Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Rights for workers to have a 'day of rest Socialists and Sundays missed

Socialist Organiser no. 511, 9 January 1992 · scan p. 14 · Alan Gilbert · about 1,044 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 14

Learning fro

agree with Gerry Bates

who, in his article •'Commercial Pirates' in

SO 510, wrote that "Sunday trading is a good idea because it will allow people who work the rest of the week to shop"

1am pleased to see that on this issue, just as on Europe and Electoral Reform, Socialist Organiser is prepared to take a principled socialist stance even though it goes against the traditional left position.

Bedfordshire County Ross, Malcolm Bailey and Mike Heathcote have been expelled from the Labour Party under the new rules from this year's Party Thr ee" of the hun ts.

As a libertarian socialist and a Christian, I support a pluralist and multi-cultural

society and 1 am therefore keenly aware of the need for the disestablishment of religion. The disestablishment of the Christian Sabbath is as important as repeal of the blasphemy laws and the separation of the State and the Church of England.

I also agree with Gerry Bates that Sunday trading is a good idea in the hands of unscrupulous commercial pirates", However, accepting all th le other victi italinist wit ages of support

Sunday opening necessarily mean 7-day opening.

ohn Jeffers ordshire Ce iS Winchest

does not accepting

The Sunday trading restrictions could be replaced by a 6-day opening law under which shops could open 6 days a week and no more but could choose which day to stay closed.

Some of the conditions of work which Gerry suggests are also questionable. "Double time for Sunday; and the right for every worker unwilling to work Sundays to keep their job" are demands which Secr tary, B ity Lat our Pa Garde as. Lut

reinforce the idea that Sunday should be the day of rest (an idea which would not

receive enthusiastic support from Jews and Muslims).

Work conditions should not support discrimination between days of the week. *6-day working (or 5-day working) agreements with double time for the 7th (or 6th and 7th) day, regardless which day of the week it is; the right for every worker to choose which day to have off and to keep their job" would be preferable demands.

David Ball, York ED! LU3 3UD i82- i44. Spe: aker John Je iffer Alan Gilbert reviews the on the face of it, Socialist Organiser, socialist and Living Marx have little in common, beyond all being publications of the left.

Yet all can trace their political strands back to the same period of upheaval and division in the 'International Socialism" group (as what is now the SWP was then called) in 1971-5. Much that is apparently incomprehensible about the splits and disputes on the left is made clearer by this pamphlet's examination of that watershed period.

The major item in the pamphlet is well worth reading for broader reasons, too. It is a criticism of the ideas on revolutionary party organisation of SWP leader Tony Cliff, written in 1969, the bulk of which is an excellent positive exposition of the views of Lenin and Trotsky on that question.

Today "Build the Party" is the SWP's catchword, its answer to everything. Many readers will be astonished to find that in the 1960s Cliff's ideas were very different. In his pamphlet on Rosa Luxemburg, published in 1959, he wrote:

*Marx's statement (the proletarian movement is the self-conscious independent movement of the immense majority in the interests of the immense majority') and Lenin's that revolutionary social democracy represents the Jacobins indissolubly connected with the organisation of the proletariat, are definitely contradictory... For Marxists in advanced industrial countries, Lenin's original position can much less serve as a guide than Rosa Lux emburg's.

Cliff presented the choice as being between a "Leninism" which implied sectarian attempts to build self-proclaimed vanguards, with a haughty and arrogant attitude to rank-and-file workers' struggles, and a loose, vaguely anarchistic, discussion group which would service and assist workers" struggles without anything that might smack of vigorous intervention. And precisely because of that, when he decid ed in 1968 that his group could grow seriously and must get properly organised, he flipped and its splits British bustine An Tor Worket.

Liberty over into the same "toy-town Bolshevism" he had previously denounced.

Cliff's about-turn caused

much consternation in the IS/ SWP, and a lot of individuals left, but there was no organised split. The organised split most directly connected to the 1968 turn came seven years later, in 1975, when a large slice of the people who had led the IS/SWP in the late '60s and early "70s — Jim Higgins, John Palmer, Stephen Marks, Richard Kuper and others - were expelled after protesting at the increasing tendencies to ranting and blustering sectarianism.

Many of those people are now active around the newspaper socialist and the magazine Catalyst, apparently guided by the same sort of antiLeninist ideas as Cliff argued before 1968.

The IS/SWP's decisive turn towards tinpot "vanguardism" had, however, been earlier than 1975. In 1971 it had expelled the Workers' Fight tendency (some of whose activists now contribute to Socialist Organiser), and legislated a general ban on factions within IS/SWP whose views might diverge from the leadership's 'The late '60s and early '70s were a time of great opportunities Marxists in Britain. This pamphlet explains why those opportunities were missed. across the board rather than just on isolated issues. in 1973 another opposition was expelled. Its guiding spirits were Roy Tearse and David Yaffe. Tearse had been a leading Trotskyist organiser in the 1940s; by 1973 he had been long inactive, and was not a member of the IS/SWP, but influenced the opposition from outside towards ideas more similar to those of Militant than to anything else on the left. Yaffe contributed long polemics on economic theory; for a while, the merits and demerits of the "permanent arms economy" theory, and the intricacies of Marx's "transformation problem" became a major topic of debate. •After this rather loose and in coherent opposition was expelled, it scattered, and the main organised force to emerge out of it was the RCP, which publishes Living Marxism. Yaffe became a Stalinist; Tearst died: Tearse's lieutenant Tony Polan now writes anti-Leninist

----- pull-quotes -----

ENESON THESEFIT

new Alliance for pamphlet A traged) of the left: Social Worker and its splits

the of Socialist

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 511

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →