Learning from
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-01-16Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
can a post-mortem tell us about the Stalinist systems? think it indicates that they were state-capitalist — an opinion shared, despite Moshe Machover (SO 511), by Kuron and Modzelewski in 1964.
Chris Arthur (SO 506) argues that the collapse of Stalinism shows that it was "not a genuine new mode of production". the bureaucracy is nothing so solid as a class; Hillel Ticktin is right. Ticktin himself (SO 508) summarises his views: Stalinism had "no fundamental economic law". It was a "temporary formation" , a "defective embryo" , in limbo.
In fact the revolutions of 1989-91 have shown that the bureaucracies have a remarkably solid base in "civil society". The old tyrannies were smashed - and power slid easily into the hands of an alliance of the bulk of the old bureaucracies with small groups from the middle class. After their governments have been toppled, the bureaucrats have kept their domination of the armed forces, the civil state machine, the means of production. They have shown themselves to be a social The current economic breakdown in the USSR shows that it had no mode of production only if such breakdown has been constant for the last 60 years. It has not! The developing collapse shows by contrast that the old system was not a permanent state of collapse or a lawless limbo.
Ticktin suggests that the Stalinist USSR had no economic growth. Yet the USSR and Eastern Europe today are shaped by whole social classes (the bureaucracies, the technical and professional middle class, the urban working class) largely generated by Stalinist economic growth. Quibbles about the low quality of technology in the USSR can not define those classes out of existence.
hus far I agree with Tom Rigby (SO 506 and 509).
Stalinism was "a limited parallel to a certain stage of capitalist development" - not post-capitalist, and not a system in limbo. The bureaucracies were ruling classes. These are the conclusions most important for politics.
But Tom Rigby then wants to label the Stalinist systems "bureaucratic collectivist" (BC). I think this label serves only to blur the question of exactly how the Stalinist systems fit into the era of capitalism, just as Ticktin's wordplay only evades questions about how they are supposed to fit into the "period of world transition" (as Ticktin, following Mandel, sees it). In the decades-long debate about "bureaucratic collectivism" and "state capitalism" (SC), disputes over labels have often confused argument over substance. Yet there was substance. In all variants, SC meant capitalism, BC meant something beyond capitalism. The new BC era might be considered better for the working class than capitalism (by Isaac Deutscher, for example, or worse (by Max Shachtman in his later years, for example, but in any case it was postcapitalist.
For the decisive social class, the BC class, the class which, for that era, regulated development, BC was the new order through which they went beyond the bounds of capitalism. All socialist advocates of the BC analysis argued that BC was only a very limited postcapitalist order; but it was postcapitalist.
There was a dispute of substance about what classes generated the Stalinist systems, and what classes those systems generated. The advocates of SC could ask: where did these new BC classes come from within capitalism? How did they fit into Marxist theory? (The mystery is doubled if BC is after all not postcapitalist). Did BC generate a wageworking class similar to that generated by capitalism? And if so, how? (I am glad to see Tom Rigby agreeing that it did generate such a working class).
The theorists of BC had an impressive counter-argument: if the Stalinist systems were only variants of capitalism, why were the capitalists so hostile to them? Why were they generated by revolutions against the capitalists? Weren't the theorists of SC closing their eyes to the manifest fact of a new class hostile to both socialism and capitalism? A new class within capitalism which could break the bounds of capitalism and create something post-capitalist?
The collapse of Stalinism in the USSR and Eastern Europe sheds light, I think, on those disputes of substance. It shows that Stalinism was not postcapitalist. And mere political revolutions - without the shattering of the old state machine or the old ruling class - have put the Stalinist systen s clearly on the road to "ordinary"
Scan page 11
STALINISM IN PERSPECTIV Socialist Organiser Ni