Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Trying to do without trust

Socialist Organiser no. 511, 9 January 1992 · scan pp. 13–14 · about 1,058 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 13

Belinda Weaver review Proof he notion of a blind photoT grapher may seem weird to some people, but Martin, the blind photographer in Proof, takes pictures for a reason — to get proof that what The Treaty The Treaty, ITV, Wednesday 15 January. 9.00pm The Treaty was negotiated representatives of Dail Eireann, set up by MPs who sece ed from the Westminster parliament in January 1919, and the leaders of the British imperialist government, led by David Lloyd George.

For two and a half years Britain used mass terror against the irish. he heard or sensed when he took the photo was real, was the truth.

This is important to him; it's his way of ensuring that people don't lie to him. He began using the camera as a boy, to try to catch his mother, of whom he was suspicious, in a lie. When she describes a garden in which a man is raking up leaves, he takes his first picture to try to prove that there is no man, that his mother is deliberately deceiving him. When, hurt, she asks him why she should Martial law, Dublin 1921 Now more subtle methods were used in negotiation.

Ireland was offered dominion status (self government, de facto independence, like Australia and Canada). The representatives were also threatened with immediate and terrible war" if they did not there and ther agree to sign away the Irish Republic in whose name Dail Eireann acted, and agree to accept the King England as the King of Irelan..

The majority of them did that: civil war followed in Ireland. The Treaty dramatises those negotiations. lie to him, he turns to "Because you can!"

As an adult, Martin is no different, still prickly and suspicious of people. His camera is his way of keeping them at arm's length, of showing how little he trusts them.

Yet despite his lack of trust, he's still dependent on people for the descriptions of the pictures he takes. He needs their eyes to help him make sense of the world.

When he meets Andy, an amiable dishwasher in a restaurant, he seems to relax for the first time, to let, himself be helped. Andy describes his pictures, and gives him triendship. Messy, open-hearted and cheerful, Andy is the opposite of Martin, who's brusque and coldhearted, even verging on the callous in his treatment of his young housekeeper Celia, who's in love with him.

But Celia has plans for revenge, and what she tries to do forms the plot of the story, which is all about trust - when to give it, and who deserves it.

The film is neatly constructed, it has good performances, and there are some funny moments, so it's worth seeing. It's a little hard on Celia, perhaps too hard, so that we end up feeling sorry for her and the way Martin treats her. But we also feel sorry for Martin, not because of his blindness, but because of his stubbornness and his unwillingness to trust. They, not his lack of sight, are his real disabilities. Americas had a "gangster mentality" The behaviour of Columbus and his followers in the Americas is likened to the Vietnam War. Columbus's voyage of 1492 is "*the drama of a murderer coming ever closer to his unsuspecting victims".

But why was Columbus such a nasty person? Because, explains Koning, he was "a man of his race,... he was a typical man of the white West". Other races might behave cruelly, accepts Koning, but "what sets the West apart is its persistence, its capacity to stop at This approach to history reaches its climax in Koning's description of the Second World War as "the great whiterace civil war".

Koning calls for *an atonement of past crimes". (All 500 years of them?) "If we do not learn from history, we are doomed to repeat it" , warns Koning. So the next time someone "discovers" America, they should behave differently from Columbus?™ Koning deals not in terms of historical development but in terms of timeless moral categories - and even then not always accurately.

"The fateful year 1492" was the beginning of "an era of genocide, cruelty, and slavery, " he writes. In its earliest period of development, capitalism did resort to slavery in the Americas. But the further development of capitalism as a mode of production abolished the slavery which had been an element of all pre-capitalist forms of society (including those of the pre-Columbus Americas).

At the end of the day, Koning's view of history is that of the backwardlooking opponents of capitalism of 200 years ago. The "man of the white West" has fallen from a state of grace. He has corrupted what the French philospher Rousseau called "the noble savage".

Koning might be successful in debunking one mythology in which the past 500 years have been cloaked. But he merely ends up replacing one mythology with another.

Eric William's *Capitalism and Slavery" is not an ideologically righton' kind of book.

On the very first page, Williams talks about Columbus's "discovery of the New World", a phrase he uses repeatedNeer the and "the Negro race". He book. He talks about describes the historian Carlyle as *personifying reaction at its blackest".

Williams' use of the term "anti-imperialist" has nothing in common with its current connotations. Williams' "anti-imperialists" are the industrial virtue. Williams cuf through the cant. Abolition, dictated by economic need, was a case of "lucrative humanity". At a stroke, Williams shattered the selfsatisfaction fostered by bourgeois historians.

"Capitalism and slavery" is a book which bears the stamp of its time, such as uncritical use of the term "Negro" (The Trotskyist C.L.R. James also used the term without any equivocation). Whatever Williams' limitations as a politician (he later became Prime Minister of Trinidad and Tobago), the book is a starting point for any serious Marxist discussion about slavery.

In the run-up to the Columbus quincentenary, Williams' work merits republication far more than does that of Koning• His book is a historical polemic, whereas that of Koning is a personal whinge. More importantly, Williams, unlike Koning, has not just a sense of history but also an understanding of it.

Why was Columbus such a nasty cannot know why in terms of timeless moral categories, but onl terms of historical development

Scan page 14

Socialist Organiser No. 511 page 14 LET

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 511

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →