Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Tur 1992the 192 the politica

Socialist Organiser no. 511, 9 January 1992 · scan pp. 8–11 · Martin Thomas · about 3,703 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

The year the Tories can be drive from office, and a Labour govern ment returned!

The year the labour movemer will begin to get its nerve back! Th year the "free-market" Thatcherit chickens will come home to roos for the bourgeoisie!

The year in which the right-win conventional wisdom of the 1980 will be routed by the social an economic consequences inflicted b its devotees and high priests on th working class!

It is the year in which the left ca begin to get its bearings again.

Some of these predictions depen on what socialists do - the reviva of the left, for example. Yet other are virtual certainties, or hav already begun to happen. Th market mania which is the core o Thatcherism is already bein discredited, and so is the labou movement's own diluted version d Thatcherism, retailed by no-gu Neil Kinnock.

Consider these points.

ONE: The Tories are in tremer dous difficulties. Everything is go ing wrong for them.

The economy is in a deepenin slump. Unemployment is risin again. All the bourgeois experts e pect it to keep rising, and to be 2 million, on the Government's rige ed official count, by the end 1992. The Tories will not be able t engineer • the sort of "electio boom" that helped them win i They are seen to be a divided par ty on Europe, and they cannot cor trol the political schedules of burc pean politics.

Their squawks about Labou policies meaning high taxes have li tle impact on people disgusted b the Tories' rundown of the N tional Health Service. Th

Scan page 9

n the tide in 1992. ah for Kinnock and Hattersley's right economic miracles they claimed to have worked are seen by more and more people to have been con-artist affairs.

What once seemed their most solid achievement - spreading home ownership — has jack-knifed on them, as tens of thousands of families are turned out of their homes because they can not keep up the mortgage payments.

Kinnock may yet help the Tories snatch victory from the jaws of defeat. But if the Tories win the coming election, it will only be because Neil Kinnock and his "team" have convinced the electorate that they are almost indistinguishable from the Tories, and passive, shifty, and unreliable as well.

The chances are that the tide is now flowing too strongly against the Tories for a "Kinnock miracle" to save them.

TWO: Labour is on course to form a government. Whatever Kinnock intends, that will begin to change the face of British politics, and of the working-class movement.

Such a Labour government dous contradiction. For most of a decade, Kinnock and his friends have purged and battered the Labour Party, trying to reshape it as a continental-style social-democratic party.

They turned themselves from parliamentary leftist phrasemongers, without theory or social perspectives, into pale-pink Thatcherites, or duck-egg blue neosocialists. It was plain that in office Kinnock would try to be like Gonzalez's Thatcherite "socialists" in Spain, Hawke's Australian Labor Party, or Lange's New Zealand Those "socialists" ran their BRITAN countries contemporary and parallel versions of Britain's Thatcherism. They embraced and advocated the "spirit of the age" in the 1980s, and Kinnock waited for his call to do the same in Britain.

It was never by any means a certainty that the British labour movement would allow Kinnock to get away with it, but it was certain that he would try.

And now where is he? The New Model Labour Party is likely to come to power when Thatcherism is being thoroughly discredited, and the market mania of the 1980s is being succeeded by widespread recognition that the social consequences are unacceptable even if it works the miracles it claims to -and it does not.

Already, in Australia, Paul Keating, once the most aggressive free-marketeer in Bob Hawke's cabinet, and now prime minister in place of Hawke, has signalled an about-turn, cancelling health service charges, for example.

In these circumstances, Kinnock in power is not likely to be able to sell neo-Thatcherite GonzalezHawke policies to the labour movement. Pressure will build up in the labour movement for traditional reformist and interventionist action by the Labour government. The labour movement will redefine itself in conflict with a Kinnockite Labour government!

All those on the left who refuse to fight with everything they can muster to kick the Tories out and put in a Labour government are being criminally foolish.

We can offer no guarantees that the labour movement will revive -quickly or evenly once the Tories are out and Labour is in. The memory of the bitter Thatcher years WHAT WE THINK may induce many to back a Kinnock government uncritically for a long time.

We do not know: but it is a certainty that the only way the mass labour movement will begin to revive politically is by way of the experience of kicking out the Tories, putting Labour in, and then confronting a Labour government trying to administer slump-ridden British capitalism.

HREE: The neo-liberal euphoria of the 1980s is everywhere now dissipating in face of the slump and aggravated social chaos and dislocation.

The triumph of marketism in the Stalinist world is accompanied by the exposure of its limits and consequences in the West; and it will quickly be accompanied by exposure of its terrible and lunatic consequences in the East.

A socialist counter-offensive is now becoming possible in a way it has not been for a long time. The search for answers to conditions like those in Britain will compel workers to reassess the socialist case — the case for real socialism, this time, not Stalinism.

The legacy of Stalinism is still a dead weight on the left. For the bourgeois anti-socialist propagandists, Stalinism still functions as a great anti-socialist scarecrow. They are still served well by the plausible lie that they have taken over tor their own purposes from Stalinism, that Stalinism was the real socialism.

But those lies will lose their power as marketism loses its lustre, and workers are driven by circumstances - and helped by publications like Socialist Organiser - to dig deep for the truth about socialism.

FOUR: For all the reasons above, the left will begin to get its bearings.

The way forward for the left can be outlined in a few sentences.

Go on the offensive against the ideologists of the New Right! The Right has never been right about anything. Even on Stalinism, the Trotskyist left was better and more consistent in its condemnation, clearer in its understanding, and more comprehensive and consistently democratic in its alternative to Stalinist elitism. The Right were able only to counterpose their own bourgeois elitism to the elitism of the Stalinists. Go after the Right!

Fight for a Labour government! The Labour Party is the mass party of the working class, its only possible governmental alternative to the Tories. Those socialists who "re1246 MILL PROFIT Car workers fight Labour-imposed wage restraint, ject" that movement and refuse to fight for a Labour government *because of Kinnock" are in fact abandoning politics for a preaching socialist sectarianism or a neoanarchism. (The SWP combines both - and then on election day usually adds "vote Labour" to ingratiate itself with Labour supporters!). Any socialist who voluntarily abandons the labour movement to the Kinnockites is simply not serious.

The serious left must regroup and fight for a Labour government.

And the left must organise our own forces to be effective in making our propaganda and in the battles of the class struggle. That is what the Alliance for Workers' Liberty exists to do.

Scan page 10

socialists have long argued that, because of forget our miserly attitude towards every exthe difficulties of centralising information, a cess minute of labour, and our humiliating Continding our ongoing offensive against the ideas of the New Rig Martin Thomas replies to David Marsland's argument for the free market and against socialist planning, published in the new Alliance for Workers' Liberty pamphlet, Socialists Answer New Right.

apitalism encourages and allows individuals to plan for themselves;

socialism means planning by Big Brother, which is unfree and anyway does not work. So David Marsland argues.

In fact planned co operation on a large scale was introduced into human life by capitalism, not by socialism. Modern methods of production involve intricate networks of cooperation linking thousands of people.

Under capitalism all that planned cooperation is shaped and regulated by the competing drives for profit of a minority of wealthy owners; and the planning is done despotically, from above, by those owners. Working-class socialism certainly does not mean replacing "unfettered command" by private capitalist owners with "unfettered command" by the state.

It means making the planned cooperation social and democratic; and regulating it so as to provide for every citizen comfort, security and, by cutting work time, free time.

Is planning workable?

David Marsland argues that planning on such a large scale cannot work. The central administration cannot conceivably gather all the relevant information fast enough. A market economy, by contrast, provides information where it is necessary in a deceniralised way.

There is some truth in this argument. In the dispute which David Marsland cites between Hayek and the maverick socialist economist Oskar Lange, I think Hayek was right. Lange's scheme, where the socialist administration is supposed to act like a socialist version of that theoretical fiction of academic economics, the "Walrasian auctioneer" who simultaneously finds prices to balance supply and demand in every market, is unworkable.

Rut Tange was a maverick. Marxian he driving force capitalis consume eman profit.

N DEPT workers* government would have to combine broad strategic planning with the use of markets (real markets, not Lange's pseudomarkets) for a long time.

Only the broad patterns of investment, social provision, and income distribution would be planned. Not all that planning would be centralised, any more than big capitalist corporations do all their planning in their head offices.

There would be tensions in the combination of planning and markets. A lot of experience from capitalist societies, however, shows it would be workable. Some highly successful capitalist systems, such as Japan's or South Korea's, have had effective government planning of major investment. It has been capitalist government planning, done bureaucratically, undemocratically, corruptly, and in the interests of profit. There is no reason to suppose that democratic planning would be less workable.

And then the working class, the great majority of the people, would no longer toil only to enrich the top 10 per cent, who in Britain own 53 per cent of all marketable wealth and almost all land and shares. Everyone could have a decent job, and the excess of what the workers produce over their own direct consumption would go to social provision and to socially-controlled investment.

We could get rid of the vast waste and duplication arising from capitalist competition - and its offshoots, such as advertising, excessive packaging, and so on - and economise on the labour currently used to provide luxuries for the rich. Cutting the competitive drive for profit would also cut the roots of conflict between nations, and open the way to redirect the huge resources currently spent on preparations for war.

We could ensure decent public services -health, education, child-care, transport. With improving technology, the working week, and thus the control of the economy over human life, could be cut, to allow free time for a society which is a free association of free individuals.

do without low fast the use of markets could be -reduced, and when and how it could be reduced to nothing, is a more difficult question. That reduction, I think, presupposes that the burden of drudgery to meet our material wants is cut to a low level, and that those material wants themselves become stable and are satisfied. As Trotsky put it, it awaits the time "when the steady growth of social wealth has made us bipeds HUD IGN claim be true, it that the workers that the by, in a li fe of dri at out fro n access ahtil 4 Lx. e ruined from one day to the next."

fear about the size of our ration"

The argument of Hayek, and other apologists for capitalism, rests on the axiom that it will never be possible to remove that "fear about the size of our ration" - that it is unchangeable human nature always to want to consume more, sooner. A competitive scramble for rations is therefore inevitable, and the market is a more flexible, dignified and efficient way to organise it than policemen and queues.

That argument, to my mind, is circular: it takes the patterns of behaviour shaped by capitalist economics, calls them human nature, and then triumphantly concludes that capitalism fits human nature! Obviously no-one can say for sure when, or it, a cooperative commonwealth could erode the anxious greed for property bred into us by capitalism. But even if it never could, even if socialism could never get beyond an uneasy compromise between democratic planning and markets, we need to get rid of capitalism.

For David Marsland's claims for capitalism do not stand up. The best gloss that can be put on his claim that capitalism encourages and allows individuals to plan for themselves is this: that the market informs those individuals of the limits put on them by the need to fit into a society based on largescale cooperation (as capitalism is), and does it in an efficient way, allowing the individuals to make dignified choices within those limits.

Ideal markets capitalism f that amou nts only saying is a gi way telling con lemn o scrape idgery anc wOr argely sh to the wer Ith a culture built on their labour. No doubt the discipline of the market is preferable to the slavedriver's whip, and it does leave the worker a choice about how to scrape by.

But capitalism disrupts workers' plans for their lives even within those limits. With high interest rates and unemployment, some 80,000 people lost their homes last year through mortgage repossessions; there must have been hundreds of thousands who avoided repossession only through desperate scraping by. Any plans you make in a capitalist economy can be ruined from one day to the next when you are thrown out of work; and millions are thrown out of work, forced on to the dole queue or into marginal jobs, all the time.

Marx put it like this: "The sphere of commodity exchange is a very Eden of the innate rights of man. It is the exclusive realm of Freedom, Equality, Property, and Bentham ...Bentham, because each looks only to his own advantage... When we leave this sphere, a certain change takes place in our dramatis personae. He who was previously the moneyowner now strides out in front as the capitalist; the possessor of labour-power follows as his worker. The one smirks selfimportantly and is intent on business; the other is timid and holds back, like someone who has brought his own hide to market and now has nothing else to expect but — a tanning."

David Marsland claims to defend capitalism. In fact he — like all the others who have undertaken the same grim task, Hayek, Friedman, and so on — defends only an idealised picture of "the sphere of commodity exchange"

Marx was only half-ironic. Free-market capitalism, as compared to serfdom or slavery, does bring a real expansion of freedom and equality. But

Scan page 11

ties of capitalism capitalism is not just a system of individuals making free and equal exchanges in a marketplace. Behind that market-place stands a system of production where the worker is unfree and unequal. The apparently free and equal exchange between buyer and seller of labour-power means in fact that in return for a routine pittance, scantier or more ample as it may be, the workers have to labour under the dictatorship of the capitalist and to increase the wealth of the capitalist.

Does capitalism mean "consumer sovereignty"?

And real capitalist markets do not correspond with the "ideal" of efficient, reliable N DEPTH wants which capitalism creates. Signals are sent through the market only by consumers with money, not by human wants or needs. The whim of the rich is satisfied; the desperate need of the poor is not.

Capitalism does not even satisfy the most basic physical needs of millions. An increasing number of people in the world today -some hundreds of millions — live on the edge of starvation. The poor countries of the Third World are just as much a part of world capitalism, with its patterns of uneven development, as are the relatively rich coun tries of the West.

Moreover, the big strategic investment decisions which shape the course of the economy are not dictated by consumer demand. At best market signals convey information only about now, not about the time, five, ten or fifteen years away, for which those big investments must be planned. Even Darges they area major source of avid Marsland argues that inequalities progress... They are a major source of incentive, aspiration, and ambition." In an idealised free-market economy made up of millions of small workshops or farms, this argument would have force. By making sure that the efficient workshop did better than the slovenly one, the market would promote progess.

It is also true that a workers' government would at first need inequalities as incentives. Skilled and conscientious workers would get more than unskilled and idle ones. But the idealised free-market economy has never existed and never will exist. Even if it did exist, it would be a cruel and arbitrary system for those many whom it recognises only as "dependents" - those too old or sick to work, housewives, and children (that is, everyone in a large and important part of their lives). And the major inequalities in capitalist societies today have nothing to do with differentials between more and less productive workers.

A series of excellent books — all written, be it noted, by supporters of capitalism — have recently told us a lot about what the rich actually do, and how they get rich. Read Liar's Poker, Barbarians at the Gate, or Maxwell: the outsider!

People who are very skilled and diligent at caring for children or the old, or educating, or scientific research, or engineering, or even production management, do not get rich. The skills and efforts encouraged by huge *incentives" under modern capitalism are those of the huckster and the wheeler-dealer. No doubt the skills of the energetic dealmaker and the fixer will be needed in a cooperative commonwealth, as they are needed in the labour movement today. But why should those skills be rewarded by huge riches? Why do they need to be? Moreover, the evidence is that when those skills are rewarded by huge riches, they are corrupted rather than refined. The Robert Maxwells, the John Gutfreunds, the Henry Kravises, the Ross Johnsons, become foolish self-indulgent despots, if not outright crooks. Nares this in a apia so world here evertheless, argues David Marsland, argues this in a capitalist world where 1500 million people in two subcontinents, sub-Saharan Africa and South Asia, have an average food consumption of only 2200 calories per head, while the World Health Organisation sets the minimum for health at 2600 calories! That the poorest countries often have governments calling themselves "socialist" does not lift the blame from capitalism. From Nigeria to Bangladesh, these are capitalist countries, shaped over

Organiser

centuries capitalist rule trade. • In Britain people do not starve. It seems to me rather sick to give great credit to capitalism for this fact, when technology today allows only five per cent of the workforce to produce more than enough food for everyone.

Even in relatively rich Britain, a survey published in June last year found that hundreds of thousands of small children go without enough to eat at least once a month because their parents are short of cash; well over a million have "nutritionally poor" diets. Diseases of poverty such as rickets have reappeared.

Some hundreds of thousands - no-one knows exactly how many - are homeless. Yet David Marsland asserts that "real poverty" is "obsolete", , and the illusion of continuing poverty is sustained only by "the Poverty Lobby's spurious identification of economic inequality with poverty" - No-one equates poverty with economic inequality. A millionaire and a billionaire are economically unequal, but the millionaire is not poor. However, a homeless family in Britain today living in a council-provided bedand-breakfast place is poor, even if their food, their clothing, their amusements, and even the squalid room they live in, would look like wealth to a medieval peasant.

Human beings are social animals. Human life is not just biological survival as individuals, but life in society. To get out of poverty means more than not starving or freezing to death; it means being able to take a normal and dignified part in society.

Capitalism does create poverty. Regularly and routinely, workers are paid no more than the value of their labour power, which is defined by a "living wage" adequate to keep the working class fit for work. Regularly and routinely, workers are poor relative to the riches they produce for the capitalist class and its hangers-on. And, while the averagelypaid worker generally scrapes by in modest comfort, regularly and routinely capitalism throws millions out of their jobs. Capitalism cannot work without unemployed people, and without those unemployed people being unable to maintain even a working-class standard of living, The pauper existence of the unemployed may mean starvation, or it may mean only discomfort and misery. It matters which. Capitalism modified by reforms imposed by the labour movement is better than unmodified capitalism; liberal capitalism is better than capitalism mixed with archaic or semi-feudal survivals; prosperous capitalism is better than stagnant, backward capitalism.

None of that should make us "marvel at the market's gifts to mankind" - or to tolerate the fact that, under capitalism, so many human beings have to give up so much of their dignity, their energy, their hopes and their happiness to a cruel and inhuman

----- pull-quotes -----

BACKS = ROBBER STUFE THE 5/

Does capitalism destroy poverty, or create it?

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 511

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →