Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

When is a ruling class not a ruling class?

Socialist Organiser no. 512, 16 January 1992 · scan p. 10 · about 1,003 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

necessary tnal the surplus be pro- state and the production or weain.

To give some familiar examples: by a Ministry and the district party the Mafia lives off surplus value; secretary, and if the surplus is imlandlords live off surplus value; mediately at the disposal of the money lenders, from your local state, is not the relation between the loan shark up to the Rothschilds state and production less an exterlive off surplus value; but only in- nal parasitical one, and more an inMass grave at Chelyabinsk for victims of Stalin's Terror. More 3y Chris Arthur agree with Moshe Machover (SO 511) that modernisers in backward countries may be represented as adopting Stalinism as a non-capitalist road, allowing a forced march to "catch up".

How successful it has been is an empirical question hard to assess. How does one balance a space programme against grinding misery for the masses deprived for years at a ume even or soap and sanitary towels?

Nonetheless, it still has to be shown that Stalinism created a new "state collectivist" mode of production. That means demonstrating its law of motion, under what form the surplus is expropriated, and now this is achieved. Here "state capitalism" falls at the first fence because the surplus is clearly not appropriated in the form of surplus value (but in the main of use-values) and it is available not in proportion to one's capital, but to one's political position.

In these respects Stalinism is more analogous to teudalism (indeed, a Readers' Digest article once characterised the USSR as "state feudalist"'), each member of the nomenklatura being allocated a fiefdom.

In trying to understand what a ruling class is, it is important to grasp that appropriation of surplus is not a sufficient condition to define the core of the class, it is duced under its direction. thought to have died here in the 1930s lustrial capital produces the surplus. This then is the core element, because the relation of exploitation is internal to the mode of production.

But the landlord does not particularly care whether you are a worker, a shopkeeper, a farmer, a businessman, a mine operator, or whatever, just as long as the rent is paid. Of course he depends on the surplus being produced, but his relation to its production is external: to put it crudely, he "rips off" his share.

This model was clearly in Trotsky's mind when he characterised the Soviet elite as a gigantic parasite. In his view, unlike capital, itself.

it had no essential role to play in production, but exacted tribute in virtue of its political power, having politically expropriated the proletariat.

The doubt that came into my mind when reading this was put, but not answered, by Trotsky himself when he wrote that the nationalisation of the economy "created a new and hitherto unknown relation" between the as ...

If a factory manager is appointed ternal organising one?

Moshe must assume the latter is the case. But I find it a tricky question. If we return to basics we must start not from the form of state but from the form of production. It is not production for profit. It is not production for need. It is production for targets laid down external to the logic of the production process itself.

In the case of capitalism we know that the law of value transmits from factory to factory the socially necessary labour times for any item, and that capital flows and technological innovation are mutually reinforcing. In the case of production for need we might imagine some mutually informative institutionalisation of producer/ consumer relations. But Stalinism contains no such feedback loops! The so-called plans were meaningless because the information available was so corrupted by the political distortions of the system. And where the plan was fulfilled, it was often only in the letter but not the substance. The state interfered in the economy, eg. appointing personnel, administering prices, nominating priorities, but En e system did not regulate itself in accordance with some inherent logic of its productive capacity.

Thus I would argue that the well-known phenomena of a rapid expansion of basic tactors ot produc tion (steel, etc) followec by a chronic paralysis when diverse, sophisticated, products were required, and by total collapse wher the growing "noise" in the infor mation system scrambled it completely, and the bureaucrats ceased to fear the bullet, should not be interpreted as effects of some economic law but as a sign of a lack of law.

A combination of political factors (coercion and voluntarist enthusiasm) got things off the ground, but because no new mode of production was stabilised the system could not run itself when these political pressures diminished.

Finally, the only coherent theory of "state collectivism" I know of sees the core of the new ruling class arising from the "managerial revolution': the key class of the future is not the owners, nor is it the workers, it is the class whose power derives from its being the brains of the ever more complex and integrated productive process.

This does not seem relevant to Stalinism in which the technically qualified people, including some factory directors, and "professionals" generally for that matter, are much worse off in relation to production line workers than in the West. Indeed it is these people who are frequently enthusiastic about the current overturn in the hope that capitalism will reward them etter, both absolutely and relative lyThe whole experience emonstrates the wisdom of Marx's insight that economics is decisive over politics. The elite wanted to be a ruling class, and it seemed they had all the power anyone could wish for, with the KGB, the GULAG and the house-trained party millions; but they could not ground themselves on production; they could pour out "plans"

— it's as simple as that. Congress, 1934: the "Con

----- pull-quotes -----

"Because no new mode of production was stabilised, the system could not

"decrees" , "orders" , "reforms"' but they could not deliver the goods

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 512

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →