Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

"How to beat the racists and fascists'

Socialist Organiser no. 513, 23 January 1992 · scan pp. 14–15 · about 1,285 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 14

*Labour "Traq - unsafe haven". 7.00, Man- "Fighting racism and fascism, 11.00-5.00, Conway Hall, Holborn, chester Town Hall. Iraqi and Kur- WallapayOrganiser expand Thursday 23 January Manchester University, 1.00. Speaker Nik Barstow Hull University, 7.30.

Speaker Paul Hampton Poly of North London, Hollowa Road site, 1.00 Monkwearmouth College, 1.00. Speaker Habda Rashid Park Lane College, 12.30. Speaker Mike Fenwick York University, 1.15. Speaker Nick Lowles St John's College, York, 7.00. Speaker Nick Lowles Newcastle, Rossetti Studios, 7.30 Sheffield, SCCAU, West St, 7.30. Speaker Pete Radcliff Leeds, Swarthmore Centre, 7.30 Anti-racist action Friday 31 January Anti-Fascist Action social: the Bhundu Boys, Stoke Newington Town Hall, London. £7.50/€6.00 Saturday 22 February "Close the BP HO".

Looking ahead Students demonstrate against debt. National NUS have organised a demonstration to oppose student poverty. Assemble: 12.00 on Wednesday 12 Fighting the right. Sellingether paper.

120 copies of Socialist Organiser were sold on the Asylum Bill demonstration.

12 copies were sold before a Socialist Organiser meeting on fighting racism at Nort London College.

10 copies were sold at Whitechapel tube, East 12 copies were Glasgow Poly. Brighton, Great Eastern pub, 7.30. Speaker Sab Sanghera Friday 24 January Richmond-Upon-Thames College, 1.00. Speaker Paul Ramsamooj Goldsmiths College, 1.00. Speaker Jill Mountford Huddersfield Poly, Conference Room, 1.00. Speaker Mike Fenwick Saturder 26 camem Bipply Sandy demonstroR.

Demonstrate: 12.00, St. Nicholas Church, London SE18 Saturday 28 March Oppose police racism.

Demonstrate: 12.30, Plashel Park, London E6. Called by Newham Monitoring Project February in Battersea Park, South London Workers bert l9nz will bembeibi atlaxton Homse, North London Trom Fridayed to Sunderr 15iJuky...

PALERTY Striking GEC workers read SO's coverage of their dispute.

If you would like to help us sell Socialist Organiser, write to PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA. Thursday 30 January Kent University, Eliot College,. 6.00 Liverpool Institute, Room 58, 12.30. Speaker Gail Cameron London SO Forum meeting. LSE, Room A142 7.30. Speakers include Ernie Roberts and John O'Mahony onde Monder 21. ender/ dish speakers and Jeremy Corbyn Libert-see elp Socialist received 88,65 this ocialist Organiser week, bringing our fund total to £6292.58.

We aim to raise £10,000 from donations and fundraising to buy new equipment.

This weekend supporter: in London are organising two jumble sales and car boot sales to raise funds.

How our readers help You can help our paper by sending in a donation to help us buy new equipment. You will be helping the figh for real socialism in a practical way.

Send a cheque or postal order (made out to Socialist Organiser) to SO, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA.

of the left Socialist Worker splits and its British Justing An CATALYST Worker: Allance for Liberty pamph MARXISM meeting, 6.00 Join our 823, 4NA. These meetings are sponsored by the Alliance for Workers Liberty. For details of Socialist Organiser your area, phone Mark 071-639 7965 "Socialists and the general election, Essex University SO Club! Win Socialist Organiser need more regular money to help us expand. We want to take our message to more workers.

We are running a "200 Club" draw with a monthly prize of £100. Surplus money goes to thi paper. You can enter the "200 Club" for as little as f1 per month.

Get details of the "200 Club" from your local SO seller.

uS posi Al IL, 823, London SE15 SE1 phenomenon Laurens Otter continues our debate on the class nature of the Stalinist states goth Chris Arthur's position and Tom Rigby's (S0506) are part and parcel of the "Marxist" tendency to conflate class systems into larger brackets than Marx accepted.

The usual myth is that Marx divided class-dominated systems into four, when what he actually said was that anyone who thought that was an obvious "Dummkopf" [blockhead).

Thus - despite the fact that in Capital Marx clearly distinguishes the two - entrepreneurial capitalism and mercantilism are both assumed to be "capitalism", an analysis which conveniently fits the thesis that a class system can only arise in a country after that particular country has the appropriate insurrection.

This thesis, however, is not to be found in Marx. For instance, the French Revolution came in a country that was already Mercantilist, though conflicts had arisen between the system and its political government. No stable mercantilist regime arose since mercantilism had already exhausted its progressive potential and - for the political and military defence of the new regime — needed to introduce new technological and social forms, which in a short time came into conflict with mercantilism.

This new technology and these new class relations were introduced far more rapidly in Great Britain, an island which had had a revolution to introduce mercantilism, but not entrepreneurial capitalism. That country was forced, primarily for military reasons, to advance its technology in ways that affected social relations. The introduction of industrialentrepreneurial production in Britain led very rapidly to the Great Reform Bill and the apparent overthrow of "Old Corruption".

Mercantilism was established faster in France than England — in both countries it was in response to the needs of revolutionary wars - even though it was England that had had the revolution.

No-one in France, in 1789, con sciously set about unleashing an entrepreneurial capitalist revolution. The aims of the early leaders were all in terms of progressive mercantilism, though these immediately conflicted with the aspirations of the more radical revolutionary visionaries as also with the self-interests of the sans culottes at home and the slaves abroad.

No English Puritan revolutionary conceived of a mercantilist system; there too was immediate conflict with underclasses and those who had a more far-reaching revolutionary perspective.

Arthur and Rigby are both arguing on the basis that bureaucratic collectivist system could only be found in the Soviet Union (and in subsequent Stalinist states) since only in these has there been bureaucratic-collectivist revolution — as if anyone consciously ever set out to make bureaucratic-collectivist revolution.

It has always been fundamental to bureaucratic-collectivist analysis of the Soviet Union that the new class system is found not only there but also in modified forms within fascism, in Keynesian reformism, in the vast complexes of monopoly capitalism and in a host forms throughout the Third World.

Indeed, the earliest form of the analysis (that of Simone. Weil) started from the fact that in Weimar Germany members of the bureaucracies of business, ol trade unions, of political parties, and of the state appeared-to be able to move into each others' jobs with virtually no difficulty. (An observation which would be even truer now).

Arthur's argument (which amounts to an adaptatibi of Thatcherite triumphalism) rests on the fact that Stalinism has collapsed (though only in the Soviet Union and (its European dependencies). He would not, presumably, retrospectively, argue against a capitalist analvsis of the French Revolution on the strength of the Bourbon restoration of 1815; nor against the view that England after the Great Reform Bill was capitalistdominated on the strength of the Tory (land-owning and merçantilist) revival of the 1850s.

It is generally held that in Britain the compensation paid by Labour for nationalised industries financed the take-over and asset-stripping corporatism of the subsequent period. It is obvious that the economic mainstay of Thatcherism was not in the productive industries (as it had been of traditional Adam Smith entrepreneurial industry but was a parasitism, the political expression of asset-stripping.

In no way does the existence of such a parasitism disprove the bureaucratic collectivist analysis, any more than the fact that "Old Corruption" was given a new temporary lease of life by the needs of the new capitalist industry, means that Marx was mistaken in the Manifesto and that such capitalism was not dominant.

Otter, Salop

Scan page 15

INDUSTR Socialist Organiser No. 513 page

----- pull-quotes -----

GEC DEAL •EL.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 513

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →