SWP: no democracy, no programme and no party
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-12-05Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 14
Socialist Workers Party's internal life or well over twenty -years now the SWP and its forerunners have maintained a deeply contradictory attitude to the Labour Party. As the years have gone by this has led to their politics getting more and more inconsistent so that now the SWP effectively has two policies on the There is the 'normal' attitude which amounts to defining themselves as a single issue campaign with the object of getting disillusioned people to leave the Labour Party.
Then there is the 'election time' policy of making a great fuss about being 'pro-Labour' best summed up in Paul Foot's immortal prose during the "79 General Election campaign: "During the next few weeks I will be a very strong Labour supporter" and absolutely cynically outlined in their recen conference documents:
"Labour may very well lose [the election]. It would then be very difficult to intervene in arguments amongst the best Labour voters as to what went wrong if we were seen to have abstained".
This is advertising agency In both cases, what the SWP does is tail-end passing moods presenting themselves as the militant embodiment of these moods rather than working out a consistent policy.
Thus you get the ludicrous situation of calling on people to quit the Labour Party and then calling on workers to elect the same party! [Presumably minus as many class struggle socialists as possible, thus weakening our ability to force Kinnock to concede to working class demands.
This confusion has been deepened by their latest conas the militant embodiment of these moods rather than working out a consistent policy." ference document which moves towards an understanding of the Labour Party as fundamentally no different from, say, the US Democratic Party.
"Historically, Labour was a bourgeois workers' party, not simply in the sense that it got workers' votes, but also that it had a cadre of working class activists"
But this is beside the point. The US Democrats have a considerable amount of working class electoral support and some working class activists, but this doesn't make the party a "bourgeois workers' party". On the basis of this reasoning, if the SWP are to be consistent they would call for a vote for the Democratic Party in the US and for the ANC in a future But of course they won*t; that would not be seen as radcial enough.
In reality, what defines the Labour Party as a 'bourgeois workers' party" is its organic link to the unions.
But this is only brought up a an afterthought by the SWP leadership in the context of explaining to their more naive comrades that no matter how hard they huff and puff, they won't blow Kinnock's house down. "None of this means the Labour Party is going to disappear... it has an organic connec tion with class organisations."
Thus the two lines continue to co-exist in an unstable compound resulting in no coherent policy for the poltical wing of the mass labour movement.
This brings us to the question of programme. Several resolutions made it into SWP head office calling for the party to adopt a programme. There then followed a very stilted 'debate' in the pages of the pre-conference bulletins.
In essence, a party programme is nothing more nor less than a given tendency's relationship to the class that it would aspire to lead. In addition to immediate perspectives that is providing an answer to the question "What next?" A fully developed programme must include an understanding of the working class as it exists and how it must change ideologically and politically to become fit to pursue the goal o working class self-rule: of the relationship between working class power and the final goal of communism; and an understanding of the nature of the world around us from the Labour Party under Kinnock to the collapse of Stalinism and the "triumph of capitalism".
In this sense, the SWP's lack of a programme is nothing more nor less than its refusal to try and make sense of the real world.
Neither side in the SWP discussion seem to be properly aware of this.
One 'faction', with support in the Liverpool and Hornsey branches at least, wants a programme and called for the SWP to set up a special programme" commission.
The Central Committee' opposed this - but not in their own name. They got Gareth Jenkins to argue for them: *The possession of a formal programme guarantees nothing" [true, but irrelevant).
"We do have a programme. In addition to 'What we stand for' in the paper, there are also the perspectives that flow from our concrete analysis... on fighting the Tories, reacting to the Gulf War etc."
So Gareth tells the comrades: «We don't need one but, just in case we do, we actually have опе". . Ingenious, but not very convincing. [He'll have to wait longer for his seat on the CC, think].
Gareth then shoots himself in the foot by attempting to insert some "theory' to justify his stance:
•Trotsky was at his strongest when putting forward concrete perspectives in response to developments like the rise of fascism in Germany". Precisely!
But try and find a 'concrete perspective' other than hate Kinnock but vote Labour in the pages of Socialist Worker.
You won't. The SWP has no programme because they have no policy for the mass labour movement as it actually exists... just the desire that it be different. Pio take on the onerous oor Gareth also had task of defending the Central Committee's proposal to abolish what remains of the SWP's severel! limited internal democracy - the National Committee.
The CC announces: *This year we have abolished the branch committee structures which ran the branches for the best part of ten years... In the past year, the National Committee has been largely irrelevant... activity has been pushed by the Central Committee, by the organisers and by the activists inside the branches" Hence good bye National Committee.
So the SWP has now adopted a structure which consists of a handful of full-time organisers [the Central Committee), branch leadership 'teams" [arguably a new word for the old 'abolished' branch committee] and... nothing else, except what ad hoe meetings the Central Committee may feel like calling.
The idea of what in Leninist theory a National Committee should be — a politically selected forum that combines and balances seasoned cadre with the best fresh organisers with the aim of checking, developing, reassessing and testing the organisation's activi ty - has been totally lost.
In its place, you have an arguably less democratic structure than the Bolsheviks were forced to employ under conditions of Tsarist illegality.
A structure that would delight Joyce Gould. As one recent ex-SWer commented: "1 'The tragedy is that the SWP have now adopted an internal structure which confirms exactly what an anti-Marxist and anti-Leninist bourgeois academic or journalist would say is Leninism. "
Teft the Labour Party to join the SWP because the Laboar Party was becoming buresucratic. But the SWP was no different. In two years i got just one vote and that was just to rubber-stamp a branch committee slate."
To justify such centralisation, you get the kind of crass caricature that I thought the SWP reserved for their opponents on the left, but it seems they employ amongst themselves. Gareth again:
*Saying the CC has too much power, is to misunderstand what democratic centralism is about... spending tim consulting the members as to whether this or that initiative is correct would inevitably mean missing opportunities and turning the organisation into a debating club".
Presumably the CC will make the trains run on time as well.
The tragedy here is that the SWP have now adopted an internal structure which confirms exactly what an anti-Marxist and anti-Leninist bourgeois academic or journalist would say is Leninism.
They are a living caricature, the exact opposite of what they used to be in the dim and distant 'anti-Leninist' past of the early '60s Cliff group.
Back then they spent most of their time attacking Gerry Healy's Socialist Labour League for displaying exactly the same characteristics as they do now.
The only reason this can come about is that the SWP leadership has never digested or understood what a revolutionary party is all about.
For them, "Building the par(y" simply means, first and foremost, building an organised machine. Politics comes a very poor second.
But a 'revolutionary party' not the poses, badges and slogans of the SWP. On the contrary, to build a revolutionary party, is to take part the concentrated organised ef fort of a Marxist tendency directed to the purpose of fighting the class struggle on industrial, political and ideological fronts.
That is the task that the Alliance for Workers Liberty sets itself.
----- pull-quotes -----
EYE=ON THESIEFT Tom Rigby concludes his examination of the
"What the SWP does is tail-end passing moods, presenting themselves