Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Stalinism and the century or the unexpected

Socialist Organiser no. 511, 9 January 1992 · scan pp. 12–13 · Anne Field · about 2,090 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 12

Moshe Machover contributes our continuing discussion on the class nature of the Stalinist states.

have read with interest the statement "What is Stalinism?" reprinted in Socialist Organiser 502, as well as the ensuing discussion in SO 506 and 508.

It is worth pointing out that the two views voiced in this debate — Socialist Organiser's (which seems to be almost identical to mine) on the one hand, and that expressed by Chris Arthur and Hillel Ticktin on the other - are in agreement over some important theoretical points.

Both SO and the Critique comrades reject the orthodox Trotskyist doctrine that regards Soviet-type societies as "transitional" formations between capitalism and socialism, presided over by "degenerated" or "deformed" workers' states. Equally, both you and the Critique comrades reject the rival doctrine, favoured by most heterodox Trotskyists, who regard those societies as state-capitalist.

Both you and the Critique comrades agree that Soviet-type societies are sui generis. But you differ on whether the ruling bureaucracy is (or was...) a class, as you assert (I think correctly), or a mere elite. More importantly, you regard those societies as representing a specific mode of production, whose historical role was to implement by noncapitalist means some of the transformations - the early stages of industrialisation and modernisation - which elsewhere were achieved by capitalism.

In this sense you regard that mode of production (again, correctly, in my opinion) as parallel to capitalism. The Critique view is that these societies are a piece of historical nonsense, "defective embryos" incapable of proper functioning and survival.

To some extent, these differences are merely semantic. But not entirely. Behind them lurk issues of greater theoretical import than the diagnosis of Soviet-type societies.

Chris Arthur lets one cat out of the bag when he repeats, with complete approval, Trotsky's well-known argument: if this is a new mode of production, then it must either be more progressive than capitalism or less progressive. If it is more progressive, then we face centuries of this mode of production. (Here Trotsky added something that Chris omits: he claimed that in this case the new mode of production must spread throughout the whole world). If it is less progressive, then history can regress. In either case, socialism is doomed.

Underlying Trotsky's argument — with which Chris, and I suspect also Hillel, concurs — is an over-schematic view of human history, according to which modes of production correspond to epochs, each lasting several centuries. These follow a single unilinear sequence, starting from primitive communism and progressing steadily towards the communist future. According to this the Soviet type of socioeconomic formation has proved to be extremely unstable and relatively short lived. But then som modes of production are less stable than others. " view, virtually all parts of humanity go through the same stages in the same order, albeit sometimes at an unequal pace.

Real human history has never been like that. Marx himself recognised an Oriental mode of production (Oriental Despotism"") which evidently never existed in Europe. On the other hand, most of Asia - the home of the vast majority of the human species -never went through a feudal mode of production (Japan is one of the rare exceptions to this rule!).

Similarly, although the institution of slavery was very widespread, most human societies never went through a slave-based mode of production, in which a major part of the surplus product is produced by slaves. Moreover, detailed study of non-European history has revealed the existence of several modes of production unknown to earlier generations of Marxists. Some modes of production were very widespread; others were confined to relatively small societies. Some were extremely stable; others much less so.

seems that virtually the whole of humanity is destined to go through the capitalist mode of production (which, by the way, has proved to be very stable - far more so than most Marxists have been prepared to admit). But in this respect, as in several others, capitalism represents an exception rather than the rule.

In other words, the true picture is one of considerable complexity. Far from forming a single linear succession, modes of production evolve along lines that sometimes bifurcate and diverge, and sometimes re-converge.

The bureaucratic mode of production represents one such bifurcation in history. It did in fact spread beyond the Soviet Union, but not throughout the world. With two notable exceptions (East Germany and Czechoslovakia) it spread into "underdeveloped" countries where for various reasons the "normal" development of capitalism was blocked or stunted. In some cases it was imposed partly or even largely by external Russian force; but these cases cover only a small part of the population of (what used to be) the "Second World"

For the most part, this mode of production was implemented by the initiative of a modernising elite, mainly of middle-class origin, that seized power from a workers' state (Russia) or led from the start its own revolution under a stolen red banner (China - the largest nation on earth - Vietnam, Yugoslavia, Cuba...). Having achieved power, that elite converted itself into a ruling In order to deny that this is a mode of production, the Critique comrades have to fly in the face of reality and deny the enormous initial achievements of those countries in the fields of industrialisation, modernisation and education. Hillel goes as far as to say that the surplus produced in the Soviet Union (and presumably also in China and other Second World countries) was mere rubbish, useless waste. If so, it is incomprehensible how the "non-class" that appropriated this surplus could not only live in lavish affluence, but also maintain a huge social apparatus of internal repression and a formidable armed force to defend and sometimes extend the domain of its rule. Apparently this "non-class" knew a thing good effect.

Hillel actually contradicts himself when he accepts the analogy between the USSR and *Neanderthal Man". No serious anthropologist will agree to the description of Homo neanderthalensis as a "defective embryo not having vital ingredients for life". What Homo neanderthalensis probably does represent is a bifurcation in the evolutionary history of the genus Homo, a species (or subspecies) that was eventually displaced by Homo sapiens.

