Anti-Zionism and anti-semitism
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-12-05Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 14
Or does not seem helpful to pursue the recent disagreement between Socialist Organiser and the Jewish Socialists' Group.
There is however, one major point in Sean Matgamna's reply to David Rosenberg's letter (SO507) which cannot go unchallenged.
That is that "the anti-Zionism of the left is currently the most important form of anti-semitism in Britain"
Attacks on Jewish cemeteries and synagogues and the distribution of antisemitic literature are carried out not by the left, but by the far-right.
The far-right are also involved in physical attacks on Jews, black people and other minority groups.
At a time when support for fascist parties is growing throughout Europe, we should not underestimate the threat posed by the far-right in Britain.
This is not to ignore the fact that there is also antiWHATSS-ON "Where we stand", Plymouth SO NEd jeeting, Bepr moncee, JpesI : 300 SpeRMeN ISDOrE Satundey 1, Decennber MElenti , essemble T Dinity Trige meptingse Murphy Blackpool. Speakers inicluge iceri J Steven Mi Elel Kowed pe SD wrel "Where londay 8 December поінив метано Lora VACHY S HACLIm Thei futurem ardihe student Rieey Workers' Liberty on Le Pen, May 1988 semitism in the mainstream of our society, including of the Press and, indeed, parts of the political left as well.
However, it can only help the cause of the fascists if groups like Socialist Organiser and the Jewish Socialists' Group get caught up in disputes.
Of course we value Blew waves of old-style washing across Europe. on all these issues, but when a short letter from one of our members is answered by a full-page condemnation of our organisation by you, we feel that the energy spent in this way, is not progressive.
Myra Woolfson, Jewish Socialists' Group National Committee contend that the coverage in Socialist Organiser and in Workers' Liberty, our magazine, has underplayed the danger from the new wave of anti-semitism? She couldn't, noi seriously.
The new wave of open antisemitism is a relatively recent development. The demonisation of Israel and the comprehensive left wing' hostility to Jews that goes with it, have been with us for a couple of decades.
Even the anti-semitic thugs — those of them who can do other than grunt — now often disguise themselves as "anti-Zionists".
Whatever is "most" important, that is very important still.
The left's anti-Zionism could easily merge with the old-style anti-semitic agitation.
Below a certain level of political awareness — that is, to the degree that the propaganda of a group like the SWP succeeds in reaching raw, politically uneducated people — it is not at all easy to distinguish one from the other.
The good intentions of the left - which is not racist, but "anti-imperialist" , albeit with the anti-imperialism of idiots — will count for very little here.
The sustained anti-Zionist polemics of the left and the demonisation of Israel - including, it should be said in the interests of truth, by Socialist Organiser for a long time -have created a widespread political culture that may well ease the way for the new fascist anti-semitic right — just as Stalinist "National Bolshevism" in 1930s Germany helped ease the way for the Nazis to win over left wing workers.
If Myra Woolfson's letter is the JSG's reply to my article about the JSG and the WRP, then it is a throwing in of the towel. Progress!
----- pull-quotes -----
WORKERS, LIBERTY