Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Behind the Middle East peace talks Shamir faces a dilemma

Socialist Organiser no. 515, 6 February 1992 · scan pp. 7–8 · about 1,076 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

TOTAL US AID TO ISRAEL 82/83 84/85 86/87 88/89 90/91* Adam Keller in Tel-Aviv analyses the background to the Middle East peace talks. (From Other Israel, 15 January)

he most profound effect of Madrid was the Occupied Territories. In general, even those Palestinians who supported the conference expected little to come of it.

However, the sight of their people's representatives being received by the great powers of the world created a wave of enthusiasm, and even of euphoria, throughout the Occupied Territories.

The returning delegates were given a hero's welcome; Palestinian youths went out into the streets, holding olive branches in their hands, giving them to the laughing soldiers they had been fighting but days before, and even decorating Israeli military vehicles with them -to the great consternation of the Israeli Army High Command.

The time was particularly fitting for what diplomats term confidence-building measures. This would have involved Israeli willingness to announce a freeze of settlement activity, a release of prisoners and the legalisation of political activity in the Occupied Territories.

Such steps on the Israeli side would have enabled the Palestinian leadership to proclaim a suspension of the armed struggle, and the Arab states to their trade boycott against Israel. This should have been a lucrative deal for any reasonable Israeli government, but it implies a definite abandonment of the "Greater Israel" dream — a price the Shamir government is totally unwilling to pay.

By the middle of Novem Bber, the government hac definitely shaken off the Spirit of Madrid and resolutely embarked upon a series of what Palestinian negotiator Hanan Ashwari termed confidence-destroying measures: the Palestinian olive-branch demonstrations" were proclaimed to be the terrorists, gimmicks of were ordered to disperse them; unofficial promises to reopen Bir-Zeit University (closed since the beginning of the Intifada) were withdawn;

I SOCIALIST DREALISER Israel /Palestine Two nations, Two states! OLiu dunna tha throat nf IIS aid cut.nffs snamir races me uncar vi vo a vus settlement activities were increased throughout the occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip, and a considerable slice of the 1992 government budget earmarked for the same purpose and to top it all, the Israeli police evicted Palestinian families from their homes at East Jerusalem's Silwan Village to make place for Jewish settlers.

Palestinian opponents of the Madrid Process contributed their share to the escalation. In particular, George Habash's Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine embarked upon a series of well-planned ambushes at the sides of main roads in the Occupied Territories — ambushes scheduled to coincide with each stage of the Madrid/Washington talks and leaving numerous Isreli settlers dead and wounded.

The settlers reacted by launching massive retaliation raids upon Arab towns and villages, as well as by extending their settlements beyond the boundaries approved by the government. The army, for its part, responded to the armed attacks by increasingly repressive measures: mass detentions, and the imposiMore on the SE15 4NA VITO tion of prolonged curfews.

he first round of the bilateral negotiations, held in December in Washington, was overshadowed by this escalation.

While the talks were going on, the town of Ramallah — where several Palestinian negotiators have their homes - was under tight military curtew, with armed settlers allowed to rampage in the streets.

The talks were soon bogged down in procedures and "Soldiers were ordered to disperse olivebranch demonstrations technicalities; their main achievement was the creation of a cordial personal contact between the respective heads of the Israeli, Palestinian and Jordanian delegations. Chief Israeli negotiator Elyakim Rubinstein, a relative moderate and the only Israeli veteran of Camp David involved in the present talks, was reportedly chating at the extremely limited mandate he got from Shamir.

In January, the next round of bilateral talks was preceded by a new Shamir provocation: deportation orders aginst 12 Palestinians. This provided the Palestinians with a United Nations victory largely nullifying the effect of the earlier Israeli success -the UN Zionism is not racism certificate.

Things came to a head as the delegates convened in Washington. The procedural deadlock was finally broken and the Israeli and Palestinian delegates were at last able to sit face to face. This breakthrough was followed immediately by a new armed attack upon settlers West Bank and new retaliations by the settlers.

At Washington, these events had the effect of making negotiators on both sides abandon diplomatic language and engage in half an hour's emotional outburst, where all traumas of the Israeli and Palestinian past were laid bare. At the end of this, however, one very concrete step was taken: the Israeli delegates handed to their Palestinian interlocutors a document in which the Israeli government officially undertakes to negotiate on Interim Self-Government Arrangements.

Though the document contained no details, the ministers of the Techiya and Moledet parties - who regard any kind of self-government as inevitably leading to the creation of an independent Palestinian state - were quick to offer their resignation, thus depriving the Shamir government of its parliamentary majority.

For all the provocations which Yitzchak Shamir is willing to countenance or actively support, there is one thing which he cannot afford: to be saddled with the responsibility for the failure of the negotiations.

Over the past year, Yitzchak Shamir has undertaken two incompatible sets of promises and obligations: one towards the hardline Israeli nationalists, inside and outside his own party; the other towards the President of the United States. Soon, he will have to decide on which promises to renege; probably not even Shamir knows himself what his choice will be.

But one thing seems certain: the choice will be connected with the amount of pressure to which Shamir will be exposed from different quarters. For peace-seekers in Israel and abroad, now is the time to mobilise all available forces.

ore from Socia Organiser PROBLEMS MELE STRUGGLES by Socialist Organiser and Workers' Liberty &l A handbook far trade unionists A comprehensive guide to the issues of today and the lessons of the past. €1.00 plus 28p post The case for Socialist Feminism A Women's Fightesch pamphlet 6i S billion Towards capitalismor workers' liberty"

plus 18p post IRELAND The Socialist Answer E1.00 plus A Marxist analy of the roots of oppression, and class struggle strategy for women's liberation.

£1.00 plus 28p post. Send cheques for all pamphlets tr AWL, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA.

Scan page 8

Tom Rigby looks at th ow to stop

----- pull-quotes -----

20p plus 18p postage from SO, PO Box

EASTERN EUROPE

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 515

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →