[Fight the racists! Socialist Organiser No. 513 page…]
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-01-23Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
Fight the racists!
Scan page 10
Socialist Organiser No. 513 page 10 TIDE orget - if you can → the horrible carnage on the road in Armagh and the pulped and shredded bodies of seven Irish building workers. Forget — if you can - the shattering wounds of those who were still alive when the debris had fallen.
Focus instead on the great mystery at the heart of the Provisional Irish Republican Army which this terrible piece of sectarian killing exposes. Those who set off the bomb are members of an organisation in whose initials "R" stands for a Republic within which Irish people of all religious denominations and none will be equal citizens. Those who killed the seven Protestant building workers - as casually as a farmer would wipe out vermin on his land - say that the goal they seek to serve by such deeds is to "unite Ireland"
Their dogma is that it is Britain which wilfully keeps Ireland divided, and that that is the reason for their quarrel with Britain. But their staple military activity in Northern Ireland is killing Irish people of a different — Unionist - political persuasion from their own. They claim, and exercise, the right to kill anyone connected to the Northern Ireland state, including workers who do it servicing work of any description. They have now killed 26 such workers.
These are all "Crown forces", "British agents" and — as they say to justify the killing of the seven builders, and other similar killings - "collaborators"
The point is that two-thirds of the people in Northern Ireland are active or passive "collaborators" who identify with the existing Northern Ireland state! The policy of killing those seven builders, and others like them, logically implies killing as many of their co-thinkers as "necessary''!
Though the Provisional IRA say they want co unite Ireland, every killing and bombing they do is seen in the Protestant community as an act against that community, as a sectarian act by Catholics against Protestants, as an attack on the Protestant community - as an attempt to coerce them.
The answer is that the Provisional IRA do not — not "for now" anyway — seek an intra-Irish solution: they seek a British solution imposed by British military might on the Irish Protestants. The evidence is overwhelming.
The people who run the IRA are not idiots. They are politically sophisticated and aware people (witness, for example, the way they play up to the British left). They know perfectly well that "war is the continuation of politics by other means".
They know that any "military logic"
which radically cuts across and contradicts the political objectives of the war can not make sense.
They know - they must know, can not but know! - that their military campaign, the killing of Irish Protestants for their connection with the British state, can not but work against their stated and, no doubt, sincere, goal of uniting Ireland.
They know that every act such as that in Armagh — and the hundreds of less spectacular but similar acts which do not get widely reported in Britain — adds to the great power of convulsive hatred and resentment against them, and against the Catholic community, in Protestant Ulster.
They know that this has, in the last 20 years, produced sectarian assassination of hundreds of Catholics; they know that this hatred would erupt into civil war if the British forces left.
They therefore know that every "military"
act, such as last Friday's killings, is an act against Irish unity, an act winding ever tighter the explosive opposition to Irish unity.
Know it? They have seen Protestant resentment erupt in a general strike in 1974 which shattered Britain's plans for Northern Ireland so thoroughly that the effect is still felt. Frequently, they seem to play on it. They deliberately do things which appear to be designed to "stoke up" and detonate the Protestants - the bombing of a Remembrance Day religious ceremony in Enniskillen four years ago, for example.
Of what politics can their actions be the proper continuation? That is the mystery. The only answer to it is the one I offered above.
For all their talk about "Tone's Republic" and "Connolly's socialism" , there is a core of Catholic communal feeling at the heart of the Provisional "Republican" movement in the Six Counties. It has deep, strong roots in Ireland's terrible history.
Ireland's Catholics were conquered by Britain and subjected to savage repression for hundreds of years. They faced wars of extermination in the 16th and 17th centuries. In the 1640s, the systematic slaughter of Irish children by the armies of Cromwell's British Parliament was so much a commonplace event that the soldiers had a philosophical catchery to explain and justify what they In the 18th century the Catholics faced nearly 100 years of a system remarkably like South Africa's apartheid.
By contrast with many other conquering landlord classes — like, for example, those who conquered England in the 11th century and then, over centuries, melded with the conquered people - the lords of the Irish land were no more than an alien crust.
Slowly, over many decades, the Irish people won back control over their own country. They sloughed off the alien caste of foreign landlords.
But not all those who had come to live in Ireland under English and British rule were members of that exploiting upper crust.
entire "Protestant" society with its own class structures, from aristocrats through tarmers to proletarians, had come into existence in North East Ulster.
This part of Ireland had more in common with the British colonies put down in North America, displacing the natives, than it had with the "thin crust" colony of the rest of Ireland.
It is the society produced by that colony which is the core of the present Six Counties -surrounded by and partly interlaced with areas of Catholic predominance.
In the first fifty years of Northern Ireland, to the end of the 1960s, the artificially big Catholic minority in Britain's semi-detached Six Counties state were treated as secondclass citizens.
'In the 1640s, the armies of Cromwell... w so commonplace... the soldiers' catchcry [was] 'Nits will make lice'."
This produced the Catholic revolt that is now in its twenty-third year. 'On the ground' in Northern Ireland, now the Provos know very well that the main problem they had to deal with was the "Orange" Protestants. Their attitudes are the attitudes such conflicts always produce.
The situation of the Catholic minority in Northern Ireland gives much encouragement to communalist ideas, ideas which see progress in terms of the Catholic community turning the tables and gaining power over the Protestants.
Yet, the national leaders of the organisation, though they may share such feelings, do not act on them alone. Plainly, there must also be a great part of them that is committed to the mystical idea that the God of Irish naThe wrecked minibus after the bombing at name of Irish republicanism. tionalism will somehow ensure that out of the maelstrom of sectarian civil war that their deeds may bring on the people of Northern Ireland, there will, somehow, come Irish unity and independence.
There is an essential element of mystical adventurism at the heart of the Provos' enterprise. A few years back, Gerry Adams — who also presents himself as a believer in Tone's Republican policy of uniting Protestants and Catholics - offered as public explanation to the people of Northern Treland for his close escape from an assassination attempt, the fact that he goes to Mass every morning. The leaders of the Pro- Ang Adams and his mine.
And Adams are the "sophisticated' rational ones, who displaced the old rigid anti-political Provo leaders a decade ago!
The Provisional IRA's mad disregard for the dictum of James Connolly, "Ireland without her people means nothing to me", is to be explained by the fact that a large part of Ireland's people mean nothing to them, and that to get a British solution as many of them can be killed as necessary. Despite the dogma that Britain's presence is the great evil, the Provos use the one million strong Irish Protestant community as mere ciphers and counters in the game they play with the "Brits"
They do what they do to the Protestants because, despite their Republican pieties, they think the Protestants do not count They believe that in the last act, the British will coerce, blackjack, arm-twist and economically blackmail the Protestant community into doing what they, the Provisional IRA, want.
The Provos started their military campaign with the doctinaire and deeply antidemocratic belief that what the Protestants want counts for nothing and should count for nothing when it did not coincide with what they, the Provos, wanted; the responses of the Protestants in the course of the IRA war have reinforced and murderously augmented this attitude.
Now men and women who started out sincere Wolfe Tone Republicans, have come to believe that as many Protestants as "necessary' can be killed. Thus the awful logic of communalism works itself through Irish petty-bourgeois republicanism, like a devouring cancer.
But they could not possibly believe that they can kill Protestants with impunity, and stoke white-hot the Irish minority's hatred of their cause, if they did not look to a British and not an intra-Irish solution.
The Provisional IRA hope that warweariness will eventually drive Britain to revert to the policy of uniting Ireland - but as an immediate executive goal, with Britain taking initiatives to unify Ireland over the heads of the Protestants, using the British Army to control them. That is less mad than it might seem.
Thatcher faced down the spectacular Orange opposition to the 1985 Anglo-Irish Agreement. And a war-weary Britain seeking to withdraw could not - unless the central British state itself had half-collapsed - just pull out and let things rip in a civil war which would probably spread to Glasgow and other areas in Britain. The Provisional IRA know that, and know that the British would have to seek a "political solution" in a deal with Dublin. That, at any rate, is what they hope for.
They are very unlikely to get it, because unlike the "Republicans" , both London and Dublin know that the Protestant community does count, and will insist on being counted. And after all the upheavals that would be necessary to achieve it, such a Provo-BritishDublin solution would most likely face an IRA-style military campaign by Protestants against the new Irish Establishment. Neither Dublin nor London would want that, or the risk of it.
No-one but a blinkered Catholic-Irish chauvinist could regard such a "swapping" of alienated communities - the Protestants in all-Ireland taking the place of the Catholics in Northern Ireland — as a step forward. It would not even mean British withdrawal: a big British military presence would be necessary to suppress the threat of civil war and repartition.
So the Provos are unlikely to get what they want from Britain. But they know that they will never foreseeably get what they want from the Northern Ireland Protestants. They have given up on that big part of the Irish people; and thus it is with obscene hypocrisy that they invoke Tone and Pearse and Connolly!
Most Irish people, Catholic or Protestant, know or sense all this. That is why most of the Catholic Irish — including a majority of the Six Counties Catholics - reject the Provos' mixture of mystical adventurism, Catholic communalism, and addle-headed realpolitik.
They might not feel comfortable - their business not being to say things clearly and where necessarily provocatively - spelling it out as brutally as I do here; but nevertheless they reject the Provisional IRA, whose deeds, like the latest slaughter, disgrace and shame the name of Irish Republican, a historic name to which they have no right!
The real Wolfe Tone, the real Robert Emmett, the real Joe Biggar and maybe the real Patrick Pearse, if they lived now, would be the Provos' targets, not their allies!
Scan page 11
Socialist Organiser No. 513 page
----- pull-quotes -----
systematic slaughter Irish children by the