Times of deception and cowardice
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-12-05Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 13
Uranus granus is a very curious film.
French films that don't glorify the Resistance are pretty few and far between, so it's interesting just for that. But it's muddled and its message is ultimately rather cynical.
It's the story of a bombed-out French village in the south west after the Liberation. The Communists are on top, and they've turned the tables on former collaborators, rounding them up and executing them.
It's a bad time, not just for collaborators, but for anti-Communists in the Resistance and for do-nothing people who just sat tight until it was all over. The atmosphere of rumour and denunciation makes everybody nervous, and anxious to rewrite the past, as those Gerard Depardieu as Leopold on top can always use politics to set- selfishness and greed of the master tle personal scores. collaborator, Mogliat, an old man, That unlucky fate befalls half-extinguished, who yet clings to Leopold (played with inexhaustible life, gloating over his money and gusto by Gerard Depardieu), the glorying in the deaths of his former fairground strongman who enemies. runs the local cafe. Leopold, a boozer, and quick to anger, throws sions. It contrasts the collaboraout of his cafe the mealy-mouthed tionists with the Communists and Rochard, who is taunting another finds them both repellent. It poses of Leopold's customers for col- the choice as either getting laborating. Rochard, a railway of- something for yourself (as Mogliat ficial, is a pipsqueak who joined the did) or getting something for Stalin Communists to be on the winning and Russia. Neither offer much apside for a change; when Leopold peal, but the film's sympathies seem humiliates him, Rochard denounces to lie more with Mogliat (despite him to the authorities, claiming he his loathsomeness) than with the is hiding a notorious fascist sym- Communists, who are also pathiser, Maxime. pilloried.
What merely seems to be spite on Rochard's part turns into that; the Resistance was made up of something more, setting in train a all sorts of people. The Comset of events that will lead, despite munists were not the main part of his innocence, to Leopold's it. The fact that they used their time destruction. on top to settle old scores doesn't For Maxime is not with Leopold; change that, though it does explain he is hiding in the home of Archam- why the film is so hard on them. baud, an engineer, who takes pity With their arbitrary justice, their on the outcast, though he doesn't regime of terror, their network of share his views. Archambaud is spies and snitchers, they wreaked risking his neck, especially as he is misery on the towns they controllsharing his house with other ed. bombed-out families, one of which is headed by another keen Com- men, Archambaud and Watrin, the munist. schoolteacher, who between them The film is good on what must protect the hunted Maxime from have been a very fraught, witch- the Communists. Being weak and hunting time. It captures the petty cowardly themselves, and having no self-deceptions of those who twisted firm or fixed beliefs, they cannot first one way, then another, and it is bring themselves to judge Maxime. savage about the monstrous His support for the Nazis is excused For explained away as if in the name of some spurious humanity.
They shrink from handing him in, not because they are noble and forgiving, but because they are feeLess good are the film's conclu- Uranus is about the vacillations of petty bourgeois people like Archambaud who, when taced with moral choice, throw a cloak over their vacillation, as if to dress it up But the choice was wider than into something finer and grander. In the opening lines of the film, we are told that some French people collaborated while others fought back, but that the majority of French people did neither. This film seems to be saying that that was the wisest course, because moral choices are to confused and so hard to make. As Watrin says to Archambaud: It is easier to be a hypocrite.
But it isn't. Archambaud and Watrin wear spiritual hair shirts; they're always examining their consciences. The happiest character in the film is Leopold, no hypocrite, who stands up and denounces the guilty. Some issues are difficult to resolve, but that is no excuse for ducking them. There's no lasting comfort in cowardice.