Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The workers must retake political power

Socialist Organiser no. 512, 16 January 1992 · scan p. 11 · Duncan Chapel · about 873 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →

6 Nov 2026: headline and by-line checked against the scan of page 11 ('By Duncan Chapel'). The text below is still the machine reading.

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 11

capitalism. The new class hostile to both socialism and capitalism does not exist.

As the totalitarian, or semitotalitarian, wrench-grip on the societies of Eastern Europe has been released, the spontaneous economic trends of the substructure are revealed: not collectivist but capitalist. And in the overview now available of 60 years of Stalinism in "origin, development and death" the Stalinist twist on the usual laws of capitalist development looks not anti-capitalist, but nationalist.

Today the Stalinist bureaucrats see both the futility of trying to get further on a nationalist, autarkic model, and a chance to make themselves the core of a ruling class which will operate in worldmarket capitalism.

Too many SC writers have tried to "prove" that the development of Stalinism was simply some ultimate expression of the logic of Capital Gust as analyses of many things other than Stalinism have been Stalinist regimes twist their market economies is to extend make it meaningless.

This argument has some force against SC theories which tend to deduce the capitalist nature of Stalinist systems from the mere existence of markets (Bordiga), of a despotic plan (James and Dunayevska), or of competitive accumulation (Cliff). But it has no force (to my mind, anyway) against an account showing the Stalinist systems as capitalist systems wrenched out of shape by identified forces, tor identified reasons, with identified peculiar results still lying within the capitalist epoch.

The Marxist method as I understand it should not operate with schematic "models" of capitalism, or whatever, but (as Trotsky put it) "give to concepts, by means of closer approximations, corrections, concretisations, a richness of content and flexibility... even a succulence". Marx, Engels, Bukharin and Trotsky all recognised the theoretical possibility of SC, while indicating that it would bea pathological form of capitalism.

The last two years refute "classic" BC theses. Tom Rigby agrees that labour power, were paid wages bought food, clothing, etc.

Now any system developing trom capitalism would perforce be a market economy, for a long time at least. But a workers' state would shape the patterns of investment, of production choices, and of distribution, in a distinctively anti-capitalist way; a BC state would shape them in another way, also anti-capitalist.

he question, then, is: how Toid the Stalinist regimes twist their market economies? According to anticapitalist imperatives, or capitalistic patterns? What does the post-mortem tell us about that?

Wages were set at social subsistence level, as under capitalism. Profits were grabbed and controlled by a small minority, who enjoyed vast privileges over the majority. The collective profit-grabbing class aimed for wealth not just in the form of particular use-values — be they dachas or bombs - but in general, unlimited form. The organisation of production, the choice of technology, the lack of consideration for the environment and for other social costs and benefits which cannot be reckoned Over the past month, the bourgeois revolution in the former Soviet Union has deepened.

The USSR has been replaced with a 'commonweaith' which lacks even the formally-democratic structures of the USSR.

Prices of goods have risen sharply; some by as many as seven-fold. Capitalism has not yet been introduced into the former republics of the USSR, but working people are paying the price for the bureaucracy's moves towards restoration of the capitalist system.

In the new commonwealth, democracy has been put to one side. The leadership team around Yeltsin in Moscow excludes both working people and other bureaucrats from decision-making: the ruling bureaucracy in Ukraine has had to issue supplementary shopping coupons to lessen the cut in the living standards of the Ukrainian workers.

Clearly, the Ukrainian bureaucracy differ from the Yeltsin team, yet it is the Yeltsin team who have unmediated power over monetary policy across the new commonwealth.

It would be a massive step backwards if a market system controlled by capitalists rather than by working people comes to dominate these republics. 60% of Russians, according to a recent poll, do not believe that a transition to a market economy would improve their lives. It is necessary for socialists to put forward a line of action that will allow workers and their allies in the former USSR to block restoration and move towards retaking political power.

There are three central elements to an action programme for the former USSR. Firstly, it is necessary to argue for civil and democratic rights for all so that the organisations of working people are not fettered by the state; secondly, Yeltsin: Mr Market Misery workers' control must be introduced as widely as possible, including over hiring and firing, the distribution of food and foreign aid, and in workplaces; thirdly, it is necessary to convene an allcommonwealth Constituent Assembly, elected on the basis of universal, direct and secret bailot, to institute the direct political and economic control of working people.

The demand for a Constituent Assembly unifies the struggles of working people and their allies in the former USSR against the different manifestations of the bureaucratic reconstruction.

We aim for a more democratic system than an Assembly: we are for the delegate-based democracy of workers' councils. But the struggle for such an Assembly is an important part of the fight for working class power.

----- pull-quotes -----

perverted by similar schematism). «How did the

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 512

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →