The left and the rentiers
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-01-30Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 15 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 15
A conference last Saturday 25) on "Labour and the Economy" drew about 100 socialists and activists to ear speakers including MP and Bet Peter economic Programme of Action is very poor.
Although it complains about the behaviour of the City of London and finance in general, the programme has neither an analysis of the reasons for this behaviour nor any grasp of the connections between these institutions and society at large.
To me it seems this behaviour is consistent with a strategy to turn Britain into something like a larger version of Jersey, or maybe the Isle of Man: a rentier economy in which a substantial leisured class lives a comfortable existence on unearned income, often from abroad.
There will be little industry and few industrial workers. What work there is, is principally in low-pay jobs providing services to the middle classes; both income taxes and the social wage must of necess ty be low.
"On what grounds should holders of such capital recei tax breaks for repatriating the stuff?"
The point about this picture of Britain 1992 is that it is not just a few fat capitalists, in top hats and tails, but rather a substantial proportion of the middle class, particularly those in receipt of occupational pensions, who benefit from this arrangement and for whom the behaviour of the City (dominated by the pension funds) is quite logical.
To move against the City is to provoke a fight not just with the City but with a wider section of society. The programme gives no indication of this fight, hiding all the time behind "Britain's interest"
Indeed, in as much as it hits this evolving rentier economy where it hurts most, in its pocket, I think that Labour's proposals on the abolition of the National Insurance upper earnings limit and an increase the higher rate of tax are far more radical and to the point than a lot of what is in this piro gramme (such as the to nationalise the because devaluation achieves its purpose, of making the UK more competitive internationally, if and only if workers are not fully compensated for the rise in domestic prices caused by the rise in import prices.
As for the gung-ho attitude towards the Exchange Rate Mechanism of the European Monetary System, it shows no understanding of why capital in this country thought it right to join the mechanism (so important, in fact, that it was both prepared and able to sacrifice Mrs Thatcher to maintain it). And I would have thought that as internationalists, we would find the principle of currency stability preferable to the anarchy of the market.
Of course we are not dealing with internationalists here, as the talk about the over-riding importance of the repatriation of capital shows. A great deal of capital did indeed go abroad during the years of the oil surpluses in the early 1980s (given a current account surplus, a net outflow of capital is inevitable). But in the last few years (since 1988, I think), "we" have benefitted from con. siderable inflows of capital some of which has been directed (by the Japanese) into industrial investment.
On what grounds do we prefer "our" capital to "theirs", and why on earth should holders of such capital receive tax breaks for repatriating the stuff?
Worst of all, this programm shows no understanding of the present global crisis and Britain's place in it. It is true that the depth of the recession here is to do with particular British factors, but there is no way that any government can fashion a recovery until and unless the principal capitalist economies revive.
The programme shuns "Fortress Europe", but if there is one arena in which immediate struggle is possible then it is inside this particular fortress. As Western European capital moves to impose a system based on the old West German model of an independent central bank, so that system is facing its most serious challenge from the German workers themselves.
----- pull-quotes -----
THE POILITICIAL ECONOMY
do we prefer 'our' capital to 'theirs, and why on earth