Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The killings in Northern Ireland Bombs versus politics

Socialist Organiser no. 514, 30 January 1992 · scan pp. 11–13 · Patrick Murphy · about 3,768 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 11

How many more funerals? Photo: Andrew Moore, Keflex.

t9.00 on the 27th • December we crossed athe Irish border between Dundalk and Newry on the way to spend New Year in Newry. Just a few hours earlier, the Provi sional IRA chose the same area to announce the end of their Christmas ceasefire - they planted a bomb on the BelfastDublin railway line just north of Newry and it exploded on the 27th marking the start of another year of the troubles.

It is comparisons amongst ordinary "non-political' people now and in the early 1970s, that bring home some of what these Troubles now mean.

In the early '70s, there was, as now, a variety of views on the justice and usefulness of the IRA campaign, the prospects for a united Ireland or some change in the political system. There was, however - and I have experience only of the Nationalist community - a very lively sense of politics being important. There was debate and a feeling that what we thought, said and did counted and would influence events.

Today, politics, for a lot of people, is a rotten business which infects everybody who comes into contact with it. Above all, it is inevitably connected to the worst aspect of life - the murderous Troubles which hang over normality like a huge, dark cloud; every so often it produces a raging storm, people run for cover, it stops, they return to work. But it is pointless to go back to attempts to explain it, that's been done, that's "politics' and the safest option for most people is to avoid involvement with it.

This wily, cautious, distant attitude is becoming harder. The 'politics' of the Troubles were becoming more difficult to ignore by the end of last year because the sectarian tension, heightened dramaticallv bv the actions of a handful of lovalist and republican activists, is now sharper than at any time since the mid-"70s.

In 1974-6, a horrific series of sectarian killings created an atmosphere of fear in both communities. It began to scale down after a bloody peak in 1976. when two separate incidents saw Catholics killed by loyalist paramilitaries in one evening and then, 2 days later, republican group murdered 10 Protestant workers by stopping their works van, sending the Catholics home and shooting the rest the worst sectarian incident in years).

Those days are back and it means that everyone becomes more aware, more scared and perhaps more bitter. Figures in the end-of-year press in Ireland suggest that in 75% of all the killings last year, the victims were civilians.

It's a controversial word in any conflict, but the detailed breakdown of statistics made one thing clear: this is not, essentially, a war between Republican volunteers and the security forces; the vast majority of casualties (especially deaths) involve people killed because of their religion. An additional number are killed by the IRA because of connections with security which are completely non-military.

Beyond question, these are sectarian killings; in a society with so little work and such a huge state machine, in which a very high percentage of *This is not, essentially, a war between Republican volunteers and the security forces; the vast majority of casualties involve people killed because their religion."

Protestants in particular do work loosely associated with the security forces, to regardsuch people as collaborators is to launch war on the Protestant community. The bombing of the workers' bus a fortnight ago, near Cookstown, is just a concentrated example of the reckless policy carried on by the Provos throughout 1991.

So why is it happening? In the press, of course, but even on the streets and in pubs, despite 20 years of conflict, this is being discussed again. There is no single agreed answer, nothing that hard information supports, but there are definite causes.

For much of the press, the upturn in violence is cyclical, the bombing campaign in the North and in Britain reflects the IRA's desire to push the issue of Ireland higher up the political agenda. Ten years after the hunger strikes and 6 years after the Hillsborough Agreement, only dramatic acts of violence seem to make the North headline news. The idea that the violence is driven by the political agenda makes even more sense in a general election year.

For the paramilitary side of violence, there are other factors. There has been a simmering internal conflict in the Republican movement for some years roughly between "politicos' and 'militarists' -just now, the militarists, frustrated with the lack of progress after a full decade of political work, and the exclusion of Sinn Fein from any talks on the future, want to re-establish their credentials and their effectiveness.

Similar developments appear to be taking place amongst the loyalist paramilitaries; some of the loyalists killed last year seem to have been victims of a younger, more aggressive leadership of their own organisations. They are feeding off disillusion with the established Unionist politicians for making no dent in the Anglo-Irish agreement, and frustration at the ineffectiveness of the army and police response to the IRA.

Loyalist gangs have ruthlessly stoked up the sectarian fires with a series of savage killings of Catholics. Their killing of workers from the Hyster tractor factory last year and of 2 Catholics at a mobile shop in January were simply warnings that there are thousands of Catholics who are easy targets and that, if they feel like it, they will kill them too.

It's part of a lingering threat to launch bloody civil war if necessary.

There is one final theory with currency amongst the more cynical Nationalists. The Provisionals are desperate need of a boost and they have tuned in to the current debate over internment. The theory is that some of their leadership want to provoke internment in the hope that it will have the transforming effect on the Nationalist community which it did in 1971 (or which the hunger strikes did in 1981).

Irish republicanism is a creed that feeds off martyrs and there are plenty of Unionists and Tories only too keen to provide them. If this is Provo thinking, it's highly dangerous and desperate. Internment this time will be very different - it will be selective, based on Army intelligence, not the rabidly anti-Catholic RUC intelligence of 1971.

It will come when the freshest events in Nationalist minds are not the popular and heroic civil rights marches, but over 20 years of fairly futile and random killing and, after the last few months, the risk of an escalated sectarian war. It will also come at a time when co-operation at every level between the British and Irish governments is higher than ever.

If internment is introduced, it will be done simultaneously with a crackdown in Dublin. My assessment certainly is that thereintroduction of internment would be a disaster for the Republican movement, and that conditions for campaigning against it in Ireland and in Britain are much tougher than in the "70s.

Whatever the reason for the latest wave of killings, it widens still further the huge gap between the republican tradition - with all its democratic and just aspirations - and the only force which can unite Ireland, the Irish working class.

Against all the odds, there have been some signs of hope there. When loyalist thugs murdered those Catholic workers from the Hyster factory in Lurgan last year, their fellow workers called an all-out strike the next day to protest. It is a mixed workplace, mainly Protestant, in a loyalist area, but Catholic and Protestant workers struck together over the biggest health and safety issue possible, the defence of their lives against sectarian killers.

Their action struck a chord with other workers and the "Irish republicanism is creed that feeds off martyrs and there areplenty of Unionists and Tories only too keen to provide them."

supine Northern Ireland Committee of the Irish Congress of Trade Unions even announced that they were considering a general strike to demand an end to the killings.

Of course, the demands and targets of such action are always real problems: the Catholics and Protestants of Hyster demanded "tougher security". But a general strike demanding a paramilitary ceasefire, a withdrawal of the army to barracks and the disbanding of the UDR would be something. to fight for. Above all, it would bring ordinary workers onto a political scene dominated by militarist élites.

THESLEFIT

By Anne Field Parting of the A Ways" read the headline over the Editorial Statement in last week's Militant which announced that Ted Grant had "split" from the organisation.

But Grant's "split" has all the signs of being an expulsion rather than a voluntary departure. The Editorial Statement accuses him of "effectively claiming a right of political veto over the Editorial Board" and of "abandoning any idea of acting as a loyal opposition (within Militant)".

Grant and his backers are now preparing to launch a monthly publication, going - they promise — over to a fortnightly, and then weekly, The collapse of Stalinism has left Militant in a theoretical vacuum (the Stalinist states whilst the ferocity of the Labour Party witch-hunt (which Militant never effectively opposed has pushed the organisation in the direction of SWPstyle street schedule as soon as possible. He has already secured premises and full-time staff.

The "parting of the ways" between Grant and Militant has been brought about by the recent decision of Militant to stand candidates against Labour and effectively to pull out of the Labour Party.

Militant supporter, Lesley Mahmood, stood in last year's Walton by-election in Liverpool, and a number of Militant supporters will be standing in the forthcoming General Election.

Grant opposed such a turn, but found himself in a small The case of the Walton by-election A candidate who said:

plus 32p minority. A special Militant conference last October voted by 93% to 7% in favour of the new line.

Militant accuses their former guru of "clinging to old formulas and increasingly turning them into ossified dogmas". Grant accuses his former organisation of "relegating theory and moving towards activism" Within limits, both such accusations are accurate.

Grant's political philosophy is one of "vulgar evolutionism": the Labour Party will inevitably evolve into a socialist party in which Militant would provide the leadership, whilst society as a whole will inevitably evolve into socialism (albeit, in number of cases, via Stalinism).

Such "old formulas". however, have not been transformed into "ossified dogmas". They always were "ossified dogmas" , shared by many of the leading figures in Militant who have now seen off Grant.

Grant's accusations of relegating theory and plunging into activism have a basis in reality. But both are the product of his own politics.

The collapse of Stalinism has left Militant in theoretical vacuum (the Stalinist states were manifestly not "post capitalist"), whilst the ferocity of the Labour Party witch-hunt (which Militant never effectively opposed) has pushed the organisation in the direction of SWP-style street Splits in left-wing organisations can sometimes help bring about political clarification. This is unlikely to be the case, however, in this "parting of the ways".

Grant will continue to cling to his "old formulas", whilst the Grant-free Militant will probably come to resemble the SWP, with more workers and fewer students, maybe.

Paradoxically, the biggest losers from the split might be the SWP themselves.

The SWP has generally had an open field in recruiting politically raw youth alienated from the Labour Party because of Kinnock's betrayals. But now Militant will be competing for the same audience, and no longer arguing the case as to why socialists should be in the It seems highly unlikely that a Militant minus Ted Grant will have anything more to offer the working class than a Ted Grant minus Militant. The last thing the left needs now is a second, more right-wing, Stalinismtainted version of the SWP. • More on the Militant split: see page 7.

An analysis of what is wrong with the Militant, written in 1966. E5 plus pence postage from SO, I Box 823, London SE15 4

Scan page 12

t my union meeting last A week, the SWP proposed affiliation to the Anti-Nazi League (ANL). Now, it's a fairly left-wing branch so no problem there. But the motion just said We agree to affiliate to the ANL" , so I thought it would be a good idea to flesh it out a bit with an addendum. After all,even left-wing branch members shouldn't be taken for granted.

I proposed that the branch look forward to participating in an open and democratic movement, maybe sending delegates to influence ANL policy, and inviting speakers to the branch. We wanted the ANL to campaign around issues such as bad housing and unemployment which make people vulnerable to fascist ideas.

Finally, we wanted the ANL to take on institutionalised racism and anti-semitism as part of their brief.

Debate went well. The addendum was passed and in the process we agreed to discuss affiliating to the Anti-Racist Alliance as well.

The fly in the ointment was the knee-jerk response from the usually perfectly reasonable SWP proposer who, in the context of anti-fascist debate, faced with the demand for a linked struggle against anti-black racism and anti-semitism, could not free himself from a ritual denunciation of the expansionist Israeli Such responses only serve to muddy the waters. A debate on Palestine, which the SWP then called for at a future meeting, is a separate issue.

Socialist Organiser is Sieh to e racosts and against the racists and fascists. But in the North East, the behaviour of the SWP has been worrying for all serious anti-fascist activists.

The ANL has appeared locally with no structures and no meetings, entirely controlled by the SWP. Yet, despite the existence locally of a healthy, democratic anti-fascist campaign, the ANL decided to call a demonstration in Sunderland on 22 February where there are (as far as we know) no ANL members, without any consultation, or even the decency to let us know.

This was simply a sectarian move by the sWP to try and claim the credit for the successful campaign by Sunderland Anti-Fascist Network and Tyne and Wear AntiFascist Association.

The local SWP is sectarian even by the SWP's own standards, and counter-productive (at the moment a demo would give BNP more publicity inan they deserve) and clearly aimed at by-passing the existing campaign.

Fortunately they nave o forced to back down - but ivists everywhere should be warn ANI - approach with Late Yours for unity, John Clifton Middlesbrough Jo Hill reviews 'The between Us' by Trev Griffiths With "The Gulf Between "Us" Trevor Griffiths takes on the task of dramatising the issues raised by ~ *o11 andar far Book Colin Foster reviews Hunting with the Politburo: A Gritt Hand Account of Russia's Young by A Craig Copetas i (Simen Schuster £15.99)

opetas was working for successful of Russia's new "co-operatives" (private companies). One day the boss returns to the office in a panic.

Can anyone find a supply of nylon stockings? Almost all work at the office - an information service and newsletter publisher - stops for 24 hours until someone finds some Western nylons.

The business's chief protector in the top ranks of the bureaucracy has been taken ill. He needs the nylons in order to bribe the nurses at the hospital to treat him properly.

Copetas's whole book is an enlarged version of this story. His former boss, Vladimir Yakovlev, swindles his Western partners shamelessly, repeatedly, even mindlessly: the only thing that matters for him each day is ia cut some deal which brings a profit The action takes place in a wartorn (unnamed) country with a bombed out shrine drawing the audience's focal attention. Two British workers are under orders to rebuild the outer wall before sundown.

One is a stereotypically bigoted small business man who represents the part British chauvinism played in supporting war, on a "man in the street" level. He is there purely to look out for himself and therefore he will build the wall to satisfy his own needs.

The other is a gilder who represents the universal media, metaphorically putting the thin gold veneer on anything distasteful. He is a mystical character who knows events before they happen, (makıng up the narrative to suit his purpose). Wearing a 'crown' of the craftsman optic, he is the unseen king of the war.

As the play progresses, that day. When he is not pulling a swindle or fixing a bureaucrat, he spends his time playing computer games on the IBM machines he has got from his Western partners on false pretences.

The people round Yakovlev, and thi other private business people, are much the same. Yakovlev's sidekick Roman Kudriavtsev explains: "I want to do two things with my life. Make a lot of dollars and go to America to fuck as many giris as possible."

The Western capitalists who rush their money into the ex-USSR are foolish, whether they deal with people like Yakovley or with officials. An American businessman with long experience in the USSR tells Copetas that he preferred the Brezhnevite old regime.

Before [Gorbachev] they were hap py to deal, and they always paid on time. They were extremely loyal...and they never expected anything more from you [in bribes] than what you could pick up at the duty-free store Heathrow Airport...

*The bottom line was that [they!

tually knew what was going on and (they] paid. Gorbachev's crowd doesn't seem to have a clue about what's going on and..they never pay on time."

Copetas finds one honest businessman — a farmer in Azerbaijan - but he is being crushed by the local mafia-like bureaucrats.

For a lot of reasons this book seems utterly unreliable. The text reads as if it was drafted just before the August 1991 coup, and then rushed into print with a botched update. Copetas's odd references to history are garbled: he has Stalin "grabbing control" in 1925 having previously "made a living by armed robbery, extortion, and giving information to the tsar's secret police", and then soon bringing that the shrine was used born as a military installation and as a creche and now contains the charred remains of infants' bodies, slowly emerges.

As it does, the desperation of the two workers and their Arab minder to complete the wall (hence hiding the sickening truth) increases.

The wall represents the solidity of the propaganda created by both sides' hiding the harsh facts of war from the people.

The shouts and cries of women with missing children protesting because the authorities won't give them satisfying answers to the whereabouts of the children are heard almost throughout the play.

They are the public who have to be protected from the bitter truths of war, to quell their possible As a statement about the part the media lie machine played in the about that "children who died of starvation were taken not to the cemetery but to the cook"

Copetas recounts many conversations where he tries to turn Yakovley to righteous dealing, but hardly explains why he stayed with the swindler for so long. Crassly, he seems to see US capitalism ("the democratic free market") as a paradise of sober hard work and straight dealing.

And he is not even sure of his conclusions. His basic drift is that of a section of the American Right: Gorbachev's reforms were all a sham;

nothing essential has changed in the Evil Empire. And then he has given the text a quick whiz through on the word processor to accommodate the August 1991 coup showing that a lot obviously had changed. war, che play uncompromisingly honest.

The only person to actually penetrate the wall is a nursery worker who demands to know the truth after this. She makes a powerful speech; distraught, holding out her hands, she asks the pertinent questions about the war. In this ed spot' , she is asking who else has blood on their hands and why. Her anger with God is disappointingly typical of the play.

The theme of blame and guilt for the atrocities is cleverly reiterated through the constant reference to hands. This metaphor is drawn together at the end of the play when the Gilder's writing above the shrine of "God is good" with a golden handprint becomes visible to the audience through the darkness.

Perhaps this was a popularist allusion to Maradona's hand of God, ie. the blame can always be shifted.

The play climaxes with an air-raid which kills the minder; but the Gilder (the media) lives on to move on to the next truths which have to be concealed.

At the end of the play, the audience is subjected to complete darkness with the horrifying and loud sound of bombs landing all around, a sobering experience which gives the audience a taste of a reality which most of us are luckily denied.

With this, the playwright is placing with the audience, the need for us all to look past the war propaganda to find our own answers.

Lacking in dialectical analysis, or hard malitical criticism. the play works as & thougnt-provoking denouncement of the media and of the nature of humanity but, unfortunately, not of capitalism.

These ultimate conclusions as to the reasons behind the war were left to the audience to work out for themselves.

He gives his argument a chauvinisti twist: Russians are irretrievably warped by "communism" (or maybe older traditions). They never tell the truth, they grab as grab can, they are sluggish, they don't want to work, they can think only of finding some scam which will enable them to live through another day. Then Copetas talks about a "revolution" being necessary in Russia. Who will make it if all the Russians are hopeless cases?

One thing, however, is clear.

Copetas likes capitalists. If he could say good things about Russia's new private profiteers, he would. But he finds them as corrupt and as bungling as the old bureaucrats. Indeed, many of them are the old bureaucrats or (like Yakovlev and his pals) the children of bureaucrats.

Available from SO, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA. Please add 2 (minimum 28 pence) for postage

Scan page 13

Kevin Costner as DA Jim Garrison and Donald Sutherland as 'X' in "JFK" Garrison Donald iutherland Socialist Organiser No. 514 page

----- pull-quotes -----

Ted Grant EVESON

were manifestly no post-capitalist),

Socialists and the

WHAT WE ARE AND BECOME

Entrepreneurs - and Why Soviet-Style Capitalism Can't Work,

speech, being particularly reminis- cent of Lady Macbeth's 'Out damn-

430g How the workers d0g made a revolution

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 514

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →