Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

COHSE, NALGO, NUPE: New union - the faceless bureaucrats behind it

Socialist Organiser no. 512, 16 January 1992 · scan p. 15 · about 709 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 15 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 15

NALGO Action Om Britain might come ne of the largest union into being next year with most of its members knowing little, and caring even less, about the merger that will create it.

A report from the NECs of NALGO, NUPE and COHSE going to a special conference on March 4 looks set to allow a ballot on merger to go ahead which could create a 1½ million strong public sector union by July 1993.

For the press, the main feature of the report will be proposals to ensure that the majority of the members - women - will be 'proportionally represented' on its National Executive... and that issue is likely to be concentrated on by activists.

Activists who care about unions being democratic and representing all their members will welcome the proposals, and a plan for 'reserved seats' for the lowest-paid women members who earn less than £5,000 a year...but behind this "radicalism' the union leaders have avoided some key issues.

Above all they've said nothing which really gives a reason why a 'super-union' should be created, except that it will be bigger. Activists will be arguing that there are positive reasons for a merger if we have a charter of demands for public sector workers to overcome divisions between white collar and blue collar workers in local councils, the NHS, further education, and utilities - simple things like a minimum wage, a 35-hour week for all, equal conditions, and a joint campaign to defend the public sector.

The union leaders, by contrast, have come up with a "defensive' plan to prevent the worst problems of falling membership on the one hand, and to calm the worst fears about lack of democracy on thi other.

Faced with losing the merger plan, the NECs have largely conceded that an annual conference should be held, that members should have access to adequate funds, and that the union should be led by elected, lay-members not full-time officials.

All these things were issues they had wanted to duck, but were forced to respond to by la: year's NALGO conference -and the threat that campaigns for a democratic merger would grow very fast if they didn't back down.

But there are still practical points that need raising to win the type of democratic fighting union activists want to see - a powerful union with a n eal industrial base: where the leaders on the NEC are directly elected by, and accountable to, workers in each public service in the union.

By contrast the NECs have a plan for regional and service NEC members, and have sneaked in having elections only every two years. Where the service groups based on each public service unite the workforce in communal campaigns to overcome divisions, the NEC have sneaked in, in the small print, plan for 'sectors' which keeps divisions between white collar and blue collar workers.

Activists will also want guarantees that branches have the wherewithal to campaign. The NECs have half caved in with a series of promises on funds which need tightening u 'Activists will welcome reserved members... behind this avoided some key so that the union on the grour keeps a set percentage of subs income.

So where does that leave women in the merged union - if the other changes are agreed in a far stronger position, but the backdoor approach of the bureaucracy needs bringing out into the light. Despite all the talk about a democratic union their plans for four representatives for women are about election systems, not self-organisation, and into the bargain they talker about power for the NEC to introduce fairness through sanctions' - an untrammeled right for them to disqualify conference delegations, withhold funds, or impose women-only elections in branches.

The double-speak about fairness and democracy tied up with these sort of plans is likely to put workers off, convince them that a 'super-union' will be a bureaucratic monster. It is now the activists, if they can advance the real case for merger and build on the concessions they've already forced out of the leaders, who will have to win the arguments with the oneand-a-half million trade unionists who need one big democratic union.

----- pull-quotes -----

seats for the lowest-paid

'radicalism', the union leaders have

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 512

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →