the lorries taking coke out of the depot, soon captivated the imagination of both the miners and other trade unionists.

Generally, they were unsuccessful in physically preventing seab lorries getting across. But the demonstration of mass solidarity by the pickets and the implicit consequences for future picket promises of more pickets never materialised. A trainload of Scots miners was reported to have been cancelled by their officials.

The Yorkshire pickets were billetted in Birmingham through local trade unionists and those unable to find a bed often slept on the floor of the university student unions.

Many meetings were organised at workplace:

with shop stewards, where rank and file miner:

explained the reasons and the need of their ner tactic of the mass picket.

Talking with student revolutionaries dedicated left wingers in the T&G and the ABU, Jones and Scanlon got elected and left-wing stewards sat back and thought that everything would be alright now.

Now we've got a left executive in the T&G which doesn't seem to make a lot of difference to members on the ground. The left in the unions isn't in a particularly healthy The union Broad Left organisations, in many cases, are extremely mysterious. We should ask: what the hell's going on here? We should open them up.

Of course, there are much healthier left currents in the unions.

A lot of work should be devoted to supporting those and getting membership involvement in them.

The activists in the trade unions, perhaps, particularly in the industrial arena, who are determined to fight from a total gut class standpoint, are the crucial elements in the trade union movement for socialists to discuss with. I say 'discuss with, advisedly.

Many people on the left see politics as rather romantic, out there, and they are not interested in basic trade union issues.

In fact, basic trade union issues who do post-'68 generation, the miners were warm in friendship but bemused at their refusal to unite inside the left of the Labour Party.

Condescendingly the student revolutionaries explained the obsolescence of the Labour Party and in more drunken moments some talked abc guerrilla warfare to the further bemusement of the miners.

But after the first week of the mass picket, was clear that the police were growing in confidence in dealing with the picket lines. In between the confrontations the police turned round and chatted to the pickets and offered them Polos.

The police on the lines were replaced at frequent intervals so that the convivial. 1972 they clanged shut.

are essential in getting towards an awareness of socialism. What really projects workers into an awareness of what society is all about, is struggle.

I don't want to sound like the SWP. But time and time again, relatively conservative workers are brought by struggle to see society in a completely different way.

You saw it in the Wapping print workers, probably the most rightwing, racist bunch of workers you could come across. They actually saw the police in action on that picket line, and some of them have had a rather different attitude And it didn't stop the police laying into the dozen, and snatching their leaders.

If the miners were to be successful it was clear by the weekend that they needed drastic reinforcements. And it was to come in the Responding to the Birmingham East District the workers of Birmingham turned up in their than a festival of solidarity.

The Chief Constable of Birmingham, seeing the situation was impossible, agreed to close the And still the trade unionists poured in.

gates!' wanting the moment of victory to be relived in their presence.

Arthur Scargill, addressing the assembled thousands from the roof of a dilapidated toilet declarations of abhorence and intimidation of the arsenal of the British working class movement. Peter Radcliff towards the police than before.

It's very, very important to have some sort of vehicle being run by socialists in the trade unions that can get a grip on the insights that are experienced by workers in struggle, to structure them into some sort of ongoing awareness.

For a short time in the late '80s, there was an organisation called "Solidarity Network' which, unfortunately, appears to have drifted by the wayside. It was set up by rank and file strikers to keep ex-strikers together so that they could continue to discuss the lessons of their dispute; and to get people whose lives had been changed by a dispute — it does change people's lives — to continue in that context.

I feel there is an immensely greater potential in the workplace "Activists in the unions who are prepared to fight from a total gut class standpoint the crucial elements." among ordinary, trade union members for participation in the union than is normally recognised. I did some research about trade union organisation and what struck me was that, even in the most apparently apathetic local trade union organisations, like a NUPE hospital organisation, the branch secretary would walk around the hospitals and be besieged by members coming up to him, saying this has happened to me, that has happened to me, what can you do about it?

It's not true that people are apathetic, thạt they're passive, that they're not interested. That's the whole essence of trade unionism:

people come up against problems, because of the class position they're in.

I think that that potential for participation has got to be taken up at a grassroots level.

That can be very difficult. I belong to an NUJ chapel which is supposed to be a good strong chapel, but we can't have workplace meetings if there's no issue around because people can*t be bothered to come to them. I'm sure a lot of us face that problem.

I think it's very important to get workers together at workplace trade union meetings and discuss everyday concerns whenever possible.

We must find out what's actually happening in the workplace, what people are bothered about. We must fight to have workplace trade union meetings.

-I'm not a great one for legislation on trade union matters, but I think the Labour Party should be fighting for guaranteed time for workplace trade union meetings.

Thope Trade Union News can act as a mechanism for promoting discussion and debate in the unions.

The downturn can give us the opportunity to look at strategies so that when there is an upturn, there might be a few more political ideas around in the rank and file leadership about where to go from here.

Sheila Cohen and Jim Denham were taking part in a roundtable on Where now for the left in the unions?" at the recent AWL Industrial School. NUT Executive member Andy Dixon's contribution will appear next week.

Scan page 11

Good, old-fashioned trade unionism: Bromsborough CWS workers occupy in defence of jobs. Photo: Paul Herrmann I Denham for the Alliance Jim for The trade union movement is in a pretty bad state. It's had a battering since 1979. TUC membership has gone down to 8 million from over 12 million in 1979.

*The left in the trade union movement is in a hell of a mess.

"Take the Engineering Gazette. This is the remnants of a oncepowerful broad left in the AEU. It couldn't even get its act together to campaign for a "No" vote in the merger with the EETPU.

"it can scarcely be exaggerated what a disaster that amalgamation is likely to be. The Engineering Gazette did announce that they were opposed to it for about two weeks in November. Then they dropped it, mainly because their leading light, an ex-Stalinist called Jimmie Airlie, voted in favour of it at the AEU National Executive.

"In the CPSA, the Militant tendency have a long history of considerable power and influence. They've actually got the Deputy General Secretary, a fellow called John Macreadie, but he behaves just like any other union JUST bureaucrat. "You'd never know that he is supposed to be a revolutionary socialist. He abuses his position to attack, in a thoroughly sectarian way, other sections of the left.

*The NALGO Broad Left has been a madhouse for years now. The leadership varies from year to year between the SWP and the "It's the SWP in charge at the moment. They use the Broad Left for SWP rallies, inviting Chris Harman to come along to talk to them about the class nature of the Soviet Union and how important it is to have a state capitalist analysis in the NALGO Broad Left.

"Friedrich Engels once said about a sectarian organisation which claimed to be Marxist at the end of the last century, that the best service they could do the working class, would be to wind themselves up and dissolve. To be honest, we can say that about most of the organisations of the left which are active in the trade unions.

*That sounds like quite a sectarian thing to say. But that's a misunderstanding of what "sectarianism' means. Arguing your case forcefully, even aggressively, may be a bad thing to do in and of itself, but it is not sectarian.

"Marx described sectarianism as little group, of your own sect, in putting the interests of your own front of those of the class as a 1256 LA whole. That's what sectarianism is. And in that sense groups like the SWP and the Militant are sectarian, in the classic, literal sense that Marx meant it.

"Almost as bad can be • the professional, "non-sectarian" sectarians who hang about on the periphery or the fringes of the SWP or other left groups and, all too often, dominate trades councils and turn them into rumps and talking shops. "They'll take grand stances on Ireland, Palestine, gay rights, abortion - I'm not saying that 'There is a crying need for a non-sectarian rank and file movement." those issues aren't important, but the left always wins because there's no-one else there except for the left.

"They'd lose the vote on these issues if it was a representative meeting, if manual workers from the industrial unions were coming along. Instead, the trades council is a talking shop for the left sects and their hangers-on.

There is a vacuum on the left. Whenever we have the opportunity in the trade union movement to put forward our ideas we've actually got a tremendous response from serious, non-aligned working class people. he's got a nice guy image, his Man at C&A image - Major actually has the same poisonous anti-working class venom running through his veins that Thatcher had. He's just a bit more polite about it, puts a bit more of a human face on it. "Sometimes the Tories' venom against the working class is such that I think they don't know what lies in their own best interests. They're even proposing now to do away with the Bridlington Agreement, for God's sake, something that has been used to police the working class and to make life easier for the bosses. Such is the Tories' hatred of the unions that they are even proposing to do away with that.

"If Labour get in there will be a oriet honeymoon period, but think that a lot of workers' self-confidence is going to be boosted. There are going to be major struggles because a lot of expectations that workers , have in a Labour government will be disappointed. You can almost guarantee that some sort of incomes policy, of wage restraint is going brought in. I foresee very big struggles over that in which sections of the left will cop out, as they did last time under the Social Contract.

"The Social Contract was sold to the working class on the basis of the support of people like Jones and Scanlon, great heroes of the left. It wasn't the right wing which sold us Organiser hate Communists around here because they're all in the gaffer's pocket."

"It's a very odd form of anti-communism, but it was literally true. The CP was in the gaffer's pocket, and the reason for it was that British Leyland had been nationalised and, from the point of view of the Stalinists in the Communist Party at that time, that meant that it was something qualitatively better than private industry, even verging on socialism.

*From their bureaucratic stand= point, it meant that the plant had to be made to work, had to be made to seem superior to private industry, under the old private owners.

"That was their conception of politics and the reason they sold out struggles. You only ever saw the convenor when you had a 'downer' which was a short strike, and he came and shouted at you to go back to work.

"That wasn't because he was corrupt. It was because his politics were so limited, his conception of socialism so bureaucratic, that stopping strikes was what he thought was the correct and responsible thing to do.

"i think our conception of socialism is a very different one. It can be summed up in the words of Karl Marx, "the creation of socialism has to be the act of the working class emancipating itself"

PROBLEMS

----- pull-quotes -----

Those not learn fre history are condemned repeat it

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 516

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →