Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Wat the discussion is about

Socialist Organiser no. 512, 16 January 1992 · scan pp. 11–14 · Amy Gilbert · about 4,494 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 11

(SO 511) expressed the opinion open-ended discussion, of which the the shoute dan character ad between "state capitalists" and tivist' Ton we honor 1 10 0000 BUEDUSE on to man detent nerdations thus. we hope, open, honest and scienwetate canitalist or bureaucratic col in su (a lew workers staubis anu d economies? (They were not anticapitalist but nationalist. They reflected the interests of nationalist petty bourgeoisies."

The last two years show that the Stalinist systems were "inorganic" "deformed" politicallymonopoly. They have also shown us the limits of the "deformation"': it did not transform capitalism into something completely different, with different social classes and productive forces. T been that SC is by defini- he fallback BC argument has tion impossible. Capitalism is defined as a system governed (or mainly governed) by market forces, or as a system where money buys everything, and so SC is ruled out with no more ado. Or, to put the argument in less logic-chopping form: to extend the concept of capitalism to cover state-monopoly Stalinism was not postcapitalist, but still sees it as BC: a sort of decaffeinated BC, a BC "parallel" to capitalism but outside it, on a different plane.

In SO 506 he writes: "Whether we should award Stalinism the title Mode of Production with a capital "M' and a capital 'P' is of zero importance" . (Why? Isn't it very important for our historical perspective on Stalinism, the classes that generate it, and the classes that it generates?) In SO 509 he argues that Stalinism was "governed by a law of development" , one "not analogous to the laws of capitalist development" — the law being that it could copy capitalist technique (at high cost) but not innovate or achieve high quality.

This "law" (quoted from Trotsky) is important. But there are good reasons why Trotsky did not see it as the comprehensive "law which regulated [Stalinism's] origin, existence, development and death as a social organism" . It begs many questions. Why was it "capitalist technique" which the bureaucrats introduced into the USSR at such high cost? Why did they want to? Why was poor product quality fatal? Economic systems have lived for centuries with much poorer-quality goods than the USSR has.

Look at it another way. In the Stalinist systems the workers were wage-workers, They sold their on the market, all paralleled or mimicked capitalism.

The State regulation systematically twisted the economy towards cheap, basic consumer goods and, often, fairly full employment, to assist totalitarian control; towards greater investment in heavy industry; and towards autarky (trying to construct a national economy independent of the rest of the world). Consequences Rigby's "law of development including those in Tom All those twists were, surely, not anti-capitalist, but nationalist. They reflected the interests not of an anticapitalist class, but of nationalist petty bourgeoisies. The Stalinist regimes differed from the "ordinary" SC widespread in the Third World, but to the extent political revolution. The Stalinists' great and bloody battles with private capitalists were not anticapitalist but nationalist. Their aim was not to move society away from capitalism to a new order, but to develop national capitalism. In other words, they undertook "a limited parallel to a certain stage of capitalist development"

To call Stalinism post-capitalist - that is, to use the label BC with real substance — is now shown to be false. To try to define it away as a mysterious wandering of history nto a limbo, or into a paralle lane. is to evade a broad Marxis overview by playing with words.

n his contribution to this discussion Moshe Machover that themposi Connot Diarialist or were, "bureaucratic collecposition in so suz can excer pr trom a and Machover is free to make what he tific. likes of the SO text. But it was not understood DUS TO CHIDOUY d "harpeneratic collectivist. position. In fact, it embodies views common to both "bureaucratic collectivists" and "state capitalists" in Socialist Organiser It seems to us that the argument lectivist a distinet form or class ociety that is neither capitalist nor vorking class) concerns issues outside of the ground covered in SO's 1988 LOCHCHE Socialist Organiser has no other for- The Editor mal position as to the exact SOCI Sta present exchanges are part.

very extensive agreement Despite the differences in sociological evaluawould be served by saddling the with a preemptive decimajority vote, and opted instead for discussion, free of factionalism and Whether the 1988 document is "more state capitalist" or "more La useful thing to discuss.

It is a bridging document designed. he summarisino the common ground few "Ticktinites" partially excepted), to allow the scientific discussion to

Scan page 12

A pamphlet produced by lewish Trades Unionists, in opposition to the 1905 Aliens Organis Steve •wo years ago, Omaya Wehbe and her 4 children fled Lebanon and sought asylum in Germany. The family was put in a government hostel while her claim was being considered. The hostel was regularly attacked by neo-Nazis and the residents had to arm themselves with knives and sticks to mount a 24 hour guard against the thugs.

Omaya's seven-year-old son was attacked and temporarily blinded by chemicals sprayed in his eyes. The authorities refused to allow her to live elsewhere in the country. In December, she tried to escape to Canada, but was arrested by British immigration officials whilst in transit at Heathrow. The family has claimed asylum here. The Home Office is trying to refuse her on the grounds that, under the Dublin Convention, an asylum application can only be made to one European Community state.

Omaya Wehbe's case highlights two crucial aspects of Britain's proposed new asylum laws. Firstly, the creation of a Fortress Europe with all EC countries combining to exclude refugees. Secondly, a parallel attack throughout Europe on black people by organised racists on the streets.

History as lies «We will restore the reputation that Britain has enjoyed for over 50 years of being a country that accepts refugees as a moral duty". This was one of Roy Hattersley's contributions to the Parliamentary debate on the new Asylum Bill. This was, appropriately, November 5th, since it is simply a lie that there has ever been a golden past where the UK has welcomed refugees.

It has been all dross. In recent years whenever a country has started to produce refugees, Britain has imposed visa controls on those wanting to flee — for instance, Sri Lanka 1985, Turkey 1988, Uganda 1991. The 1987 Carriers' Liability Act, which transforms airlines into spies for the immigration service by compelling them to check documents, was initially passed to keep out Tamils fleeing from Sri Lanka. The first immigration controls The first ever immigration control, the 1905 Aliens Act, was designed solely to keep out refugees. It was aimed against Jewish people fleeing persecution in Eastern Europe and Tsarist Russia.

The Act excluded "undesirable immigrants". An undesirable immigrant was defined as a person who "cannot show he is in a position to obtain the means of decently supporting himself". Immigration Appeal Boards were established to refuse admission to 'bogus' refugees. This is the same function Adjudicators will have under the new Asylum Act.

The decisions of the Immigration Appeal Boards were reported in the Jewish Chronicle. A typical case was that of Aaron Hecht Milifiore: "One of his children he said had been killed in a pogrom. His family then fled in a state of panic and frenzy, and in the confusion he had become separated from them, yet the immigrant was rejected on grounds of want of means" (Jewish Chronicle, October 25 1907).

Britain and the holocaust After the Nazi takeover of Germany, restrictions were again placed on Jews. In particular, a visa requirement was imposed in May 1938 on nationals of Germany and Austria -that is, on Jews trying to flee fascism.

The British government expected Jews, wearing yellow stars, to travel to British embassies in Nazi countries, to argue for visas. The then Home Secretary, Sir Samuel Hoare, justified this in language parroted by every Home Secretary since: "There are obvious objections to any policy of indiscriminate admission. Such a policy would not only create difficulties from the police point of view but THE About the Anti-Alien Resolution of the Anti-Alien into consideration the Anti-Alien Resolution, and the uncomplimentary remarks of certain delegates about the Jowish workers specially, issue this leaflet, wherewith we hope to convince our English fellow workers of the untruthfulness, unreasonableness, and want of logic contained in the cry against the foreign worker in general, and against the Jewish worker in particular.

It is, and always has been, the policy of the ruling classes to attribute the sufferings and miseries of the masses (which are natural consequences of class rule and class England; it is international. Everywhere he is the individual working men, we, the organised aliens, took no heed; but when this ill-founded sentiment has been and argue the matter out.

It has been proved by great political economists that a working man developed produces in a day twice as many commodities as his daily wage enables him to consume.

would have grave economic results in aggravating the unemployment problem, the housing problem and other social problems" (House of Commons, March 22nd 1938).

This can be compared with the welcome given to Nazis entering the UK after the war.

The then Labour Lord Chancellor said *I am willing to risk their being Nazis — and I think they probably are, so long as they are highly-skilled technicians" (House of Lords, March 10th 1946).

Of course, the present tightening of immigration controls is also a block on Jews fleeing the increasing and violent antisemitism in the ex-Stalinist states.

new Asylum ver since the Commonwealth Immigrants Act of 1962 there have been harsher •controls against black people from the Third World.

These have been introduced by both Labour and Tory governments. The 1968 Commonwealth Immigrants Act, taking away the right of entry to East African Asians with British passports, was Labour's main innovation. Under the last three Tory governments, there has been an onslaught — ranging from attacks on Asian arranged marriages to the 1988 Immigration Act restricting rights of appeal and bringing in further criminal penalties. The Asylum Bill is simply a further and more confident acceleration.

Some of the Bill's proposals are: • All asylum applicants to be fingerprinted • Families of homeless refugees to lose their full rights to council housing whilst awaiting a decision on their claim • All appeals against refusal of asylum to be lodged within 48 hours • No appeal rights where an Adjudicator asserts an applicant "does not have an arguable claim for asylum" • The refusal of an asylum application will give the Home Office power to remove any other immigration status — such as being a • The undertaking of political activities in the UK by an asylum seeker will itself be grounds to refuse the claim if the Home Office asserts that the activities "were calculated to Capitulation to racism and anti-semitism is one of the oldest traditions of the Rritish Labour movement.

Back in 1905, Jewish trade unionists (left) had itl TUC's support for the 1905 Aliens Act (which sought to restrict mainly Jewish immigration to Britain). Today it is the ng working class movement who must oppose our own ROY Lapore and *1007 scapegoat bogus asylum TAL pa movement is no use to у вексери the enhance his claim to refugee status" • In addition to those contained in the Asylum Bill, there are further proposals. For instance, Legal Aid is no longer to be available for advice in any immigration matter, whether or not it is to do with asylum. This shows that the new changes are not just about asylum-seekers, but are directed against all migrants and immigrants. The outlines of the new proposals were made public in parliament by Kenneth Baker, last July. However, for 3 months prior to that there had been a concerted softening-up exercise by the press to popularise the idea of more restrictions. For instance: • On April 25th, the Star attacked a family claiming social security on the grounds *They are about as British as a chapatti butty". • On May 27th, the Daily Express denounced political asylum as a "United Nations loophole" • Incredible stories were invented to show asylum-seekers were "bogus'. On July 3rd, the Sun claimed "They often pay pals to whip them or burn themselves with cigarettes to con investigators into believing they are torture victims" • The government is not at the mercy of the media. They feed off each other. The new proposals were deliberately leaked to the press, weeks in advance of their parliamentary announcement. The Mail reported them on June 10th. On June 28th, the Prime Minister made a crucial speech preparing the way for the new proposals. He called for tougher laws throughout Europe. On June 29th, the Sun headlined this as "PM in race war alert. Major calls for migrant curb"

The whole world over Bion controls extend to the cor the ritain's employment of immigraof what is left of its Empire. At the same time as introducing its Asylum Bill, it is forcibly sending back Vietnamese refugees from Hong Kong and is refusing to allow all but the wealthiest Hong Kong citizens to settle in the UK.

None of this is happening in isolation. Immigration barriers are being erected throughout all the centres of imperialism against immigrants, migrants and refugees — not so much to lose their labour as to control As Europe, Japan and the USA compete against each other, they all erect their own fortresses to regulate the flow of a cheap and intimidated workforce. • The plans for 1992 and the European Community bear an uncanny similarity with the Asylum Bill. In October 1991, the European Commission circulated a document against refugees. Its ideas included a fast-track procedure for rejecting "manifestly unfounded applications" and tougher fines on airlines for bringing in undocumented passengers. The way the European wind is blowing is shown by Italy's (mistreatment of Albanian refugees last August. The degree of violence used by the state authorities has not been seen since Mussolini. The Guardian reported "Italian police opened fire last night as thousands of Albanian refugees seeking to avoid deportation tried to break out of a football stadium in which they were being kept" • The United States has had a long history of denying entry to refugees fleeing right-wing and military governments. It is presently engaged in sending out gun boats to intercept and turn back Haitians fleeing from a military coup. At the same time, it welcomes refugees from Cuba. • In 1989, Japan introduced new immigration legislation. It made it a criminal offence for employers to hire workers without the 'correct' immigration status. These employer sanctions turn bosses into agents of immigration control on the shop floor. Similar laws already exist in the USA and in many EC countries. In 1978, one of the last acts of the Labour government was to publish the report of the Parliamentary Select Committee on Race Relations and Immigration — which argued for the introduction of employer sanctions in the UK.

Who is bogus? Roy Hattersley refugees?

In the parliamentary debate on che Bill, Roy Hattersley said *I have made it clear that I will not allow in the bogus asylumseeker" and "No-one I know wants the open door policy on immigration"

Hattersley makes exactly the same distinction as the Tories between 'economic' or "bogus' refugees and 'political' or "genuine' refugees.

The new Asylum Bill will, in any case, keep out many political refugees who have what the law describes as a 'well-founded fear of persecution' in their own countries. This is the Bill's purpose.

However, as socialists, we have to assert that there is no such thing as a 'bogus' refugee. The only reason why there is migration from the Indian sub-continent, from Africa and the Caribbean, is because the UK, along with other imperial powers, has created poverty and mayhem in these massive areas of the world through economic exploitation made possible by political power and military force.

The Parliamentary Labour Party has said that it will vote against the Asylum Bill. This is not for reasons of principle. It is simply because Hattersley claims he has a more 'effective' method of excluding 'bogus' entrants. His plan is to criminalise 'the agents of bogus asylum-seekers and immigrants'. What he means by this is the introduction of employer sanctions. This is the route by which the Labour leadership wants to enforce immigration controls.

As socialists, our only position can be one of opposition to all restrictions. It is often said that some controls are reasonable' or 'natural'. However, there is nothing reasonable or natural about them. Controls did not exist a century ago. There was a long, racist campaign to implement them. What is required now is an anti-racist campaign to destroy them.

Steve Cohen is author of That's You Don't Look Anti-Semitic.

Scan page 13

s of the word unties wrong-doing that motivates me putting favorites are on CD, and, when they First, the injustice. It's my humble tapes which sound dreadful.

Тебби МіБ D& you to stento thier aist Vin us more convenenato cusares movementor his glh IMIST Last night I found myself We buy I found the depleted masse haveswritten wone racks being busily thumbed through by version of things. As usual, it is only a taira more than LPs. So if W.H.

шое mone? - and so does the music o track down Joni Mitchell's 1980 State The theory is that the newly- won't do anything about it if Labour 02010101010 LA Kathleen Tu ugged director and : Hollyu Weaver awski f the men (and I stress the word men) who made V.I.

Warshawski were transplant surgeons, they'd replace healthy organs with diseased ones. They're wilfully, arrogantly ignorant.

The fact that audiences are staying away in droves from their movie won't faze them; they'll simply complain that films about female private detectives don't sell.

This one certainly hasn't, but the fault is theirs, and theirs alone.

Music The long-playing record is dead. Or so the flurry of articles in the press would have us believe. The decision by Me Enah to ceasestocking viny hes еен ріскед ир юніи mack esigneding wherendlon musny mold *78s gave way to LPs, 19 059 Tota Pere 15. O COLISE. more than an avelling of the usticew good hiS ot scrip vriters a pea-bra ctures ( mpany. i reservi They had good material in their hands, and they trashed it.

Sara Paretsky's six Warshawski novels have a faithful following, and all of them could have been made into watchable movies. They're tightly plotted and fun to read. But the dummies who got hold of them decided the audience didn't have the brains or the concentration to follow a complex plot, so they made up their own piffling story. They threw away the plots and filled in the space with cliches, a string of unrelated oneliners stitched together with sentimental slop, and a boat chase.

The film is an insult. All that's left of the novels are the characters' names. For no discernible reason (it doesn't help the film any) the filmmakers have even changed the way the characters act. Mr Contreras, V.I.'s fond, fussy neighbour, is transformed into a stingy landlord; Murray Ryerson, her newspaper contact, becomes her longtime Fashioned capitalist exploitation and pen to paper. And no little addiction to the 12-inch wonders.

pinion land most of the hi-fi in lustry's] that LPs, given a decen souno system sound Deller eman CDs.

Deus ene to soune unrea stele ana Brasi But that's not the point. I want the choice to listen to LPs and not to be forced to get those rickety replacements, symphony iist: heid whaly.

Smith doesn't stock LPs, they make ing COI lover. Why?

The worst transformation is wrought on V.l. herself. The filmmakers obviously didn't like V.I., didn't approve of her ragbag mixture of toughness, teminism, vulnerability, and independence, not to mention her politics (all the novels have V.I. fighting corruption - in insurance, shipping, real estate development, the US health system, the chemical industry, and so on). They didn't believe a woman would have the principles or the drive to follow through on a tough, dangerous investigation. So they gave her a motive, they gave her the same treatment Sigourney Weaver got in Aliens, they gave her a kid to protect.

Can anything be more offensive than this? After trashing V.I. at the start with a vicious crack about a "female dick", , the filmmakers turn her into a mother figure. That way, she's doing what they consider right — she's fallen victim to the don'texpensive and more than likely made from inferior master The CD does win out on convenience. But those programming bit daft. If Beethoven wanted you to listen to the Tist he have orien th that way DHtto Pink Floyd, the Sex Pistols et al.

I'm loath to admit the possibility of the over-ridino mo vanon FOrEs du diction I love records. Folding out the em or in Virgin's store on Oxford Street.

having to ask an assistant where mess-with-my-lion-cub syndrome, and any threat to men (that women might be as smart, as tough as they are) is removed. She's not an independent sexy woman any more -she's a mum.

Once they've established that, out go the high heels (one of the inane selling points of this crap movie) and in come the jeans anc the trainers (after all, mum's can't be sexy, can they?). They go one further. After a beating, when V.I. has had an injection to help her sleep, she starts wittering on about whether she'd be a good mother. The filmmakers obviously think valium is like truth serum. It's a credit to Kathleen Turner, who's quite good as V.I., that she doesn't try too hard to put this bit of nonsense over.

If they were going to throw away everything that made the Paretsky novels distinctive (the plots, the characters, the politics and the sense of place), why did these ignoramuses bother with them at all? Why not just make their own woman private investigator flick? They must have wanted the assurance of a known *brand name" as a selling/advertising point. But books aren't like coffee or washing powder, where the difference is largely in the packaging. The insides matter. Selling this movie as a V.I. Warshawski story is a swindle.

This film seems to sum up everything that's gone wrong with Hollywood movies. Dummies call the shots. The money was there to make a good film; the tedious boat chase alone, with its tricky overhead shots and Chicago skyline, must have cost a packet, and no-one would have missed it.

Had they filmed one of Paretsky's novels, instead of rehashing every TV cop show cliche they could find, they could have made a film that pleased Paretsky fans who would have come back for more), as well as other people looking for a good time. They could have gone on to film the other books, since nothing pleases Hollywood more than sequels.

But they didn't. They took a potential goldmine and turned it into dross. That's the new Hollywood. Socialist Organiser No.

Television By Amy Gilbert Dynasty the reuDnion"* aimed to tie up the loose ends left by the last cliffhanging episode of the long-running soapie. It didn't tie them up so much as pretend they hadn't happened.

Adam was mysteriously single again; Fallon had escaped burial alive in a collapsing cave (peanuts to a woman who'd spent weeks on a flying saucer); Alexis had survived a potentially fatal fall over the banisters by landing on Dex (exhusbands have their uses).

Blake was in gaol; and Krystle supposedly out of a coma, though, as ever, it was hard to tell. What really made it seem like old times was that both Adam and Steven had brand new faces and no-one seemed to notice... Plus ça change...

One thing that hadn't changed was its progressive views on women. Basically, "Dynasty'''s view women matches the Sun's — Alexis and Krystle the glam grannies, Sammy Jo the blonde bimbo, grovelling Jeannette the faithful servant, and so on. Alexis at least had the fun of camping it up — her outfits looked as if they'd been designed by Fallon's flying saucer pals. Krystle, despite the plot that had her programmed to kill Blake, was a non-starter, though you had to give points to the mad Swiss doctor for trying to knock something into her tiny brain. Most people would have given up after seeing her shoulder pads.

What was new was the coded anti-Japanese paranoia that was the heart of the plot. American capitalism is very nervous about the Japanese buying up their businesses, hence Blake's fears about a sinister "Consortium" plotting to buy up America, and his determination to be the white knight who would stop them.

It's probably not the scriptwriters' fault that this just sounded like sour grapes from the man who lost his company to the Consortium. The idea was a dog from the start. Free market capitalism can hardly be free if people cry foul from the minute they end up on the losing side. As the ads warn us, the value of investments can go down as well as up. Blake's fading eyesight had obviously overlooked the small print.

Even his speech to Consortium boss. Van Dorn (which was supposed to be a big moment) was a flop. When Blake proudly proclaimed that he had always put country before profits, my jaw dropped. Eh? Exactly when did you do that, Blake? Ever? He's always been very much Mr. Hardball. He just hides it better than Alexis.

I won't miss "Dynasty". It's not even good escapism any more. Its black and white view of the world with good capitalist Blake and bad capitalist Alexis is nonsense they're both dreadful. The piffling anti-Japanese message was so overwrought that it was counterproductive. Sinister Orientals have been done to death in Hollywood, and it was a big mistake having the woman baddie be black. People really aren't as thick as the makers of "Dynasty" seem to think they are.

Scan page 14

lISI ORGANISIN

----- pull-quotes -----

determined, and primitive forms of capitalism's economic tendensy to

Trade Union Congress. We, the organised Jewish workers of England, taking

exploitation) to all sorts of causes except the real ones. The cry against the foreigner is not merely peculiar to

scapegoat for other's sins. Every class finds in him an enemy. So long as the Anti-Alien sentiment in this country was confined to politicians, wire-pullers, and to

ofticially expressed by the organised working men of England, then we believe that it is time to lift our voices

less to produce a CD but they sell for Seenes • bone tratarei an esperience meling the this pusike inos goes /Beethover/arted whic

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 512

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →