Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Strike in Hungary

Socialist Organiser no. 511, 9 January 1992 · scan pp. 2–4 · about 2,025 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 2

Troubles is nothin it is the ecuivalent of S3.5 future. For instance, rents in apartments -45n5 HA DOSOI truổN r ANS trangely, Yeltsin's popularity is still high nent itself is unpopular. This is and people TEve In a way the new bureaucrats Stalinist bureaucrats. They are more corBUCES T tand that DOSTORI unstable. want to grab what they can today in case they lose their jobs tomorrow. The NEWCE CASE SUTCOE their position.

prospects for the left in good. socialists is the current low level OE SULLEE 101 The Russian Party of Labour of clarifying its general political positi John Cunningham reports from Hungary yorkers in Hungary Vi have taken the first step in expressing their growing dissatisfaction with the decline of • living AILY HAL Russia snubs our free beef The Star was outraged when Russians were slow to take British beef, suspecting BSE.

The News of the World reported on cops doing Dib reform by legalla standards, rising and low wages.

17 December 1991 saw the first 'sztrákkenyer' (literally "breadstrike': it is difficult to translate into English but means something like 'return to basics'). It was a largely symbolic attair, limited to a two hour stoppage, but met LOVER'S TVAND DIET ¡CINEMA E GUIDE •Vine eherte in 9 Oliver Sun FRANCE ODEVERE ADALA FOR AE1 TE REID with an enthusiastic response from the Hungarian workers' movement.

With miners and railway workers in the forefront, over 100,000 stopped work, some for longer than the two hours.

According to the Hungarian newspaper Kurir (Courier), about the same number didn't strike but showed sympathy with its aims and objectives by flying blue flags or wearing blue armbands.

Some newspapers dubbed the action the 'kék cédulás' strike (literally blue strip of paper'). This was a none-toosubtle slur on the workers' movement implying that the number of strikers had been grossly exaggerated.

It is a double insult because it equates the chosen colour of solidarity with the rigged elections of the late 1940s, when the Stalinists took over in Hungary. The ballot slips were also blue, and Communist Party hacks often voted 5 or 6 times.

Although only two hours long, the strike was an important step forward for the Hungarian workers, particularly for those sou working in the State-controlled industries who are likely to bear the full brunt of future sellbits, rationalisations and sosures sakhurdia to buttress his rule remains intact, and it is reported that Gamsakhurdia has vowed to return to Georgia to wage guerrilla war against the military council.

The situation looks unstable; and the council's supporters now seem seriously split.

Gamsakhurdia was jailed for nationalist activities in the '50s and "70s. He publicly recanted but re-emerged as a nationalist leader in 1988. In the wake of the April 1989 Tbilisi massacre (when Soviet troops killed 20 protesting Georgians), Gamsakhurdia became the only leader capable of uniting the nationalist movement and its factions.

won overwhelming Helectoral support in October 1990 and in May 1991, when 85% voted for him as president.

He gained the support of the Georgian intelligentsia in addition to his important "home base" in the peasantry of western building in Tbilisi least four Gamsakhurdia supporters when they fired on last Friday's peaceful demonstration [3 January] in support of the president).

Much of the National Guard continued freelance activities under anti-Gamsakhurdia leaders. The Soviet troops in Georgia remained neutral, and there was no effective centre of Despite the authoritarian nature of the Gamsakhurdia regime, the opposition seems to be no more than a small middle-class group in Tbilisi, supported by a couple of thousand National Guardsmen under their disaffected officers.

The new rulers do not appear to have any alternative policies, any widespread support or any real motivation outside of personal animosity and distrust of Gamsakhurdia. They were brought to power by the 2,500 National Guardsmen, not by any mass movement of the Georgian workers or peasants.

Scan page 3

That is happening in the former USSk now is a grotesque triumph of unreason.

In its destructiveness and senselessness, it will rank in history with the carnage of the First and Second World Wars as an almost inexplicable piece of 20th century madness.

At the behest of men like Boris Yeltsin and other ex-Stalinists, men who have been through their whole lives members of the corrupt old Stalinist ruling class, nearly 300 million people are now being pitched into the maelstrom of deliberately created or intensified economic chaos. humane control of economic life efforts rational and are deliberately, ostentatiously, and wilfully rejected in a mad dash to create a functioning capitalist market economy in the shortest possible time.

According to the Financial Times, people in Moscow were already spending an average of 80 per cent of their incomes on food even before the price rises decreed on 2 January. Now prices have gone up to three, four, or five times what they were.

Some ninety cent of Moscow's population will be forced down below the official poverty line. Forty percent fear that they will lose their jobs in the coming chaos, and economic experts reckon that they could indeed.

Vast numbers will go hungry or starve. Famine conditions, not widely known in the USSR since the days of the Second World War, will reappear:

ahe ex-Stalinist aspiring capitalists say to the people: fend for yourselves as best you can; starve if you have to.

Yeltsin and his friends, egged on by the gleeful bourgeoisie in the West, want capitalism. They are as inhumanly dogmatic and ruthless about it as ever Stalin was about his version of "socialism"

Their problem is that there is not in existence in most of the ex-USSR a real bourgeoisie. There are only the beginnings of one, crystallising out of the old mafia-like ruling class and the old black-marketeers and bandits. The economy is mainly state property still, not private property. Markets are rudimentary or chaotic.

In short, where in, say, Britain, the interplay of markets and profit in a mainly privately-owned economy exists as an organic historically-evolved system which works — however badly - nothing like that exists in the USSR. It can only come into existence there as a result of a long journey through a murderous chaos.

What used to exist in the USSR was a badly decrepit command economy run by the central state, which notionally, and in part really, directed and planned the economy. In Stalin's day, not only economic privileges but also stark gun-to-thenape-of-the-neck terror was the mechanism by which those at the top of the pyramidic ruling class exercised a dynamic and coordinating control over the economy.

After the 1950s, when the terror was relaxed, the bureaucracy became fatter and more complacent. It developed into a great corrupt mafia, squatting on society.

With the working class rigidly suppressed, and unauthorised markets and entrepreneurs driven underground and into the shadows, this system had neither the human rationality of democratic socialist planning, nor the brutal economic rationality of a free market regulated system ruled by the flow of profit.

n the 25 years before 1985, when Gorbachev came to power, the vast bureaucracy frustrated many attempts to reform the system from within and from on top.

Gorbachev took over a vast, overextended mess, where up to 40% of output went annually to arms production to sustain the empire and the competition with Europe and America. With his "glasnost", Gorbachev began to expose the bureaucracy to social criticism, trying to whip it into change. He withdrew from Afghanistan and signalled that he "That is what they are doing now, with a brutality and savage indifference to human life remarkably similar to those with which Stalin introduced forcible collectivisation and breakneck industrialisation 60 years ago." would not back the puppet Stalinist regimes in Eastern Europe against their people.

Disintegration followed quickly. The prisoners in the jail-house of nations that was the USSR and Eastern Europe took the chance to assert themselves. Glasnost, with its treedom of speech, meant from the beginning a surrender of one of the key levers of bureaucratic control. It inevitably generated demands that could not be denied for more concessions and more change.

As by degrees the bureaucracy lost its monopolies and prerogatives, it proved more and more helpless and, as Gorbachev found last August when it backed the coup against him, treacherous. Demagogues, in the first place former Moscow party boss Yeltsin, won over the people.

Gorbachev had the odium of responsibility, but less and less power to shape events. Last August the dying bureaucracy he had tried to serve and renew organised a feeble and inept coup, and broke its neck in the attempt. Power fell into the hands of those outspokenly committed to cultivate and restore capitalism.

That is what they are doing now, with a dogmatism, a recklessness, a brutality, and a savage indifference to human life remarkably similar to those with which Stalin introduced forcible collectivisation and breakneck industrialisation 60 years ago.

There are differences, of course: the mass grayes that may result from Yeltsin's forced decollectivisation will not also have in them bodies with bullets in the back of their neck. anstead of going from the irrationality of bureaucratic "planning" in the dark, on top of a stifled people, to an attempt at democratic working-class overall planning, using market mechanisms where appropriate and to the extent appropriate within that framework, the ex-Stalinists around Yeltsin have set out on a demented scramble to become capitalists.

We see naked bourgeois market relations imposed with breakneck speed and indifference to the immediate consequences.

Capitalism, even when it "works", is everywhere irrational.

But its irrationality is hidden by familiarity and by checks and balances which operate most of the time. In the ex-USSR now the unreason at the heart of capitalism can be seen naked and gruesome.

Capitalism works way off periodic crises which render the system healthy again by way of the mass destruction of wealth, before a new expansionary cycle begins. We see it happening in Britain now. In the USSR capitalism can only come into existence there as the dominant system by way of a gigantic exploSIon of social and economic destruction.

The peoples of the ex-USSR are embarking on a forced march in which will be encapsulated pue telescoped the bloody, wasteful and inhuman experience with capitalism of human society so far But in the early centuries of capitalism there was no other way forward possible for humankind to advance. What is happening in the USSR is entirely unnecessary. Something better would be possible if the working class there had not for so long been stifled and poisoned by Stalinism. Wis rulers of the ex-USSR e know why the ex-Stalinhave opted to replace their old bureaucratic system with capitalism. man like Boris Yeltsin, who has spent his whole life as a privileged member of the corrupt old Stalinist ruling class, could hardly lead a socialist revolution in And we know why workers there, misruled and oppressed for so long by a grotesque and incompetent Stalinist central state, go along with the Yeltsins and sometimes urge them on. We have tried to explain these things repeatedly in Socialist Organiser over recent years.

And we do believe that, despite everything, despite hardships and horrors, it is better for the working class there to have the rights to think, discuss and argue it has for now, than to have the wretched, but stable, "security" stifling bureaucratic dictatorship.

The chaos now engulfing the former USSR is the consequence, the last consequence, of Stalinism. The condition, moral, political and economic, to which it has reduced the working class that it shaped, is its latest vast crime against the working class.

All that socialists in Britain can do is to understand; to give what help we can to socialists in the former Stalinist territories; and, in the light of the horrors now unfolding, to explain why capitalism is not and cannot be a progressive alternative even to the misery of Stalinism.

Sprint Orgenisert pare

Scan page 4

ocialist Organiser No.

----- pull-quotes -----

eselcen From front page

DON'T END-

hine NEWS. MY JAIL HEL GREAT LOVEJOY CONTESTI BY SPENDEA

COPS AND BROTHELS

ONE HAS SACKED

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 511

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →