Militant's misspent youth
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-02-06Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
The Militant-led YS of the late '70s and early '80s attracted thousands of working class youth. Labour showed no interest in intervening in YCND, which CND rally. 1983. Photo: John Harris The Militant group has now left the Labour Party and decided to build its own SWP Mark 2. For nearly two decades, though - from 1969 to 1987 - it owed most of its growth to the fact that it controlled Labour's official youth movement.
Previous articles in Socialist Organiser have traced some of the history of Labour's Young Socialists (YS) in the 1960s, when it was the major arena for left-wing politics in Britain.
The sectarian but energetic Healyite SLL (later the crazy WRP) won the leadership of the YS, but then, facing a limited witch-hunt, decided to bolt in 1964-5 and purs the fantasy of building a mass revolutionary youth movement outside the Labour Party.
In 1965, the YS was left shaken and diminished; but the next few years would bring a big youth radicalisation. The different responses of the left groups remaining in the YS - Militant Young Guard (the future SWP) -would shape the development both of those groups and of the whole labour movement.
1. How Militant gained control of the YS After the Keep Left breakaway in February 1965, any choegha it.
possible that the YS would be scrapped entirely. The NEC reorganised it instead.
The Blackpool conference of the Labour Party, meeting in October 1965, accepted proposals from Labour's NEC to change the constitution of the LPYS so that:
• YS NC members would be appointed by the regional Labour Parties, not elected by conference;
• There should be no discussion of politics, no general political resolutions for conference, only motions dealing with special youth problems;
• Delegates to YS conference would have be ratified by their local parties.
The first conference under the new constitution was set for November 1965, at Malvern. 234 branches sent delegates (there had been 347 delegates at the last YS conference, at Brighton, Easter 1964). In the course of the conference the delegates went a long way towards ripping up the new constitution, thus preserving the YS as something of a political youth movement.
At a private session the delegates, by a very large majority, rejected the new constitution - on all points.
The platform had to respond to the determination of delegates to deal with politics either by closing down the conference or by bending. It bent, for the most part. On the second day the platform successfully blocked resolutions being taken on Vietnam, Rhodesia, and anti-union laws (which the government was threatening) - but the LPYS had survived.
The Malvern conference registered 605 YS branches in existence, 117 less than the 1964 conference. Since in many areas rump branches survived despite severe losses in the split, and a number of dead branches would still be on the books, it would be misleading to judge the effects of the split only from the absolute fall in the number of branches. Actual numbers of individual members are difficult to get hold of. In 1970, the official report said that the average membership of YS branches was 12; in 1972 it was said to be 18, in 1973, 8. An average of 12 in 1965 (perhaps on the high side would give a figure of about 7,500 left out of a claimed 25,000 at the Easter 1964 conference (which was also probably an inflated figure, in terms of real membership).
The Cliff tendency (the future SWP) began to focus more and more on work directed to industrial militants.
By 1967-68 Young Guard had drifted out of the YS (without the IS/SWP ever formally deciding to leave).
The YS now was left to Wilsonites, Tribunites and to the Militant.
In 1967 there were 532 registered YS branches, but only 216 delegates at conference. In 1969, there were 386 branches, dead branches haveing been removed from the lists: since there were only 150 delegates to conference, perhaps the pruning was not ruthless enough. Militant became a majority on the NC in the regional elections between the 1969 and '70 conference. In 1970, at the first conference in which Militant had the NC majority, there were only 126 delegates (457 branches registered). The YS had declined and shrivelled - and Militant had come into its own.
2. The YS under Militant Between 1969 and 1987, Militant had full political control of the LPYS, , colluding incongruously with the bureaucracy for a decade and a half.
Previously, leftists had CND drawn with the bureaucracy (Keep Left) or shared an edgy mutual contempt with it (Young Guard). Militant worked out a modus vivendi with the bureaucracy. Through years of responsible work, it won their tolerance to put its own resolutions, and their confidence that nothing much would come of it.
Before Militant took control, John Ewers, an (appointed) NC member wrote in Militant (September 1967): "The YS should aim to recruit youth to its ranks on a mass basis. It can only do this effectively with a national, regional and local organisation, elected by and responsible to the YS themselves... The NC must be elected by the members themselves, at YS conference, at which there should be no restriction on the topics discused..."
In 1968 the curbs were eased and regional elections were introduced for NC members. John Ewers hailed this as "half a step forward" (Militant, April 1968). But once Mili"Militant stood at the opposite pole to the positive qualities of youth in socialist and working class politics - ardour, combativity, willingness to take risks... the impatient belief that the themselves, here and now, can accomplish something in the class struggle and for socialis With Militant it was 'all talk and resolutionary activity'." tant got control in 1969, it agreed, hand in hand with Labour Party HQ, to exploit the bureaucratic structure whereby a National Committee not elected at conference dominated it completely.
Until about 1974, a sizeable Tribunite group still existed in the LPYS, debating with Militant. After that, it declined sharply. After 1970, Labour was out of office and no longer a millstone around the YS's neck. The class struggle intensified until it blew Heath out of Downing Street in 1974. This was still an industrial struggle, in its methods and in its focus. Nevertheless, the Labour Party, far from opposing it, was often in support, mending its fences with the unions. A trickle of militants and socialists began to enter the The LPYS's incapacity to relate to the radicalised youth in 1967-8 and after meant that it was less strong than it might have been for the struggle against the Tories. But the 1970s were very favourable times for the YS to grow. It did grow a bit.
But the Militant YS did nothing remotely like what should have been possible for a Marxist-led national youth organisation affiliated to a mass labour movement which was engaging in sometimes semirevolutionary struggles against the Tory government.
The YS was a propagandist extension of Militant, not a fighting youth movement concerned with the struggles and the interests (social, intellectual, sexual, cultural, as well as political) of the working class youth around it.
The YS was a strangely backward political backwater. Conferences in the '70s rejected resolutions in favour of gay rights that would have got through a Young Liberal conference with ease.
In 1974, the YS, following Militant arguments about 'working class unity' , failed to give support to black strikers at Imperial Typewriters, Leicester, locked in conflict with racist white workers (though in 1977, the YS did turn to attempting to organise black youth, in the very peculiar form of the British youth branch of the Jamaican People's National Party).
When the Anti-Nazi League mobilised youth in 1978 on a bigger scale than anything since the Vietnam movement or CND (and working class youth particularly), only the left-wing minority in the YS showed any interest in intervening. The Militant majority were content to reassure themselves that only the mass labour movement, armed with a socialist programme, could finally deal with racism and fascism.
Even when Militant supporter, Andy Bevan, was made official Labour Party Youth Officer, it made little difference to tne dullness and passivity of the YS.
Militant stood at the opposite pole to the positive qualities of youth in socialist and working class politics — ardour, combativity, willingness to take risks and shake up old structures, the impatient belief that they themselves, here and now, can accomplish something in the class struggle and for socialism. With Militant, it was "all talk and resolutionary activity"
Year after year, Militant boasted about *the best YS conference ever". It was all hollow and feeble, and collapsed very fast in the mid '80s, when Militant fell victim to the defeat of the left and the rightward lurch of In 1987, the YS had its structures shattered, and the maximum age limit for membership reduced, breaking Militant's control. Militant put up no fight against this destruction of the YS, tamely accepting it. Today, the LPYS is a small, shaky, shadow organisation.
he Militant period of the LPYS was shaped by the politics of Militant in the formative years of the late 1960s.
In the middle and late '60s, the role of giving a political lead to the working class (in so far as one was given), against 'its own' party in power, fell to the shop stewards movement and then to the TUC, who were forced into a head-on clash with the Labour Government over its attempted anti-union legislation, 'In Place of Strife' (1969). The YS made oppositional sounds about the Government's policies, but played little role in the decisive struggle.
Militant's reaction to the Donovan Commission, which provided the Government with guidelines for anti-trade union action, for example, was a lead article saying 'No to Legislation', but explaining that there was no point organising any campaign. "The hollowness of the employers' threats is evident... They dare not lift a finger at the present time" (Militant, December 1965/January 1966). Militant supporters who tried to start organising a campaign were quickly rebuked. Some of them (who later founded Socialist Organiser) produced a comprehensive critique of Militant's theory and practice: "What we are and what we must become". • (They were refused the right to circulate it inside the Militant group).
In its April 1967 editorial, commenting on the YS conference, Militant wrote:
...although a syndicalist interpretation could be given to the last paragraph of the Hornsey resolution, which used the formula of 'rank and file committees at the point of production' ', both at the Tribune meeting and the Militant meeting, supporters of this journal explained that this was an incorrect course to recommend to a YS conference. [It is of course very important for revolutionary socialists to warn the Parliament-oriented Tribunites against syndicalism!].
*While it is obvious that all independent action by the working class, including the formation of rank and file committees, deserves the support of every YS member, it is incorrect to hold out the prospect of activity 'at the point of production' as an alternative to the struggle for a political, socialist
Scan page 11
Derek Hatton outside Labour Party HQ. Militant the campaign for a rotten deal postponing the wrecked their base in the Labour Party by their council's financial problems for a year. In 1985, leadership of the City Council Labour group and 24,000 redundancy notices as a "tactical move". started a mass campaign against cuts. In 1984, In 1986, they did a deal with the banks and fiasco in Liverpool. In 1983 they gained the at the height of the miners' strike, they shelved made cuts. programme within the broad labour movement. Indeed, the industrial struggle of the working class will inevitably spill over into the trade union branches and the wards, CLPs and Trades Councils... "Despite the numerical weakness" , Militant continued, "this conference can assist the regeneration of the YS. If the political issues are clarified, a clear programme (particularly on youth demands, etc.) is worked out, and the YS refrain from indulging in the infantile "leftism' characteristic of previous years, it can help to invigorate the TU branches and the CLPs. It can disseminate the ideas outlined at the Llandudno conference to the active layers of the movement". The YS - the entire body of an allegedly mass youth movement - was only to make abstract socialist propaganda.
Activity in the CLPs and so on was counterposed to the real class struggle of that time, and used as an excuse to keep the YS distant and aloof from it. Militant counterposed (propaganda for) 'the socialist programme to the class struggle at the point of production (or, as it was to be in the following years, in the streets).
True, the great industrial victories were unable to change society even after bringing down Heath, because the political labour movement was in the hands of the Lib-Lab reformists. The militant workers who defeated the Tories had no political alternative to them, except the right-wing Labour leaders.
But those who, like Militant, had counterposed passive propagandist politics to the direct action struggle, contributed in their own small way to that great defeat. In an active and explosive labour movement crying out for an organisation capable of providing an all-sided integration of the class struggle — of the political, economic and ideological dimensions — Militant's passive propagandist version of 'politics' was the mirror image of 'pure' direct-action trade unionism.
Militant's approach would cripple the YS as a youth movement — it would help ensure that the great youth revolt of the late '60s was too often channelled into pseudo-anarchism the dithered and then collapsed, sending out events that might have been designed as an effective crash course in revolutionary politics (all that was 'missing' was an experience showing up Mao-Stalinism and populism). And the youth learned. But the YS could make nothing of the opportunities. The spontaneously revolutionary youth were raw and ultra-left'. A serious socialist youth movement would have dealt with this by immersing itself in their struggles, for example on Vietnam. The LPYS, shrivelled and afflicted increasingly by Militant's passivity, could do nothing of the sort. It did not participate in the Vietnam movement (unless you count a few sellers of Militant on demonstrations). The years of the upsurge were the years of the organisational nadir of the YS. They were also the years when Militant gained the NC majority. The Militant 'Marxist' YS was born away from the struggles and storms of that period. 4. "The perspective"
whe specific and distinguishing political idea of Militant was the view - they called it a "perspective" - that in its future evolution, the broad labour movement, and the Labour Party, too, would become a mass revolutionary resolutions passed by trade union conferences to show that the movement was well on its way. It would become effectively socialist with time, and Militant's propaganda.
Their model of socialism was that of 1940s-style bureaucratic "nationalisation", summed up in slogans about "nationalising" "the 200" or "250 monopolies". In YS branches in the mid-'60s there would be passionate debates between Militant and supporters of the future SWP about which was central: "nationalisation" or "workers' control". Dogmatically "Trotskyist", Militant People's Front who, giving lip service to nationalisation, remain in reality agents of capital; (3) we call upon the masses to rely only upon their own revolutionary strength; (4) we link up the question of expropriation with that of seizure of power by the workers and farmers.
Militant required centrally of its supporters that they accept a view of the future. This "perspective" would inspire them while they made general socialist propaganda, integrated themselves as citizens of the labour movement, and waited for it to "evolve"
The Militant saw themselves as waiting for "the perspective" to grow, develop, mature, ripen. In this process the class struggle could be at best the excuse for a sermon about socialism.
"The perspective" said that as the labour movement ripened, the "next stage", which was inevitable and could not be bypasssed (the big crime of the Healyite SLL was seen to be that it tried to bypass it) was the development of a "mass left wing" probably around Tribune. The Militant could only wait, doing routine work and making propaganda for this development. "Premature" struggle, conflict with the bureaucracy, or even attempts to go out and organise the Labour left would be more harmful than useful. The "Perspective" would be its own midwife.
This was their big difference with the proto-IMG, who tried to organise this expected Labour broad left.
Essentially the Grantites believed themselves to exist before their proper historical time. (Their "perspective" was like the sort of view of the world, and their own place in it, which the most pedantic of the Russian Marxists drew from the conviction that the Russian Revolution could only be bourgeois, and that the preordained protagonists in it were the bourgeoisie. The Tribune left was Militant's "bourgeoisie"!)
Militant really did not think there was much they could do in the Labour Party. In the '40s, their tendency had refused to join the Labour Party; they eventually gave up and joined only on the basis that nothing much could be done outside either. They had a strange combination of dull passivity in the present, and bland optimism about the day after tomorrow. Witness the headlines in Militant: "Rhodesia; White settlers forced to come to terms" [Julian Silverman, May 1966]. June 1966 editorial: "a Tito solution" for Vietnam [ie. a neutral, independent Vietnam] "as predicted in Militant and then later by De Gaulle and [Robert] Kennedy" February 1967 editorial: *Imperialism trapped in Vietnam", etc, etc, ad nauseam.
This combination was the basis for the incredible "patience" Militant prided themselves on in the late '60s.
Militant believed itself to be embedded in an unfolding "deformed world revolution" Workers' states" were multiplying fast -Syria in 1963, Burma in 1965, and subsequently many others, in Africa and elsewhere.
Militant placed a very high value then and later on their accurate powers of prediction!
Socialists and the
Organiser
Ted Grant could be heard describing Marxism as "the science of perspective and prediction". Passive propaganda and a labour movement routinism, combining propaganda for "socialism" with passionate belief in Ted Grant's picture of the evolution of large parts of the world towards socialism, and of the British labour movement towards active commitment to socialism. That was Militant.
limited, but it was enough to make it one of the bigger groups on the left.
Militant's political ideas served it as rationalisations rather than cutting tools. Abstract and essentially preposterous general propaganda — like "Labour to power with socialist policies" demanding nothing less than the full socialist programme from gentlemen like Wilson and Callaghan! — was often counterposed to the day-to-day nittygritty details of the necessary struggle against these people.
Its abstract propaganda notion of the socialist struggle - calling for nothing less than the "nationalisation" of everything, while doing nothing about it - could appear very radical and Marxist to young people in the YS and also, paradoxically, avoid conflict with the Labour Party leadership.
Militant thus turned irreplaceable ideas into harmful caricatures — for example the idea that socialists must relate strategically to existing mass labour movements, with the long term perspective of transforming them, was rendered by Militant into absurd, precise, detailed timetables and scenarios and Old Moore's Almanac-type predictions for the future. And Militant's practical conclusions from these scenarios and "perspectives" was to settle into waiting in the Labour Party and YS as one waits for a train to a desired destination. But politics does not run on pre-laid tracks!
Militant solaced its youth, and reconciled them to its dull routines, with the myths of an ever-expanding working class revolution spreading slowly across the globe, albeit "for now" led by the Stalinists and others.
It was all myth and nonsense. But the network of Labour Party YS branches connected to the constituency Labour Parties gave Militant a large base for its propaganda and a trelliswork — subsidised by the Labour Party! - on which to thread its own growing organisation, together with a stable routine of meetings and national affairs.
Its manner of growth, its links with the Labour bureaucracy while it grew, must be unique in the history of self-proclaimed revolutionary organisations. Made unstable since 1987, it is now jettisoning its past, and its long-time prophet, and striking out into political - and organisational — terra incognita.
----- pull-quotes -----
ARE DEF CE
3. Militant and the class struggle
*Mitant turned ireplaceable ideas Into caricatures.
movement. They would sometimes point to the many toothless "socialist"
5. The débacle ilitant's growth from the LPYS in Mimited, but it was enough to make