Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

A film with a hole

Socialist Organiser no. 515, 6 February 1992 · scan pp. 13–14 · about 1,248 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 13

A Brave New World Black Robe Black Robe is National lovely scenery, shame about the plot. Actually, the film has no plot, and there are no real characters either. Actors appear and say their lines, but nothing resonates; there's no drama.

Set in Canada in 1634, the film follows the hazardous, 1500-mile canoe journey of a Jesuit priest, Father Laforgue, from Quebec to a mission to the Huron Indians. Escorted by a group of Algonquin Indians, Latorgue is accompanied by a young Frenchman, Daniel, who is lusting after one of the Algonquin girls.

The film is adapted by Brian Moore from his own novel, so you wonder who threw the story overboard — Moore, or director Bruce Beresford? They must have decided Def II, BBC2, Wednesday 12 hird World ghetto cities, attached to some of the richest cities in the richest country on earth; the growth of a US underclass, many of whose members are outlaws because they are illegal that scenery, not drama, sells. The film is full of shots of mountains, shots of autumnal trees, vast overhead shots of rivers with canoes like tiny squiggles across their polished surfaces.

To them, landscape is holy. In one scene where Laforgue is lost in the forest, he sees the trees around him as natural cathedrals, as lofty and beautiful as the man-made churches of France.

Only this is all wrong. Seventeenth century man didn't see nature as we do; he didn't cherish wilderness. Nature to him was untamed, terrifying. The Canadian wilderness was doubly so to aristocratic priests like Laforgue;

not only was it bigger than anything in the old world, but it was peopled by "savages" out to kill.

The film sets us up for hardships -snow, intense cold, fear of death - then downplays them. No-one goes hungry, though there's no game to be caught in the snowbound landscape, the rivers are frozen and the canoes aren't full of provisions. In howling blizzards, Laforgue is lightly dressed. When he's abandoned by the Algonquins in the depth of the wilderness, without food, water or shelter, he's only mildly peeved.

immigrants; the eruption of racism across much of West Europe — our world is experiencing a creeping tide racial barbarism.

A Brave New World examines race relations in Europe and the USA, and discusses what the Radio Times describes as "the increasing racial apartheid the USA.

The film half-heartedly aims at a conflict of cultures, but it doesn't make much of this either. Rather than try to convert the Indians head on, Laforgue half-teases, halfcondescends to them. He's interested in converts, not conversation; he doesn't take them seriously «What should have been a fairly intimate encounter between two different value and belief obsession with detail."

The film might have worked as a kind of surreal quest, for there is something absurd about the Jesuit determination to convert the Indian tribes to Christianity. Their intellectual snobbery, their unshaken belief in their own superiority over mere "natives" , their rigidity, all combined to make them insensitive to the cultures on which they imposed themselves.

Which is not to say that the Indians were perfect, and that only white men were vile (as Kevin Costner was saying in Dances with Wolves). The film clearly shows the limitations of the Indian way of life. Their superstitious faith in spirits and sorcery, in "signs", the constant warring with other tribes -this is not civilisation either. But one can see why the Indians, with tneir creed ot sharing and their sensual enjoyment of pleasures, were revolted by Laforgue, a stern individualist with a taste for selfdenial.

Black Robe could have been an interesting movie, but Beresford concentrates on the wrong things. What should have been a fairly intimate encounter between two different value and belief systems gets lost in soaring scenery and obsession with detail - the painstakingly "distressed" costumes, the feathers, the bear grease on the face. After all, Black Robe is about a mismatched group of people travelling up river in bark canoes. What could be simpler? This would have been a better movie if they'd had to forgo the scenery (lovely as it is) and figure out what they were trying to say.

But scenery and detail wouldn't damage a good story. Black Robe simply doesn't have one, just a bunch of half-explored themes that don't develop. To make matters worse, we never get inside Laforgue's head (or anybody else's). Maybe, like the Indians, we're not "worthy" enough to share his thoughts. When Laforgue kneels to make his confession, the camera cuts away.

The film sits on the fence, neither endorsing Laforgue nor plumping for the Indians. (Daniel, who wants to be a priest, but likes sex too, simply doesn't register.) The most likeable character is Chomina, the Algonquin chief, whom Laforgue eventually comes to pray for. Chomina is the "good" Indian, just as the Iroquois, who take the small band of travellers captive, are the baddies. But since the film ends with a footnote declaring the unconverted Iroquois triumphant over the converted Hurons, what is the tilm trying to say! That getting religion saps your fighting spirit! Too much turning the other cheek makes you a weakie?

Kite is in the Communist Party.

Sellers' Kite is a brilliant creation -convincing, a real person, pathetic and vulnerable as well as being unpleasant, dictatorial, obstructive and, in practice, stupid. The TradeUnionese is tape-recorder sharp and accurate.

In principle, there is no reason why trade unionists should not be the target of satire; in principle, we should defend the right to satirise trade unionists, especially when it stings! But satire does not exist in a social vacuum.

"I'm alright, Jack" was an early part of the vicious drive to cut down the unions. The class spite and venom behind it was memorably expressed in an interview with film director, Sidney Gilliat, in the form of an anecdote.

An electricians steward in the film industry had said to Gilliat's brother (probably in a Cockney accent!), "there ain't no interegity [sic] no more. Ev'rythin' today is com-prom-is, com-prom-is".

Gilliat, with distaste, gave the words their peculiar articulation in his own upper-class accent. Because the electrician's accent was odd and his English shakey, he wasn't fit to have a point of view, and the workers who would elect such man were not fit to have a say in the way their own industrial lives were organised! Middle-class spite and resentment! Yet, because of Sellers' performance as Kite, *I'm alright, Jack" is brilliantly done and with something of life in it.

The first of the Sellers' movies in the series, "Only Two Can Play", (Sunday evening), made in 1962 from a Kingsley Amis novel, brought out with horrible immediacy the smugly striving lower middle class, know-nothing philistinism - proto-Thatcherism, in fact with which the work of a large and influential current of post-war British cultural icons, such as Amis himself and his buddy, the poet Philip Larkin, is awash.

God knows what Sellers believed. As well as playing Fred Kite, he played the demented Dr. Strangelove in the anti-nuclear bomb movie of that name, a character supposed to be based on Henry Kissinger. Oddly, Sellers' name appears in the WRP newspaper in the late '70s as someone scheduled to open one of their bazaars! Make of that what you will!

Next Sunday (9th), *The Mouse Roared", Channel 4, 10pm.

Scan page 14

Socialist Organiser No. 514 page 14

----- pull-quotes -----

systems gets lost in soaring scenery and

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 515

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →