Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Brother Laird' exciting vision Gavin Laird, he's go

Socialist Organiser no. 511, 9 January 1992 · scan p. 4 · about 584 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

of British trade unionism" or some such; Laird respond ed by accusing Gill of racism and then delivered a coup de grace by reading out key passages from a 'Japanese'The brilliant performance was all the more effective because Laird had seized upon a real weakness of the So it comes as no surprise to find that January's AEU Journal editorial, brimming over with radical phraseolog: and exciting new ideas, is penned by one G. Laird. The editorial advocates a bigger, better union, offering "unparalleled service" to members and shop stewards. The requirements of women members and the cause of Equal Opportunities are given prominence; a challenge to new technology, a breakdown of traditional craft differentials Convention of the Teamsters for a Democratic Union in October 1990 of the Teamsters for a Democratic Union in October 1990 and the need for "real safeguards" for members faced with the economic power of the multinationals are highlighted; the need to come to terms with "the enormous process of change" taking place in Europe and the links with "our sister unions in Europe" are central to Bro. Laird's case. "Alongside this great development, arguments about internal structure look very short-sighted. Our activists and members are rightly proud of our past but together we need to build the future. That will require change. What that change will be is now completely in the hands of our members — exactly where Who could disagree with all that? Who could fail to be excited by the vista conjured up by Bro. Laird? Only the "most cynical and backward looking persons surely".

Of course all this eloquence is to one objective: to secure the 'Yes' vote for amalgamation with the EEPTU, creating a super union to be called the Amalgamated Some of us cynical and backward looking people have been opposing these developments for some time, pointing out that it would result in the EEPTU creeping back into the TUC without renouncing the scabbing and poaching activities that led to its expulsion in 1988.

Bro. Laird even had an answer to this objection, arguing that a vote against amalgamation is a vote against the TUC"! I won't bore you with the byzantine logic that lies behind that particular claim but you have to adThe point is that some of Laird's case is strong. A big united engineering/electrical union makes good industrial sense. Part of the reason the Broad Left's opposition to the merger has been so half-hearted and (until recently) ineffectual is that it has few answers to the kind of points Laird makes, falling back all too often upon crude appeals to AEU separatism and "traditions". The (relatively) democratic internal structure of the AEU is important and worth defending but the basic case against the merger is quite separate from this: it is that such a merger would create an immensely powerful right wing block promoting blatant business unionism within the British labour movement. The case against amalgamation boils down to class politics — on any other terrain Gavin you have to hand it to INSIDE style. Like all the best right wingers, the THE UNIONS AEU's General Secretary is a past master at making his views sound fresh and progressive whilst portraying his opponents as narrowminded reactionaries.

The classic example of this occurred at last year's TUC when Ken Gill of the By Sleeper MSF launched into a denunciation of 'Japanese' working methods as 'alien to the traditions style agreement signed by the... MSF.

TUC left'. it should be."

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 511

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →