Weird and dangerous
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-02-06Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
Last week's Socialist Organiser reported that one Trotskyist group in Algeria - the "Lambertist" PT — is calling for an "allparty government of crisis".
The demand is weird, and dangerous too. In fact, it is a sort of compendium of idocies that have infected the Trotskyist movement in recent decades.
In practice, as far as I can see, the demand amounts to "power to the FIS" [the Islamic fundamentalists]. The PT lists the desired partners in the "government of crisis" as the FIS, the ex-ruling FLN, the UGTA (the FLN-aligned trade union federation), and the FFS (the Socialist Forces Front, the major party opposed both to the old regime and to the Islamicists).
The FLN is a discredited and decaying force, so the FIS would be the strongest partner. Including the FFS could serve only to abort the chances of the FFS leading any democratic or working-class fight back agains! the Islamicists. "The whole of the PT's policy seems to be shaped by the desire to have their canoe carried along on the crest of the Islamicist wave. They dismiss all talk of a threat of Islamicist dictatorship as imperialist propaganda, protesting that the FLN has already imposed some Islamicist policics, such as a strict family law. To the PT, evidently, the FLN are the "social-Islamicists" rather as the German Social Democrats were "social-fascists" to the German Stalinists in the 1930s.
Likewise, the German Stalinists attempted to deal with the Nazis by mimicking and outdoing their nationalist fury against the Treaty of Versailles: the PT focuses its agitation on Algerian "national" issues, such as repudiating the foreign debt, rather than class or democratic issues.
Wishful thinking about tionalist or populist movements has fogged up Trotskyist politics too ofter 13 years ago, almost all of us, to varying degrees, fell victim illusions about the progressive potential of the movement behind Khomeini in Iran. The PT has learned nothing. Its slogans amount to: "After the Algerian Khomeini, our turn next".
What makes it all weirder is that the PT's line is packaged i terms of typical "Lambertist" democracy-fetishism - "the Constituent Assembly" as cure all. The "all-party government" - a coalition of the extotalitarian FLN and the would-be totalitarian FIS - is supposed (in the PT's scheme) to have the sole function of organising elections to the Constituent Assembly, which assembly will sort out the problems between the forces now edging towards civil war, and between and the working class!
The PT's slogans - like many other cod-"Trotskyist" slogans, for example the tradiional "Labour to power with socialist policies" - amount to packaging a weird and contrived private scenario in supposedly popular but actually mystifying form.
Colin Foste Eslingto