Unite against racism!
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-01-30Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 3
Tax the rich!
ven Livingstone supports the (ARA). Last week, LIvingstone wrote a newspaper column denouncing ARA's rival, the Anti-Nazi League (ANL) and the Socialist Workers Party (SWP) which runs it.
Where was this piece of intra-left polemic printed? In Tribune? In Socialist Organiser? Campaign Group News, the Morning Star? No - in the Sun! The Sun! The Sun, which itself deserves to be the target of anti-racist demonstrations!
For the future Lord Redken to use his column in the Sun to attack anti-racist campaign, socialist organisation like the SWP, is a major scandal.
Livingstone's attack on the ANL came only a few days after supporters of the two campaigns engaged in a public fist-fight to decide which group should march at the head of the previous weekend's anti-racist demonstration!
The new drive to mount a powerful anti-racist campaign is only three months old. But already, as these incidents and others demonstrate, we find ourselves once again ensnared in lunatic, self-destructive, intra-left factionfighting of the sort which crippled the movement against the Gulf War one year ago. And the same political groups and individuals are responsible.
Because of that faction-fighting, we did a great deal less against the Gulf War than we could have done had the left been united. We will pay a heavy price if we waste our strength in irresponsible intra-left factionalism now instead of organising a serious campaign to stop the growth of British racism and fascism.
How can we stop this crippling factionalism? The truth is you can not stop factionalism in the present state of the left and the labour movement - anyone who tells you otherwise is a demagogue or a fool. What you can do is prevent factionalism crippling us.
The root of this poisonous ARAANL factionalism lies in the conflicting claims of the two groupings monopoly in anti-racist organising. Everything flows from this claim and from the way the campaigns making such claims are structured.
In turn, this is rooted in the desire of competing political groups to have and use "their own" factionally policed and controlled antiracist campaign.
"Inside" the ANL, running it as an 'operation', , is the SWP. Inside ARA is Socialist Action entwined with prominent individuals like Livingstone. These are the bone struc Graham Bash Vadimir Derer Terry Eagleton Jatin Haria (Labour Party Black Sertionsi Dorothy Meterw Joe Marino John Mellroy John Nicholson Petermatchell Members of the Advisory Committee [EI GrEENNI FROM BIDEORGI CHOSSESECEMP EI thellett whowere opposed ta the Labour Party's witch-hunt against Socialist Organiser. Views expressed in articles erertnernesponsib ikty of he authors and not of the Advisory ditorian Board.
Small children in tears in biscuits after paying increased taxes: that was the picture of Britain under a Labour government presented by the last Tory political broadcast.
Such is the look-after-numberone mentality bred by 13 years of Tory economics that this ludicrous paranoia even seems to be having some effect. Never mind the facts!
• The Tories' scare-stories about Labour taxes are based on adding up all the increases in public spending which Labour people have mentioned as desirable or possible and assuming that they are all made in one year. The same method of tures: the affiliated organisations and celebrities are the loose flesh of the organisations. The SWP is a sizeable organisation; Socialist Action is a miniscule splinter of the old IMG dependent on its symbiotic links with Livingstone and others.
In the anti-war movement a year ago, Socialist Action's influence came from people like Livingstone and from having committed members like Carol Turner in key positions in CND. Its influence was utterly destructive and pernicious. Itself committed to "Victory to Iraq" as a (private) slogan, Socialist Action with its friends witchhunted others in the anti-war movement who dared go as far as calling for American troops to withdraw from the Gulf. As we said at the time, they and their allies thereby reduced the anti-war movement to "the calculation, applied to Tory statements, would show them running a budget deficit next year bigger than Labour's alleged £35 billion spending increase!
• Since 1979, the Tories have increased taxes for most people -while cutting them drastically for the very rich.
• Labour proposes to raise taxes only for the rich and well-off -many of whom now pay a lower rate of tax than the average person, because they are exempted from the nine per cent deduction for National Insurance. • Labour's proposals would only go a small way towards reversing the greater inequality of after-tax income developed since 1979 by Tory tax and other policies.
Never mind all those facts: the Tory-dominated press has been politics of the madhouse".
The rivalry of the ANL and the ARA now threatens to reduce the anti-racist and anti-fascist movement also to the politics of the madhouse.
The problem lies not only with Socialist Action and Livingstone (whose own anti-racist credentials are far from impeccable: he worked very closely and for a long time with Gerry Healy's now scattered WRP, which was blatantly anti-semitic). The SWP also pursues grotesquely narrow aims in this work.
The SWP decided to set up the ANL only when it saw the scale and scope of the anti-Le Pen demonstration last November: at its conference only a couple of weeks earlier, there was no mention of any such initiative. In these matters the SWP is not entirely devoid of a funshouting at the top of its collective voice about the Labour threat to well-filled pockets.
The din is having some effect on= because Labour is running scared, piteously protesting that it will raise taxes only very slowly and gradually. The facts are clear: so is the destruction and barbarism created by the Tories' denial of cash to the Health Service, to public sector housing and to other public services. Repeated opinion polls show that most people would rather pay more taxes and have better public services.
The top ten per cent in Britain today own 53 per cent of marketable wealth and almost all privately-owned land and shares. Labour should say boldly that it will tax the rich to provide services for the working class.
damental sense of responsibility, but in practice it does tend to operate according to the principles, the guidelines and the morality of the Stock Exchange speculator.
It arbitrarily wound up the original AN in the "70s when the SWP leaders felt they could gain more in narrow party terms by so doing. (And after they had led the ANL to the disgrace of choosing to go ahead with a pop festival instead of mobilising to defend the Bengalis of Brick Lane in East London, on which the fascists chose to march at the same time.)
The SWP's idea of the work of the ANL now is best illustrated by the fact that ANL bookstalls in colleges carry the full range of SWP "anti-Zionist" literature denouncing Israel - this in conditions where Nazi anti-semitism is rampant again and where, in consequence, fighting anti-semitism will have to be one of the central concerns of any adequate anti-racist movement. On our letters page, we carry an account of rank and file SWPers in the teachers' union responding to proposals that their union opposes anti-semitism with... diatribes against Israel.
What can we do to escape from the craziness of ANL-ARA factionfighting into the world of seriously building against racism and • Reject and fight against the idea that any permanently organised campaign, either ANL or ARA, or another, has a monopoly on • Insist on properly accountable democratic structures for such bodies. • Organise major demonstrations and campaigns not through either of the pretenders to a monopoly but through ad hoc committees which will include ANL and ARA, and others. • Reject all attempts - of the sort we saw on the Gulf War demos by committees or campaigns to impose narrow restrictions and controls on what slogans can and can not be carried on demonstrations.
Hard decisions will sometimes have to be taken and imposed -tactical decisions about physical battles for example - but such decisions will gain greater authority coming from ad hoc, truly representative committees set up for a particular action than they could possibly have as decisions of any grouping claiming a contested monopoly in this work.
Not the least argument against the present state of affairs is that it precludes serious action because the authority claimed by both ANL and ARA is not, and will not be, generally accepted The great anti-Vietnam war demonstrations were organised ad hoc and so was last weekend's giant demonstration in Paris. Dozens of organisations co-operated loosely and democratically for a specific purpose and Paris saw a tremendous demonstration of anti-racist strength.
Both the ANL, organised and controlled by the SWP, which is already peddling thinly-disguised anti-semitism within the ANL, and ARA, fronted by Ken Livingstone, must be called to order by those who are concerned to build a strong anti-racist and anti-fascist movement in Britain, now, while there is still time!
The best thing now would be for the ANL and ARA to hold joint discussions, inviting other interested parties, with a view to dissolving existing structures, and replacing them with one campaign organised more loosely and more democratically.
Meanwhile, democratically broad organised local committees should be set up under the rubric of "ANL/ARA". They should affiliate to both organisations, and fight for unity.
* The emancipagion oil the warkm class is also the emancipation of all human beings without distinction of Seк0...
Ka Merp SpeedsuOrganisen PD Boy BREW london S01514FA Renasdesk: 011.639 7966 Latest bie for seportsa Monder Editor: John 0 Mahony Published by WL Publications Ltd, 29, Lendor Printed by Tridant Press, Edenbridge Ple Post Office Articles do not necessarily reflect the views af Socialist Organiser and are in unla S-13
Scan page 4
Socialist Organiser No. 514 page 4
----- pull-quotes -----
Aldansory Eilitoroad Board
Soments because their country because their parents can't afford chocolate