It is, of course, true that the Soviet type of socio-economic formation has proved to be extremely unstable and relatively short-lived. But then, some modes of production are less stable than others.

at is true that Hillel Ticktin was one of the few people on the left who predicted the disintegration of the Soviet Union (from 1975 onwards). But this does not prove that his theory is necessarily correct. In order to forecast the terminal crisis of that system it was, of course, necessary to look closely at the reality of the Soviet Union, rather than be content with repeating old Trotskyist formulas mulas. It is to Hillel's credit that he observed that society closely; we all owe him a debt for his writings on Soviet reality.

However, he was by no means the only one to forecast the demise of that system. I, for one, made similar predictions in the 1970s, while defending a theoretical conception very similar to the present position of Socialist Organiser (see The Century of the Unexpected by John Fantham and myself, published in 1979 by Big Flame). I cannot claim any credit for this, however, because my own analysis of the crisis of the statecollectivist mode of production was largely based on the brilliant and seminal Marxist analysis contained in the famous "Open Letter" written by Kuron and Modzelewski in 1964.

These two Polish militants argued in detail that Poland (like other Second World countries) was a society under a new mode of production, which was based on class exploitation but was non-capitalist, and in which the role of ruling class was played by the central political bureaucracy.

They further showed that while this mode of production was quite successful in implementing the early extensive phases of industrialisation and modernisation, it became increasingly dysfunctional when it came to the more advanced, intensive and sophisticated phases. A period of terminal economic and social crisis set in. They concluded that:

"As the economic crisis cannot be overcome within the framework of present production relations, so, too, the general social crisis cannot be overcome within the limits imposed by prevailing social relations. A solution is possible only through the overthrow of prevailing production relations. Revolution is a necessity for development."

True, in 1964, Kuron and Modzelewski expected and hoped that the coming revolution would be a socialist one, led by the working class. But so did we all. None of us expected that capitalism would be not so much restored as re-invented in those countries without any serious resistance on the part of the working class.

The reason for this grave error has little to do with this or that analysis of Soviet-type societies. It has everything to do with the profound misconception (to which both Critique and Socialist Organiser seem to adhere even today!) that the present era, beginning from 1900 or 1914 or 1917, is a "transitional" era from capitalism to socialism, in which capitalism is "moribund" and "decayed" and is given a new lease of life merely due to the subjective failure of the workers' movement or the betrayals of its leadership.

But this is the beginning of an altogether different debate.

Scan page 13

Mar Anne Field reviews "Columbus: His Enterprise" and Eric William's "Capitalism and Slavery"

Dans Koning's *Columkind of book. It is part of the challenge to what Koning justifiably calls the "Eurocentric white-race oriented teaching of history".

Written in 1976, the book has now been republished by the Latin American Bureau as part of its preparations for next year's 500th anniversary of Columbus's historic voyage to the Americas.

At the level of debunking the mythology which has been spun around Columbus and his voyages mythology which will doubtless be given a fresh lease of life next year - Koning's book is a success.

In other respects, however, the does not make any sense at all.

According to Koning, capitalism was brought into being by a new outlook on life, rather than the other way around: "A new individualism began. At its best, it was to bring in the Renaissance, and its near worst, early capitalism" This is the only mention capitalism receives in his book.

Koning's historical analogies confuse rather than clarify. In his dealings with the Spanish monarchy Columbus used "what is now called salesman's psychology". He was *a worthy, if somewhat pathetic, predecessor of New York City's Madison Avenue".

The Spanish conquerors of the Socialist Organiser No. capitalists of the nineteenth century who campaigned for free trade to replace the preferential treatment enjoyed by the produce of Britain's colonies!

And yet Williams' work, written in 1944, is one of the greatest books about slavery ever written. Entire bookcases in libraries have been filled with works written in response to Williams" arguments.

Williams analyses the development of slavery in the Americas after their "discovery" in terms of the development of capitalism. He understands slavery in terms of historical development and economic need, and not abstract morality: "The eighteenth century, like any other century, could not rise above its economic limitations".

does not waste any time on *wouldn't it have been nice if.." speculations. The expansion capitalism, the emergence of a unified world economy, made slavery necessary at one stage deve onment. and superfluous at a higher stage: capitalists had first encouraged West Indian slavery, and then helped destroy it".

Nineteenth century capitalism was the age of industry, not hand-picked sugar. It was the age of free trade, not protective customs duties to guarantee a market for colonial produce.

Slavery in the colonies was an obstacle to the further development of capitalism. So capitalism swept it away. The opponents of slavery were "not only the humanitarians, but also the capitalists"

And Williams argues more controverThey sially -exaggerated the horrors of the sially, the humanitarians were liars.

Middle Passage (from Africa to the Americas)" in order to add weight to their demands for abolition of the slave trade. The horrors of the Middle Passage were "not something unusual or inhuman, but part of the age"

Before Williams, abolition of the slave trade and slavery had been portrayed as the selfless act of great men of

----- pull-quotes -----

*It is, of course, true that

"In order to deny that [Stalinism] is a mode of production the Critique comrades have to fly in the face of history."

His Enterprise", is an ideologically *right-on'

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 511

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →