Mourning the Good King
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-01-30Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 13
(m ke mimer eerd were funny bits ings. But they should do it for its Belinda Weaver "JFK"
"JFK", Americans are a nation of Hamlets who amourn their murdered fatherking (President Kennedy) but cannot dislodge his usurpers from the bloodstained throne. Director Oliver Stone calls the assassination a coup d'etat: he hints at fascism.
There probably was a conspiracy to murder Kennedy. You can take your pick of suspects — Lyndon Johnson, the Vice-President who wanted his job; the CIA, from whose control Kennedy was threatening to wrest paramilitary operations; the military establishment who might have thought Kennedy was soft o1 communism; the Mania; right wing Cubans. a cast of thousands. Lee Harves Oswald was another suspect ne film suspect, but the film exonerates him «'JFK' is a mourning film for that vanished and There's a lot of "JFK" implicates everyone but Oswald, though the military-industrial complex probably gets the biggest nod. They had the most to lose, and thus the most to gain if he died. Or so says Oliver Stone.
As an anonymous source tells New Orleans District Attorney, Jim Garrison, who's trying to find the real killers, military spending before the Vietnam War was $10 billion. With Vietnam in full swing, spending rose to $100 billion, so the military (and the arms dealers who supply them) had a real stake in getting rid of Kennedy, who was considering pulling out of Vietnam.
Or so the film alleges; in fact, there is no evidence - not one single shred - to show that Kennedy was going to do any such thing. The idea that he was is pure myth: Kennedy started "Vietnam"!
There's a lot of Kennedy-worship in this movie, a lot of myth. It's as if the last ten or twenty years had never happened. Oliver Stone sees Kennedy as a Life magazine cover, as a golden boy. There's no tarnish on Camelot.
For Stone - and never mind the facts — Kennedy is the man who could have ended the Cold War, and the Vietnam war too. He is anti-nuclear, the champion of black Americans (er... wasn't that Martin Luther King?), a New Man, no less, years before his time "JFK" is a mourning film tor that vanished and wholly imaginary Golden Age, though Stone is probably right to say that America would have been different without Vietnam. That war wrecked the American economy and ended the long post-world War Il boom, ushering in the imperial decline and loss of prestige abroad that an adventure like the Gulf War was meant to reverse.
But Stone is mourning all the wrong things. Murdering Kennedy (if they did it) is not the worst the military and the arms manufacturers can do. Their greedy pursuit of their own selfish ends tramples over all humanity.
The film is structured like those populist dramas of the 1940s - Mr Deeds Goes to Town or Mr Smith Goes to Washington - where a small-town guy with the right values wins out over the faceless and corrupt authorities. Jim Garrison a real person) is Stone's Mr Deeds, and with Kevin "Clean-cut" Costner in the role, we're primed for a battle between good and evil.
But the drama hasn't been updated for audiences who have lived through Watergate, and IranContra, not to mention the seamy Contra nat ta man n tha 'evelations about Kennedy himselt. We're too knowing and cynical to swallow Stone's view of Kennedy, or to watch patiently while Costner's Garrison has his eyes opened. The film would only work if Garrison were presented as a naive, bumbling fool who nonetheless stumbled on truths that other people were desperate to hide. But he's not. He's the guy in the white hat, a knight in shining armour, Sir Galahad no less.
Garrison, in prosecuting a businessman who he alleges was involved in the murder plot, claiman wa cars m ms cyes anu quotes Curith tanne in hie avar from Tennyson) that Americans have been denied the truth about Kennedy's death, and that the people covering it up are doing it to enslave and control them. Only when they know the truth can the American people wrench government away from the corrupt and the self-serving and reclaim their freedom. constricted ov society's view of Be modesko Chru ti Most were grieving over the lack SIC COLDES tant or authoritarian fathers.
suourDanM mO Shopper mall than in sidekick that he was going off could see the sidekick nodding Stone makes much of this big courtroom speech (though Costner is so lacklustre as Garrison that it's not the firework it ought to be but he doesn't make much of his own freedom; he doesn't name names or SO I MAG 1 10. The right to call tell it like it ic Tha richt to nall things by their real names is an important freedom. In films like Salvador, Wall Street, Platoon and Born on the Fourth of July, Stone has shown that he knows who the real enemy is - American capitalism, American imperialism - but, like the characters in "JFK" , he's not game to put anything on the record Though the movement claims to "they want us to be in10W mous pressure women race to raise man said the women's movement themselves; it's healthy that they esu! their upbringThe hokey, semi-mystical nature 10 u itiation stuf ust seemed weird! like something left over from than wife-beating, boozing to obli-
----- pull-quotes -----
wholly im- aginary Golden Age.
Kennedy-worship in this movie, lot of myth."