Sticking up for the Seventies
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-01-30Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
To build a thriving women's movement you can't just focus on economic oppression; you have to relate to their oppression in Picket of Millwall Fire Station, in support of sexually harassed the statutory two years over more urgent operations that haven't serv ed their time. Still the backlog wouldn't go.
Next, people were expected to run up and down the country to find a "vacancy" in a suitable hospital, often paying their own fares. Still, those embarrassingly long lists showed up in the figures Next, operations were contracted out to the cheap end of the privati health market, but the NHS spent too much time cleaning up after the botched jobs.
Finally, military hospitals have been drafted into the effort to make the figures appear respec table before the deadline on April 1. That gives the electioneers a clear 8 days before the election te parade the results of their cosmeti surgery- privatisation has run into a he new Russian "chief of few problems. It seems that no-one trusts the bureaucracy to privatise itself. The privatisations are seen as just another opportunity for the apparatchiks to garner a crop of bribes.
Fitter enterprises are sold off cheap in closed auctions in return for backhanders. Or else, the bureaucracy are snapping up choice Labour seats economics than any other MP.
To you find Socialist 1 Organiser sectarian?
Factionally-minded?
Inward-looking?
Maybe you would prefer socialist, the new fortnightly paper which prides itself on being non-sectarian and outwardlooking?
But what's this? The latest front page of socialist is all about the infighting between the Anti-Nazi League and the AntiRacist Alliance; the one before, about the infighting in Militant.
The "non-sectarians" seem to be much more absorbed in left infighting than the nasty Trot skyists are! What distinguishes socialist from Workers' Power, Workers' Hammer and suchlike is that its treatment of intra-left squabbles is as if from the viewpoint of the fascinated but inactive sidelines voveur. rather than the participant; and that is hardly an ad. vantage.
socialist claims to be selling well, but has told subscribers that it will fold unless it can raise an extra €12,000 in the next few weeks. Noua disagree min socialist-feminist Liz Millward's point (SO 511) that we want a women's movement which bases itself on the needs of the most oppressed women, and that aims for a total transformation of women's position in society, rather than just promoting a few women to the ruling class. I must, however, take issue with Liz's implicit assessment of "1970s feminism"
It is true, of course, sociologically, that the women's movement was predominantly middle class in composition, though I am tempted to point out that the same could be said for the revolutionary left. But the hallmark of early '70s feminism was an attempt to weld a socialist understanding of society as a whole with the experience of women's oppression - an experience which had been ignored or denied for decades if the revolutionary left.
Many of the 'figures' of "70s feminism had themselves been active in mixed revolutionary organisations.
Their aim was to enrich the Marxist movement, not to reject it. I think they succeeded in this aim - Socialist Organiser's politics on women, as I understand them, emphasize the specificity of women's oppression, whilst arguing that its historical roots are to be found in the development of class in society.
Socialist Organiser has consistently argued against reducing women's oppression to class oppression, and has acknowledged that women of all classes share aspects of oppression.
"Socialist feminists should learn not only from the 'failures' of Socialist Organiser did not suck this understanding out of its collective thumb, but partly, at least, through an active engagement with that very 1970s feminism which Liz is at best ambivalent about burying.
Towards the end of the 70s, and certainly in the 1980s, there is a strong case for saying that feminism "lost its way" and became preoccupied with individual rather than society-wide solutions.
But I think it is quite unfair to take this out of its historic context. The late '70s also saw defeats for the working class movement generally, demoralisation which led to increased support for fascist organisations, a Labour government which moved consistently to the right and attacking the working class.
1979 saw the election of an ideologically-motivated Conservative government with a project of atomising and destroying any collective opposition. It would have been a miracle if the women's movement alone emerged untouched from these experiences.
We should not be uncritical of those feminists who seemed to fall lock, stock and barrel for individual solutions, nor should we ignore the reasons for this.
Socialist feminists should learn not only from the "failures' of "70s feminism, but also from its strengths.
It is not possible to build a women's movement with impeccable Marxist credentials alone. Such a movement must engage with women's immediate experience of oppression. This can be workplace-based experience of low pay and bad conditions, but it can also be the experience of being beaten, raped or simply not being taken seriously. variants of radical feminim ome eason.
have become so powerful, even amongst avowed socialist feminists, is that radical feminism does engage with these issues, provides an explanation and, most importantly, expresses gut anger and outrage at women's oppression.
Socialist feminism will get nowhere if it simply relies on cold, pat, ideologically pure answers. It will attract no-one. Liz might assert that we "cannot pretend '70s feminism never happened" Well, I for one do not want LU.
Formally, Liz and I probably have the same analysis of women's oppression. I cannot share her dismissive attitude to our sisters' struggle in the 1970s. Without them, we wouldn't have a women's column in a revolutionary paper.
Scan page 7
Socialist Organiser No. 514 page
----- pull-quotes -----
WOMENYS EMI
'70s feminism, but also from its strengths."
NOMEN Si MEAN