How 1920-21 paved the way for today's conflicts The Treaty and the Troubles
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-01-23Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
Those who do not learn from history indefinite imprisonment without trial - of the Bogside, the Catholic ghetto was banned. The organisers defied the under the perfectly preserved walls of ban and the march went ahead. It was the old Protestant city, soldiers opened a peaceful, unarmed protest, which fire without warning. armoured cars and soldiers armed to - many of them teenagers - outright, Television Patrick Murphy Treaty make it down from the mast, Irish traitors/It's the flag we republicans claim/It will never belong to Free Staters/For you've brought nothing on it but shame.
That is how the republican nationalist tradition has summed up the events leading to the partition of Ireland in 1921.
After years of bitter, costly war with the British, the Sinn Feindominated government in Dublin achieved not a republic, but a Free State (Saorstat) and not Irish unity but partition.
It was a momentous, decisive period and was well-portrayed in the 2-hour Thames TV and RTE coproduction, "The Treaty", last Wednesday.
"The Treaty" was a dramatic reconstruction of the negotiations between Lloyd George's coalition government and the Irish delegates led by Arthur Griffith and Michael Collins. If you had no interest in or little knowledge of Irish history, the film's dilemma was still of universal interest; this was "principle versus compromise, , the conflict personified in the person of Michael Collins more than in anyone else.
The portrayal of Collins was the kindest, though it was far from sycophantic or uncritical, and, to this day, his assessment of what all the republican politicians were up to has always struck me as more accurate than the nationalist ballad quoted above.
"I am going to London", he said, "to do a thing that those who send me know has to be done, but haven't got the courage to do themselves"
The last General Election in in 1918. Outside of Ulster, the old Nationalist Party led by John Redmond was crushed and humiliated by Sinn Fein. The dramatic upsurge in Sinn Fein support was a result of their role in the war with Britain which followed the execution of the leaders of the 1916 Sinn Fein won 73 seats, the Nationalists 6. Sinn Fein refused to take their seats and instead set up a separate Irish parliament in Dublin (the Dail), formed their own army, the IRA, and proclaimed their right to govern Ireland.
The British declared the Dail illegal, banned Sinn Fein and, from August 1919, a still more bitter war ensued between the British forces and Royal Irish Constabulary (RIC)
and the IRA.
The British government had difficulty recruiting police locally, and the RIC were driven out of large parts of the south, so they sent in specially recruited reinforcements of ex-soldiers and police called the Black and Tans.
The Tans soon developed a welldeserved reputation for brutality and bad discipline. They ferociously reacted to one successful IRA attack by burning down the city of Cork.
The changes in Irish politics pressurised the British government to come up with some acceptable political arrangement.
Their main aims had nothing to do with democracy or rights, of course. Lloyd George was head of a coalition government dominated by the Conservative Party and they were determined to keep Ireland within the Empire and to protect condemned to relive it On January 30 1972, a march in Derry the teeth. to protest against internment -took place in an area bristling with the northern Unionists from rule by Dublin. This they did effectively. n 1920, Lloyd George tried to pre-empt the democratic demands of the republicans by passing the Government of Ireland Act which introduced Home Rule with two separate parliaments, the southern Parliament would rule 26 counties, the northern Parliament 6 counties.
It was sold as a temporary arrangement, and a Council of Ireland was set up in which both Parliaments would be represented and which, Lloyd George claimed, would lead to re-unification.
This was never a serious possibility. The real drive to partition Ireland was coming from the northern Unionists, not from Westminster.
On May 20 1920, the first elections to the Stormont Parliament in Belfast were held and the Unionistdominated Parliament opened in June.
The decisive events were occur! ing, however, on the streets and in the workplaces. When the marchers got to the fringes They kept on shooting, killing 13 men The Loyalists attempted to establish their permanent control over the north, and pre-empt any plans at unity by driving Catholics out of Belfast, or out of mixed areas and mixed workplaces.
There were vicious pogroms of Catholics and Protestant trade union activists who tried to protect some of the class unity built up in the post-war years of industrial militancy in Belfast.
Sinn Fein, meanwhile, totally rejected the 1920 Act and the Anglo-Trish war continued.
It was becoming costly for both sides however.
The Government's response to the Troubles was, chiefly, brutal violence and coercion.
It was a policy proving very unpopular internationally, relations with the US were in danger, the growing Labour Party, the press, and even the King, publicly opposed the extremes of repression.
The ex-PM, Asquith, commented that "there are things being done in Ireland which would disgrace the blackest annals of the lowest and wounding 29 others. died not long afterwards).
The soldiers claimed that they were fired on: none of the many independent reporters present saw any evidence for this.
It was outright murder by British soldiers gone beserk and out of control.
despotism in Europe".
In 1921, Lloyd George offered to negotiate with Sinn Fein. He convinced the Conservatives to consider the best compromise available, helped by the resignation of arch-Unionist, Bonar Law, and his replacement as Tory leader by the more amenable Austen Chamberlain.
Sinn Fein accepted the invitation to talks. They were war-weary, exhausted and unconvinced that they could sustain, let alone step up, the war with Britain.
This weariness on both sides came across strongly in the reconstruction of the talks, but, above all, the drama conveyed the way in which the Irish delegates were outmanoeuvred.
Lloyd George suggested that the area controlled by the North would be so small as to be unviable, the exact division would be decided by a Boundary Commission.
Unity would be inevitable, delayed.
The flip position was a guarantee that a major, tion was a guarantee that a escalated war was the alternative.
In the end, Lloyd George confronted the Irish delegates with an ultimatum - sign the Treaty with all its risks and enjoy peace, or refuse and take the consequences.
He did not allow time to refer back to Dublin or discuss further. Griffith was convinced that there was no alternative, Collins became convinced quickly and, in the end, they all signed.
slightly contrived to make the tale clearer, but, with some qualifications, it was a story welltold.
It is irritating that such productions have to be laced with bits of stage Irishry' - the only time the ordinary people of Ireland come into the scene, they are huddled around bonfires in Dublin streets, crooning rebel ballads background to the key conversations of the leading characters.
This mock Sean O'Casey was reinforced by other historical drama favourites like women in the background "pulling the strings', accidentally making decisive suggestions, offering tea, wiping the sweating brow and so on.
The tragic consequences of the Treaty were hidden in a lot of innocuous subtitles at the end. The Treaty was ratified in Dublin but the two big hopes for the Irish were cruelly and quickly denied.
Peace it certainly did not bring Sinn Fein split and De Valera and Cathal Brugha, who had sent Collins to negotiate, led an anti-Treaty force in a bloody civil war against Collins' new Irish government.
More nationalists lost their lives in that war than in all the fighting since 1917.
The Boundary Commission finally reported in 1925 and Northern Ireland included all 6 counties controlled in 1920.
So the Treaty achieved neither peace nor unity and, from the point of view of the 1990s, its cost in blood, misery and conflict appears all the greater.
It was terrible statement.
on the shoulders of Michael Collins.
This film and recent work by Tim Pat Coogan and others has redressed some of the balance.
dilemma faced republicans in 1920 wis ma same as the greatest dilemma facing them to this day.
There was and is a great tension between the republican desire to break the link with Britain and the nationalist desire to win a unified Ireland.
That tension is imposed by the politics, identity and power of the Northern Protestant minority, a minority with decisive support in 1920/1 from the British government.
The great political mistake of Sinn Fein in 1921 was, arguably, to treat the desire to separate from Britain as more important than the desire to retain a united Ireland.
Certainly, in this dramatised' version, the amount of time spent in the negotiations discussing the relatively trivial question of the oath of allegiance and the exact relations with Britain was way out of proportion to the time spent dealing with Irish unity and the need to avoid partition This Treaty is a much-analysed historical episode, but if I had to draw one lesson for Irish polities today, it would be that democrats and republicans might again have to consider links between Britain and Ireland in order to unite the contry.
Scan page 13
Nicole Kidman as Drew Preston — too nice. Loren Dean as Billy Bathgate too dumb. CULTURAL scialist Organiser No. 513 pay Television an South Carolina, USA, some women can be jailed for being •pregnant. Unbelievable? Not according to the Everyman programme on BBC1 last Sunday.
This horrific story centres around the issue of rights for unborn children.
When a pregnant woman (in practice, mainly a poor, black. woman from the ghettoes) enters the antenatal clinic of the free state hospital in Charleston she will be tested for drugs without her consent. If the test proves positive, she will be given two "choices": either go on the drug rehabilitation programme or go to prison for the duration of her pregnancy.
"Failure" on the programme leads automatically to prison.
This action is "justified" on the basis of protecting the life of the unborn child whose health could be seriously jeopardised unless the
----- pull-quotes -----
"he Treaty" was a ponder. slow film,
For too long, in Irish nationalist legend, the responsibility has lain