One bad deserves another
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-01-30Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 7
The British left is plagued with once-serious groupings who have degenerated into tragicomic caricatures of Marxist polities.
At the moment SO readers should try to engage some of the more seriou Militant supporters in open discussion for there are too many signs that both factions emerging from their recent split could travel that well-trodden path.
The most likely contenders for WRP-status are the majority (Taafe) group. They now nave an internanional "perspective" which was arrived at by circumstance, by improvisation, at best by the crudest empiricism and never theoretically argued or worked through with the membership. The perspective is to exit everywhere from work in social democratic (Labour or Socialist) parties.
In internal discussion the Taafe group argued that special circumstances justified a Scottish turn involving candidates opposing Labour in the general election. Recently, as readers will know, they have decided to leave the Labour Party "as a temporary measure" to prepare the forces to re-enter when the party shifts back to the left.
But what will shift it that far to the left and open it up? Why, the forces of history, comrades!
Now the Taafe majority argue that this "exceptional", "temporary" measure holds true everywhere and they insist on all their international sections breaking from work within, socialist parties. After decades of sucl work, that is a major decision and it should require the most thorough. reassessment of the group's politics, ideas and strategy yet - but of that there has been none.
The point about these wild zig-zags is not just whether they are right or wrong, but that a leadership which ca make such shifts with no theoretical reassessment, no political accounting, is a leadership which has a miseducated and apolitical membership. Such a membership could be steered in almost any direction.
That is the seedbed for WRP-style degeneration.
The Grant faction appear much more sane. As a result of their decision to organise a proper opposition a conference recently (35 delegates) their leadership (Grant, Rob Sewell and Alan Woods) have been expelled and oppositionists everywhere are being expelled - *for belonging to an organised opposition", I was told by one of them. They will have serious problems, too, however.
For example, they oppose the Walton stunt and the "Scottish turn" but are ambivalent in their attitude to Dave Nellist standing in Coventry SE. If he does they seem likely to support him, despite their Labour Party line — because "there are special circumstances", etc. (Talk about failing to learn the lessons!)
Secondly, one of the centrepieces of their political identity will be the idea that the USSR and the old Eastern European states were post-capitalist and that the collapse of those "planned economies" were the biggest defeat for the working class this century. This means that what exists there now is some sort of historical regression with no obvious cause - plenty of room there for intellectual implosion!
So the Grant faction have a political identity which would make Socialist Action feel at home, the Taafe group argued in an internal document that "much could be learnt from the organisational methods of the SWP", and in all this the raison d'etre of Marxist groups doesn't get a hearing.
Clarity of ideas, sharp discussion and political accounting - that is the currency we deal in, everything else is just sect-buildingSee also page 11.
----- pull-quotes -----
turn THB POUCAL FRONT