Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

New economics for Labour?

Socialist Organiser no. 513, 23 January 1992 · scan pp. 11–12 · about 1,349 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 11

Labour

Investing in peo The left needs a clear alternative to Kinnock's blah-blah. Photo: John Harris. of Action' conference on 25 January "Programme y Martin Thomas Asic 1985, when Andre lmost for the first time Glyn published his Million Jobs a Year pamphlet, the Labour left is discussing economics.

Labour MPs, trade unionists, and left-wing academics are meeting in London this Saturday, 25 January, to discuss a "Programme of Action" on "Labour and the Economy"

The chief sponsors include MPs Ken Livingstone, Tony Benn, Jeremy Corbyn, George Galloway and Audrey Wise; trade union leaders Ken Cameron, Peter Heathfield, Peter Lenahan and Joe Marino; and academics Ben Fine, GC Harcourt, Laurence Harris and Frank Wilkinson.

Their statement has seven points:

• "Policies for full employment: the rebuilding of the public services; a shorter working week...

• National minimum wage and *an end to restrictions on trade union solidarity"

• Cut military spending to the curopean average; a "planned programme" to convert from military production.

• "The creation of a new core of publicly-owned companies" , compensation "in the form of longterm government securities" where firms are nationalised.

• 'Tax incentives to promote the repatriation of capital"

• "A sharp cut in interest rates" and devaluation of the pound.

• "International economic cooperation, both inside and outside the European Community, including Third World debt cancellation...

It also calls for "raising dividend taxation and reversal of the Tories' multi-billion pound tax cuts for the rich"

his policy is wider-ranging, but less sharply radical, than Andrew Glyn's proposals, published by the Campaign Group of lett Labour MPs in 1985, for comprehensive state control of financial institutions, capital export, prices, imports and all large companies.

In its preamble, gramme of Action statement refers back approvingly to the "Alternative Economic Strategy" published by the Labour left in the early 1970s. That "AES" was centred on planning agreements between a Labour government and big companies, increased social spending, import controls, and price controls.

Through the planning agreements, through increased ''The 'economy' not a machine that can be tinkered with one way or another... A real socialist policy car never be just an mobilising the working cl social spending, and (in more radical versions) through new nationalised industries, investment would be jacked up. The import controls (and withdrawal from the European Community) would ensure that increased demand did not just pull in imports; and price controls, that it would not just lead to inflation.

"Such policies could have been applied at the beginning of the 1980s" , declares the preamble, but today "a different emphasis 1s required. Policy cannot aim to put existing plant and machinery back to work [but instead] to generate resources for investment...

The immediate background the new Programme of Action is two books published in 1989: Beyond the Casino Economy (sponsored by the Campaign for Labour Party Democracy), and Livingstone's Labour.

Beyond the Casino Economy included some readable and detailed argument about how modern information technology makes planning and social control more necessary and practicable, and concluded with a sort of sawn-off version of Andrew Glyn's recommendations: an "anti-monopoly programme" to nationalise 25 top companies, and the banks and finance institutions, as a "first stage" • Livingstone's Labour was an altogether feebler effort, proposing no new public ownership but instead a package of forcing capitalists to bring their money back to Britain, cutting arms spending, increasing taxes on the rich, and..a trade pact with the compromises no doubt neces- hose are the ingredients. The sary to get broad support have left the final dish very watery in parts; and some elements necessary to make a nourishing programme for a working class socialist movement are, I think, missing from the ingredients.

Workers' plans; workers' control; industrial democracy; the revolutionary change in the state necessary for state economic controls to become social controls — all these are missing from the ingrethe ABst, as a back in 1980°f put it back in 1980:

"The 'economy' is not a machine that can be tinkered with at will by this or that government, with the class struggle only applying external 'pressure' one way or the other... A real socialist policy can never be just an 'economic policy; it is a policy for mobilising the working class... " [Colin Foster in Workers' Action, 22.03.80] The collapse of the command economies in the USSR and Eastern Europe makes this issue doubly important. Any credible socialist policy today has to explain very clearly how it differs from what passed as orthodox socialism for 60 years: a bureaucratic statemonopoly system.

Marx wrote ironically in Capital : "It is very characteristic of the enthusiastic apologists of the factory system, that they have nothing more damning to urge against a general organisation of labour in society than that it would turn all society into one immense factory" • Under the influence of Stalinism and Fabianism, too many socialists have seemed almost to adopt Marx's caricature as their own policy — to propose in place of the tyranny of capitalist factories a more comprehensive "planned" tyranny!

Marxian socialism is about freeing workers from the tyranny of the factory system. Workers' control and democracy are central to that. he Programme of Action notes the "globalisation of industries" and "west European integration". But instead of concluding that we should ditch the old Stalinist and Fabian notions of "socialism in one country" • and to explain very orthodox socialism for 60 years: a bureaucratic statemonopoly system.

return to the ideas of the Communist Manifesto - "united action, of the leading civilised coun tries at least, is one of the first conditions for the emancipation of the proletariat" — the Programme instead concerns itself with what is "needed to match Britain's competitors"

What about what is needed for the cross-European working class to "match" increasingly integrated Euro-capitalism? Neither immediate proposals for a levelling-up of workers' rights and conditions across Europe, nor broader perspectives for international democratic planning of credit, investment, and production, find a place in the Programme of Action.

The wateriness of the Programme also destroys its coherence at some crucial points. Even less than the 1970s "AES" does this Programme have "handles" to connect it to day-to-day working class concerns and struggles and make something more than vague advice to future Labour government ministers.

On many issues it is so vague as to be vacuous: issues such as working hours ("a shorter working week" without any more precise indication, such as 35 hours); childcare provision ("a sustained boost" , without even indicating whether this "boost" should be big or small!); and training (it just says "a national training programme" - but even the Tories have some programme of training!.

In the area which is central to its logic - state control of the economy — the Programme signals a loss of nerve. Many of its sponsors used to identify socialism with state control of the economy, and see the old order in the USSR as embodying that idea; now, it seems, they have no answer but to propose the same idea in milder, more watery form.

Thus the Programme proposes not comprehensive state control, but only "a new core of publiclyowned companies...in order to have the information and leverage to drive up the level of investment" The new socialist government will tame the capitalists not by expropriating them, and not even by controlling them, but by competing with them! And it will do that while burdened with paying full compensation to former owners, albeit in the form of interest-bearing paper rather than cash.

For all these reasons, the Programme can only be a starting point for discussion. But that the Labour left is discussing economics again is itself a step forward.

"Labpus andJthe recpromy" anterense 00391 BUT0DNS 1ce ati Coseway Halb Retiia Square, London WC1 Admission E5/E2 unwaged.

Scan page 12

er ULTURAL FRONT

----- pull-quotes -----

at will by this or thai government, with the class struggle only applying external 'pressure

'economic' policy; is a policy for

"Any credible socialist policy

clearly how it differ. from what passed a

Workers' control democracy are central to that."

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 513

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →