Too much money too little film
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-01-23Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 13
sure was he of his skill, that he knocked him out in the first minute.
By Dion Desta ateosie boxers ine rino nne OL MS Not nec asoma (he ONT SONEC in Ine way he saw it, "no Viet Cong fan mail from Britain he looked toward the Third World ekiyer eng . gme ano sica in parucular. de However, he was described in ane wile - working class people. CALCHICE PODU WIL HALV — DIACK often pointed out that Black is muser Yet it is often forgotten that there of all! me mosu amous ace oine oanea were many who hated him. He wa He was born Cassius Marcellus Clay called cocky and arrogant. It was hard dodging the draft but carried on trainin 1942 in Louisville, Kentucky. e to understand that here was 29 he was an intelligent, witty and arrogant black allowed to box apain. After some Tokyo. Lie dona Placas Opel Ali had predicted a fifth round vieDecime more ano more cri asioner: tory. My dad says that as Ali walked where he outsmarted George Foreman. with the racism he witnessed and even, through the crowd, he was spat upon it is said, threw the medal he had won and some people tried to throw pun- up LISteMing for the United States into the river Ches anme radio.
men, millionaires, PAHA TIS ourth round. But in the next round good boxer. He was a showman who Ali demolished Cooper, and the fighi made trite but funny poems about his predictions about the exact round in conniason the muei-aneed eram pion for the World Title. After round spoke out against oppression.
boxing nad never seen anytning like to come out. In round seven, Ali Belinda Weaver Billy Bathgate Billy Bathgate is a *so what" movie. Nothing happens in it, and if it did, you wouldn't care because no a waxwork, not cinema. It's dead in the water.
What it does have is "production values" - movie-speak for sets, costumes, cars, etc. New York gangsterism, 1935-style, has been faithfully recreated on screen, but to no purpose. The director, Robert Benton, has nothing new to say, and the actors have nothing to do.
It's an adaptation of an EL Doctorow novel of the same name. The Billy of the title is a poor Bronx kid who falls under the spell of gangster Dutch Schultz. To Billy, whose mother works in a sweatshop/ laundry for four dollars a week, Schultz is a role model - someone who clawed his way out of poverty and made himself the richest man in New York. The American Dream, only this time with guns.
Perhaps the film is about Billy's disenchantment with Dutch once he sees him up close, sees his creepy paranoia, his psychopathic rages. But perhaps it isn't. Billy is such a blank that it's impossible to tell what (if anything) is going on behind his blandly handsome face. The actor who plays Billy is too old for the part, so he plays young by playing dumb. He's a lunkhead with a half-open mouth. Since Billy is supposed to be both smart and lucky, and the centre of the movie, this is Benton's first mistake.
The other main parts are also poorly cast. Nicole Kidman is more high school sweetheart than femme fatale; she simply doesn't have the presence to play Drew preston, a wised up society dame who gets her kicks by sleeping with gangsters. When she seduces Billy, they're like goofy teenagers; she's too young for the older woman role. The role of Drew called for someone debonair and insouciante, someone mysterious, fascinating, exciting. Kidman is nice.
And Dustin Hoffman as Schultz brings nothing to the party. His portrayal of a mean little psychopath is all externals - the clothes, the tight lips, the tight walk. His sudden murderous rages come from nowhere; we never get inside this little crook.
There has to have been more in The figure of Ali, now afflicted with Light Heavyweight gold medal at uear as none towa:
Nevertheless, there were eleven white WISCH HE WOWE SO DIS ODDOneTE AmEPue WaS UsuaI TEUE the novel than we get on the screen, but the appeal of Doctorow's books (they have a kind of sparkle) is in the writing, not in the plots. When the stories are extracted, they congeal; they badly need the leavening of his style to succeed.
Without Doctorow's writing, the film adds up to nothing. Its premise that fearless people lead charmed lives is piffle. Drew only survives because Billy is watching out for her. and Billy survives because the director needs him to.
The main thing wrong with Billy Bathgate is too much money. ms reneres to craue buncuessne Tirune literally danced the Ali shuffle. . Then stribi he would use his tremendous punching Vietnam.
ww dau was one or ne mant thousands who packed Wembley to see предалиеми was StOPPeU.
Soon after Ali was 22, he fought six, Liston sat in his corner reluctant Everything is lavishly done, there are crowd scenes galore, and the period has been painstakingly recreated. In this kind of set-up, the script is usually the least of a director's worries. But films need more than sets and costumes to succeed;
they need a story, they need a point.
Actors get suffocated by all this "production values" paraphernalia; it's the period picture equivalent of being upstaged by special effects. Not every movie needs the "big" treatment.
Hollywood has binged too long. It's time for a purge. ne useu Just when Ali was at the peak of his The he was a Muslim and rejected his name. Rather like beautiful he was the most beautiful He served a short jail sentence for The regained the World Title by beating Joe Frazier.
1 remember the mehts used to stay pr o de Boxing might be a barbaric sport but Ali represented more than just a opponents and who always put his inerwewer on the He was proud to be black and he The was and remains a hero of mine!
mother can be prevented from abusing herself and the child with drugs.
Women were shown being taken to hospital in manacles, living in cramped prison cells; reportedly they are chained to their beds.
One woman was still in prison six months after giving birth to her baby, seemingly without any rights of access to the child.
This inhuman, brutal system was defended by one smug administrator — who then admitted she hadn't even visited the prison to which the pregnant women were being condemned. Unfortunately, the programme didn't ask why the overwhelming majority of women in prison happened to be black.
The authorities made the wild claim that no changes in the statistics for women seeking antenatal treatment had been detected, yet the film showed police squads hunting women down who had become fugitives to escape prison.
Other American states are watching this so-called "experiment" with a view to adopting it elsewhere. The implications are frightening.
Concern for the welfare of unborn children is legitimate; our system tackles the problem by completely trampling on the rights of pregnant women who are victims of drug abuse, not criminals.
It turns their pregnancy into a nightmare. And why stop there? Cigarettes and alcohol can cause foetal damage, too.
This criminalisation of women is not just an indirect attack on abortion rights — what greater harm can be caused to a foetus than death -but it could also force women to opt for abortion rather than face a prison term.
It will inevitably drive women away from seeking vital health care and in the case of South Carolina, lead women to have their babies in other states.
The prison option is favoured as it is a less costly, more convenient alternative to providing a decent health service. The last decade has seen a massive cut in welfare in the US.
The individual woman is blamed for harming her child and punished accordingly without reference to the social conditions which, for instance, breeds drug addicts.
In the climate of guilt and fear directed against "bad mothers" it wouldn't be a massive step towards the forced sterilisation of some women considered to be unfit to bear children.
"Health fascism" is an abused term which is bandied around on the left, but this barbaric project must rank as one of the best examples of it.
----- pull-quotes -----
барыи Muhammedsı thẹi a 0 eT5 baleM theigrenes, heamen- In 1963, Ali came to England to
character in it has any drive, interest or charm. It's a tableau,
Boxing hokenlerewhps erar abeen.
starcu bui e boral nab o. the Olampic