Socialists challenge Kinnockite leadership
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-02-06Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
student democracy too these Hammond: victim of a bureaucratic stitch-up FEUD (personal capacity) eft Unity met last weekend and agreed to stand a slate of candidates for the forthcoming National Union of Students (NUS) executive elections.
oor old Eric Janine Booth, NUS Hammond has Women's Officer, will be the victim of a standing for President, with thoroughly unfair Mark Sandell and Kevin Sexbureaucratic stitch-up. ton also contesting full-time positions. Alice Sharp's canNo, don't laugh: this is didature for NUS Women's quite serious, actually. Officer was also endorsed.
Last week's Labour Part The campaign will focus on NEC voted to disbar 11 the record of the Labour StuEETPU delegates to Birm- dent (NOLS) leadership over ingham Ladywood Consti- THEEUNIONS= the last decade. Instead of tuency Labour Party. No Defend reasons were given, apparently on the novel By Sleeper grounds of "personal privacy". Objections from Nigel Harris, the AEU representative on By Alice Sharp, NUS NEC (personal capacity) anti-Militant "left wing" witchhunter.
The date and place have been set for the Extraordinary Conference of the National Union of Students: 4 March, Wolverhampton.
Only the third in the last 20 accepted practice no longer applies. ent to stand down.
Small Heath nomination. delegates. Janine Booth: Left Unity candidate for President building a fightback amongst the rank and file against the Tories, NUS has relied on the suppert of right-wing sabbaticals. Last term, when thousands of students took action against student poverty, NUS preferred to organise for NUS reform. years of NUS history, this Extraordinary Conference will cost something in the region of £60,000 t100,000. It will discuss and pass policy not on any emergency or urgent issue of the day, but on "reform" of the union's internal structures.
fake "emergency"? Why call such a conference at such great exLeft Unity's campaign will be arguing for basic student unionism and for socialism. The last few years have seen ideas of collectivity and participatory democracy under attack as right-wingers see student unions as small businesses of which they can play at being manager.
Janine will be defending those ideas and linking them to a perspective of students joining with the labour movement to stop the attacks on students and workers, and fighting for an open, democratic education system.
Already the Socialist Workers Party (SWP) have said they will vote for Kinnockites and Independents rather than Left Unity canpense? It will only be 12 weeks since the last national conference (including the Christmas break) and only five weeks to the next national conference (mid-April).
In short: why blatantly ignore and side-step the constitution of the national union in order to push these "reforms" through? That is what is happening.
LEFT UNTY 7 Out the The didates. They would rather see the right-wing lead NUS, with the sort of politics which are ruining the union, than a socialist "competitor" in a good position to help students fight debt and education cuts.
Even after only a few days, messages of support for Janine are coming into the Left Unity office. Rallies and meetings are planned in thirty colleges. Pledges of support from Irish and Scottish colleges are particularly encouragingFor more information about the campaign, for speakers etc. write to 56 Kevan House, Wyndham Road, London SE5 or phone 071-639 7965.
For six years now, the NUS leadership has been trying to "reform" the union's structure. Time and again, at 11 NUS conferences, they have been knocked back. Demoralised and desperate, the NUS leadership still see no alternative strategy for harsh times, so now they hope to capitalise on the weariness of the membership and ram through "reform" mob-handed.
At the NUS conference in December, the "reforms" once more failed to get the required two-thirds majority. The NUS constitution states that no issue decided at an NUS conference can be reopened at the same conference. NUS President Stephen Twigg flouted the constitution and forced a "re-vote" which got the two-thirds majority for abolition of NUS's Winter Conference.
Such constitutional changes require a two-thirds majority at two successive conferences. Especially after their outrageous bulldozing at the December conference, the NUS leaders knew they were unlikely to get their two-thirds majority at the forthcoming April conference.
They have called an emergency conference because they are much more likely to get a two-thirds majority there. Delegates can be appointed, not elected; and Further Education college student unions, short of cash, are unlikely to send delegates at all. The emergency conference is therefore certain to be unrepresentative, dominated by union officials from the universities and polytechnics.
Those are the people most likely to support the "reforms" , the gist of which is to transform NUS from a union organising students to
Scan page 5
leadership that will fight student debt and education cuts wreckers now!
pacupied therd ree- dent, said: *The occupation раковиская Bredord was a definite victory, and College. shows childcare is an issue The demands of the oc- we can win on for childcare provision, and erigreney campaignao mmpra ve Sub chüdeale. recerved From local conlege into a services agency with a bit of parliamentary lobbying.
The NUS leaders thus hope to get abolition of the (large and representative) Winter Conference finalised by this (small and unrepresentative) emergency conference. They also hope to get a tirst two-thirds majority for other "reforms" - regionalisation (meaning the destruction of NUS Area organisation) and changes in NUS Executive (to cut out minority left-wing representation).
With the wind behind their sails, and the opponents of such "reform" demoralised, they reckon to get the second two-thirds majorities for those further "reforms" at the April conference; and then NUS will be safe for careerism and bureaucratic services-agency "unionism" for a long while.
The proposed reforms are basically aimed at closing down democracy and accountability in NUS. The best activists in NUS understand this and have fought hard against the "reform"
caliuescia ya- FBDO ruary thoe medenis cupation were for £10,000 NUS's leadership, Stephen Twigg. Lorna Fitzsimmons: they break the constitution and flout democracy. They want to get rid of all accountability in NUS proposals. Indeed, wereimet withe ізно прорв clara dre gro Hol.
50 pempler signe den p niee Anoncariea through. Numerous Memberd.
RICK CHEES 1010l us have been opposing "reform" since it was first proposed back in 1986.
Now, after six years and 11 NUS conferences of debating and defeating the right's "reforms" many activists are bored and tired with the whole affair (preferring to build campaigns to fight the Tories) - so much so that even outrageous actions by National President Stephen Twigg and his friends go largely untackled by the left.
The constitution clearly states that to call an Extraordinary Conference 25 colleges must submit motions requesting one and stating the topic for discussion: Each motion should be passed by the union's recognised governing body.
Stephen Twigg accepted 34 motions, only 19 of which had been passed in line with the rules stated. Twigg had once more broken the constitution.
The student movement, like the labour movement, has suffered defeats under the Tories. It has been weakened and demoralised. The right wing in NUS has come up with answers like those of the right in the labour movement.
They go something like this. The nature of the movement has changed over the last decade or so. We now live in new times. We have to alter the structures to reflect these changes. NUS needs to be modernised. The old structures are cumbersome and expensive.
In fact, the proposed "reforms" will weaken NUS further. They are, in part, a reaction to the Tories' threats to restructure NUS on a basis of individual voluntary membership, but they will close the union down to rank and file activists, and to the largest section of the membership, working-class youth the FE sector. in Already carved out and under-represented, FE students will have what little say the ve got snatched away.
The national union will become a services agency for the rich and powerful university and polytechnic sector. The reforms will extend and consolidate a transformation - from real student union to student services business -already underway in many universities. Once carried out they will be extremely difficult - almost impossible in the current climate - to reverse. Those best able to fight them will, in effect, be excluded from the new structures. 'The abolition of Winter conference will seal off the leadership from membership.
NUS, despite its leadership, is by and large a democratic and open organisation. Its structures, by they Area organisations or the National Executive Committee itselt, are open to all its membership.
For surc, the structures could be improved and strengthened. The abolition of the card vote would be an immensely positive reform: it is regularly abused by the big right-wing universities at the expense of larger, but less powerful, sections of the membership. Left Unity has proposed and supported a number of positive reforms over the years, and has fought hard to defeat those reforms that will weaken the national union's strength.
After years of defeat, the right wing's determination to push their reforms through at any cost has now become clear to all. Calling for revotes on matters already decided, going ahead with plans for Extraordinary Conferences that clearly breach the constitution, show their virtually complete disregard for NUS as it stands, and for its membership.
The abolition of Winter Conference will seal off the leadership from the membership. Accountability will become a thing of the past. With only one conference a year, elections will be the main feature of the event. Policy debate and opportunities to hold the elected leadership to account will be pushed out. There is nothing progressive or modern about such "reforms" • It is dangerous, and it weakens our ability to organise and fight.
If abolition of Winter Conference goes through, together with the regionalisation reforms (destroying NUS Area organisation), and the major alterations in the National Executive Committee (crutailing minority representation), then one and a half million students will be left with a flashy services and lobbying body irrelevant to all but a small fraction.
Student union activists who allow weariness to make them defeatist or resigned about all this are making a big mistake. Our ability to organise and fight back is under threat. We must spare no effort • to defeat these "reforms"
To roll over and play dead now; or to be under the romantic illusion that we can just mouth slogans about building a movement to march forward and smash the right wing, is to be irresponsible.
anise •to now I have Socialist Organiser's campaign against "left" anti-semitism exaggerated the way in which anti-Zionism is used as a form of anti-semitism.
Events at the Campaign for Labour Party Democracy (CLPD) conference last Saturday have made me re-examine the issue.
A resolution was moved which dealt with "the growth across Europe of physical attacks on blacks, immigrants and, in Eastern Europe in particular, The motion pro- Jewish composed affiliation to the AntiRacist Alliance.
During the debate two comments were made which sharply illustrated the existence of thinly-veiled antisemitism.
Early in the debate a speaker, someone newly appointed to the CLPD EC, made a disturbing remark. The speaker, apparently from an East London constituency where the fight against racism is a life and death issue, said "Arabs in Britain are the victims of racism from Zionists".
I objected to the crass irrelevance of such remarks. If Arabs are attacked it is by racists rather than people with a particular opinion on the Israel/Palestine question.
But the issue was not settled. Ray Sirockin, of Socialist Action and Deptford CLP, defended the original contribution, declaring "many Jewish people hold deeply racist views towards Arabs and have done so since the Six Day War of 1967"
This prompted Sophie Nicol, also from the CLPD EC, to object to the way Jewish people were being discussed. Quite correctly, Sophie said that in a debate on combatting racism the ony references to Jews in the liscussion were as perpetrators rather than victims.
Neither the chair nor any of the senior officers saw fit to pursue the matter.
A few points are worth making. Firstly, "Zionism" was used as a code word for "Jews"
Secondly, while we deplore attacks on Jews in Eastern Europe - at least in writing - not only are attacks on Jews in Britain not worthy of nention, but Jews are astigated for their own alleg ed racism.
Thirdly, this debate took place in a respected organisation of the Labour left. believe that these issues need dealing with. I am sending a copy of this report to CLPD. I will be including a copy, with any reply received, in the report to my CLP
Scan page 6
inise To the millant Desr Comrades. intelligentsia with for the masses...
"I have no difficulties with the existing monarchy", says the member for Tottenham.
"A lot of people like and believe The role of the BBC radio news is particularly important, given its reputation for HICH
----- pull-quotes -----
Fight Student Debt
campaign for their demands We Say NO to Es rantsi JON LEFTUNITY Dr All Fight
epsil, ama sithe denaeB and the Left Unity NEC WELFARE ain
partor ithe it qaRt :C12z%
Benefits StrEaFT UNITY right: Student Denti
Accountability will become a thing of the past."
• Bi Fair Grants For All
anti FIGHMINIG RACTISIM By Kevin Feintuck Valways though that