Debate: Leninism or democracy
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-02-06Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
A welcome blow for socialist commonsense nteresting as I find Socialist Organiser, 1 have for some time despaired of the paper as a good gene al socialist paper.
It is too full of sectarian infighting for the average reader.
However: -UUI dit (SU 513), which argues that the fight against racism and fascism is too important to be diverted by petty squabbling between the Anti-Racist Alliance and the Anti-Nazi League and that both organisations should be supported, is a welcome blow for socialist commonsense. Keep it up!
Broadhouse La recent issue of Socialist Organiser, Tom Rigby wrote a lengthy reply to a short piece I wrote on Leninism May I in response take this opportunity of restating what I believe to be obvious:
(1) The structures of political domination developed under Stalinism were rooted in the undemocratic practices of Leninism in power (1917-23). (This is not the same as saying that Stalinism inevitably arose out of Leninism nor does it mean that all of the excesses of Stalinism can be laid at the door of Leninism).
(2) The undemocratic practices of Leninism in power were a product of both the material conditions pertaining in the Soviet Union at that time and the ideology of Leninism.
(3) The ideology of Leninism contained Jacobinical element which asserted itself in the course of 1917-23. (This does not preclude the existence within Bolshevism of many other elements including those of a democratic nature.)
The above points are sustained by a huge body of research produced by historians of both a left-wing and a right-wing persuasion. A useful recent compilation and re-assessment from a left-wing point of view is Samuel Farber's Before Stalinism (1990).
...the failure of Bolshevism before 1917 to address sufficiently the institutional factors involved in the process of transition was one of its major weaknesses."
The weight of this evidence and body of opinion is so overwhelming that it is surprising to find Tom Rigby take issue with it and there is nothing in his article that throws fresh light upon the matter.
To continue to belabour this point is as of little value as debating whether the now defunct Soviet Union constituted some form of "workers' state"
What would be ductive would be to analyse the significance of what happened in the Soviet Union in 1917-23 as a contribution to understanding the processes of change towards a socialist society in Britain today, eg:
(1) What would the relationship be between workers' councils and a national legislature elected on universal suffrage?
(2) How can the notion of freedom of the press be guaranteed and extended?
(3) What is to be the relationship between established trade unions and factory committees which may well arise in a period of revolutionary change?
(4) How is the democratisation and independence of the judiciary to be addressed?
(5) What form of political party is best suited to carrying forward such changes?
As Farber indicates in his book, the failure of Bolshevism i before 1917 to address sufficiently the institutional factors involved in the process of transition was one of its major weaknesses. Socialists today should learn from that experience.
Lan McCalman Glasgow
Scan page 13
Laforgue half-teases, half-condescends...The conflict of cultures"
Her Television Gerry Bates Last Saturday night, Channel 4 put out a long profile of •Peter Sellers as a promo for its season of Sellers films.
There was, naturally, a lot of taik about "I'm alright, Jack" in which Sellers starred.
This was a nasty anti-trade union film made in 1960 by the Boulting brothers who specialised in toothless "satires" "I'm alright, Jack" had bite, not to speak of anti-working class spleen and venom.
It was also very funny. The upper-class twit of a hero goes to work in a factory and falls foul of both crooked bosses and the trade union organisation there.
The crooked bosses are cartoon spivs, socially weightless, engaging in unbelievable plots and conspiracies: they are there to give a semblance of balance and "fair play", but they don't. The film targets trade union organisation.
The workers are lazy - when they should all be keen to work harder - conniving, mob-handed bullies. The shop stewards venor is Fred Kite (Sellers), an insecure, posturing, pretentious, power-mad "little man" with a Hitler moustache who speaks the best "Trade-Unionese" - a botched, pompous, clumsy jargon made up mainly from jaw-breaking phrases out of rule books outlining procedures.