Orange Labour?
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-01-09Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
A systematic reign of terror was rebruary 1914, ine miners strike inflicted on the Catholic popula- led to a General Election which Republican demo 1974. Any more attempts to beat down the Catholics will be
TIDE
Matgamna t looks, doesn't it, as if Tories have lost the next out of control. Despite Kinnock's craven immobility, Labour might win the election!
What if Labour "wins" the next election and forms a government but without an overall majority? Right now the opinion polls suggest that this is a serious possibility. Then Kinnock will do what James Callaghan did in 1977 and after when Labour no longer had a majority — he will wheel and deal with the smaller parties and do trade offs for support to keep his government in power.
Deals like those of the "70s with the Liberal Democrats are not likely to push Kinnock's Labour Party far off the course its leaders would follow anyway. Unless the improbable happens and Kinnock concedes P.R. to the Liberal Democrats in return for support or partnership - and I think that is very improbable — no dramatic policy shifts are likely to result.
But what if, for example, the Liberal Democrats hold out for P.R. and a Labour Government does a deal with the Ulster Unionist MPs. who will number least a dozen?
That is something else Labour did in the :70s!
Dramatic shifts in British government policy on Northern Ireland would be the minimum price of a Unionist deal with Labour. This seems to me to be one of the things to look out for and warn against.
There is not much in the record of the last Labour government — certainly not after 1975- which we can be proud of. But nothing is quite as shameful as what happened in Northern Ireland under that government.
SAri MCOOL 25 YEARS 3 "neither desirable nor possible. tion, and events were set in motion which culminated - after the Tories were back in control at Westminster - in the hunger strikes of 1981 in which 10 Republicans were allowed to die of starvation. One reason the Labour government allowed the British Army to do what it did in Northern Ireland after 1976 was Labour's need for the support at Westminster of such Unionist MPs as the late Harold McCusker.
It was no less a man than Michael Foot, long time tribune of the Parliamentary Labour left, who did the wheeling and dealing with the Orange politicians. Among other things, he negotiated with them a big increase in Northern Ireland's representation at Westminster (from 12 seats up to 17).
The need to neutralise or gain the support of Unionists at Westminster was only one factor shaping Labour's policy, or, to b more precise, the policy Labour allowed the Army and the "Security Services" - the same Security Services" that were busily conspiring to undermine and discredit the Labour government - to carry out.
But it was certainly a factor ant probably a big one. Right now, Unionist politicians are hoping for a rerun. They might get it. Let us look back a little closer at what Labour did then.
The Tories tried using big stick against the Catholics when they cam to power in mid-1970. All the achieved was to stoke up the deep fires of Catholic resentment and to help the IRA grow into a powerful movement with mass support. The effect of internment in Augu: 1971 was the exact opposite c what was intended by its architects. It made much of NI ungovernable.
When the paratroopers ran amok and shot 13 unarmed men dead for marching in a peaceful demonstration in Derry on 30 January 1972, the horrified outcry against this savagery made the British government change course:
They abolished majority - that is Protestant - home rule in Northern Ireland, and sought to create institutionalised power sharing with a guaranteed place in a Belfast government for representatives of the Catholic people. After bitter pro-Unionist opposition they managed to set up such system at the beginning of 1974, resting on parties representing a minority of Protestants and a majority of the Catholics. In 1AMA AL 19 YEAS157 NOEL SEAMU:
CAIRNS RGUSO! 10 YEARS (TYREZ YEARS SEAMUS SOLE 12 YEARS brought Labour back to power.
In the same election, the Protestants voted massively for Unionists opposed to the Belfast power-sharing government (based on a Northern Ireland parliamentary election 6 months earlier). A powerful Orange general strike broke out in May 1974 against the power-sharing executive and a feeble Council of Ireland then being set up. The Labour government buckled and the power-sharing executive collapsed.
This would have been a good thing if the Labour government had drawn the necessary conciusion: that since the Protestant majority — for whose protection from all-Ireland Catholic domination the Six County state had been set up - could not be trusted with majority rule over the Catholics, the whole structure had to be radically overhauled on an all-Ireland and maybe British Isles basis.
abour concluded nothing o the sort. It called elections for a Northern Ireland Constitutional Convention in which Catholics and Protestants would try to work out a modus vivendi within the Six County framework. But there was no hope of this — it is im probable they ever thought there was. The majority of Catholics wanted powersharing and had now wonby way of the IRA military campaign — a veto on Protes tant majority rule; the majori ty of Protestants would not have power-sharing or links with Dublin at any price.
After a year the Assembly collapsed.
And then the Labour government committed a gross betrayal against the Northern Ireland Catholics.
In the last 3 years of Labour rule, the Catholics got nothing be savage repression. While Michael Foot and his friends hobnobbed with the Unionist MPs at Westminster, the Army and the RUC did the sort of things the Orangemen wanted doing in NI.
The British Army started a driv against the Republicans which included systematic mass house sear ches for arms - in practice, they went about the Catholic districts wrecking houses, and furniture, sometimes repeatedly. This went on for years.
After Bloody Sunday, when the Tory government abandoned the big stick, political prisoners had been given some political rights in jail: Labour took away those rights and began to try to crush the prisoners by "criminalising" them. They resisted in the jails for years, culminating in the hunger strike in 1981.
One consequence of the O repression unleashed by Labour after 1976 was the growth of mass Catholic support for the Provisional IRA and Sinn Fein, especially at the time of the hunger strike and after. Election results showed that more than one in three Catholics backed Sinn Fein. There was a move away from the middle-class Catholic nationalist party, the SDLP.
To stop the peaceful nationalis shrinking and Sinn Fein from cor tinuing to grow, new political initiatives were started in the '80s.
In November 1985, a LondonDublin agreement was signed which, against the tremendous indignation of the Protestants and widespread resistance, gave Dubli a political say in the running of Northern Ireland.
Socialists should not give positive backing to that agreement, but even weak Dublin involvement in Northern Ireland on behalf of the Catholics, is better than what they had before. The scrapping of this agreement is something the Orange politicians hope to gain if they hold the balance of power at Westminster after the General Election.
A hundred years ago and then again 80 years ago, Irish Nationalist MPs holding the balance of power at Westminster forced the Liberals to bring in Home Rule Bills: the Unionists now hop to be in the same position and get the concessions they want.
As the Six County entity recreated, within a smaller area, an intensified version of the all-Ireland Protestant-Catholic conflict, so - in the '70s and maybe in the "90s - has been recreated the political role at Westminster that in times of instability the Iris MPs used to play - with the Unionists playing the role the Nationalists used to play.
egular readers of Socialist •Organiser know that we are as far from the identikit left's demonisation of the Northern Ireland Protestants as we are from that left's demonisation of Israel and "Zionism". [In principle it is the same issue in both cases].
The Northern Ireland Protestants have an inviolable right ti their identity and they should not be forced against their will into a united Ireland under majority Catholic rule without any protection for the minority.
We believe that the only solution is a united Ireland, but that the only possible or desirable united Ireland is one in which the Protestants have regional autonomy.
But no good can come from another attempt to beat down the Catholics: this is neither desirable nor possible. The Catholics will not be beaten down. A step back from the London-Dublin agreement of 1985 to the policies of thi late '70s, or anything like it wouk be the beginning of a new cycle o horror inflicted on people who have known little else for over 20 years.
Make no mistake about it: the present Labour leadership are capable of that! The Front Bench which rushed - on the initiative of one-time leftist Margaret Beckett, it seems — to support demands that the government should pick up the bill for the crass stupidity of the super-rich speculators, the Lloyds "Names' when they got into trouble, in order to show Labour's good wil towards the whole species of financial parasites - that Front Bench is capable of anything!
It is capable, for example, of once again inflicting internment without charge or trial, as the price of Unionist support at Westminster.
The new upsurge in the Provisional IRA's campaign and the continuing intractability of the Northern Ireland conflict make il ternment a real possibility in the period ahead. There might be a 'happy coincidence" of Army pressure for internment and Labour's need for Unionist support at Westminster.
We can not know exactly. Bul the left must stand on watch. AIRER A victory for Labour need not mean a 1 wing policies is the yea is th 'tide will turn!
----- pull-quotes -----
election? Everything is going wrong for them, everything is
JOHH BURKE LIFE