Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

"Perhaps we are all workers. The question belongs to the 19th century."

Socialist Organiser no. 510, 5 December 1991 · scan pp. 11–13 · about 5,332 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 11

Socialist Experiment. It is not good enough to wash your hands of it, you must understand what went wrong.

Or O'Mahony talked about bourgeois democracy which, apparently, we all live in, as a system of lies. But I suggest that if you really want to know what it is like to live in a system of lies you do a bit of reading about the systems actually obtained in Eastern Europe. I am not talking about the Soviet Union, but about Eastern Europe.

These were capitalist economies which should have developed into socialism, and which the Communists were only giving a helping hand to, after all. Read Vaclav Havel's essays and come to see just what it means when truth is completely marginalised in everyday We can have this discussion. At least it helps us to clear the air of unnecessary lies laying too long in our opponent's conscience. In that part of the world, until 1989, such a discussion would have led to the arrest of all the people in this room..

I think that when history is examined it is much more complex than the simplified schemes that appeal to you because they seem to make sense of it. One of these schemes was given to us by Mr O'Mahony.

A Marxist scheme where history proceeds from feudalism through to capitalism, on to socialism by necessary and logical steps. In which, until the final stage, there is always a ruling class against which the rest are struggling. I think this is all myth.

If you look at our country and the rule of law which he says the workers struggled to institute, often against great resistance. The rule of law existed in this country, existed since the reign of Edward II, in one form or another. It was not introduced by workers' struggle. Nor was it anything to do with capitalism. It was part of feudal England.

Are any of you workers? What does mean to say that workers are going to rise up once again and take possession of thei birthright? This languag belongs to the 19th century, and was even wrong when applied then!"

England, even then, was not really feudal. It had a money economy and so on. If you look at the facts all these simplifications become unacceptable. Along with them comes the unacceptable idea of "the workers". Is Mr O'Mahony a worker? Am I a worker? Are any of you workers? What does it mean to say that workers are going to rise up once again and take possession of their birthright? This language belongs to the 19th century, and was even wrong when applied then.

You should revise your rhetoric to something more appropriate to the days in which you live.

Roger Scruton sums up and replies to the floor debate will address the points mad in the discussion one by on •Firstly: has socialism come to an end?

I don't believe socialism has come an end, because I believe that the moral and emotional roots of socialism will always be there.

Socialism will take a different form, and I entirely agree with the point made from the floor that the rhetoric of socialism in our day is outmoded. It must be amended, but once amended it will channel once again the emotion which Rousseau called "compassionating zeal". I think this is what we have heard from several people here today./ One of the pieces of rhetoric which should be amended is that of socialism versus capitalism.

One gentleman, on behalf of social democracy, said absolutely rightly that this is an anachronistic debate.

Nothing in the modern world is recognisably capitalist if you mean by capitalist that system that was described in Das Kapital. Certainly the opposition which exists is no longer socialism as then defined.

For a start, capitalism has never been a system of beliefs. It was mainly used to describe an economic system.

The Marxist assumption is that economic systems determine the whole social superstructure. I believe that assumption is wrong. I would never use the word capitalism to describe the conditions of any actually existing order. Let us just remember that this language comes from 19th century Several people have said: why have 1 not explained what is good about *the rotten corrupt system" . Someone said it has been cheeky of me to avoid what capitalism has done to the world and asked why I did not defend "my system"? Well, I was here to debate the future for socialism after Stalinism, not to defend what I believe. If asked to do so, I would have done so.

As I said in the course of my talk, do recognise the imperfections of numan institutions, and I will defend nothing as an idea. I will defend certain established historicall compromises as the best that we have got.

One gentleman has said that this just a cop-out, and that I am just taking Burke's line that because of human imperfections all we can de to sustain the given things. He said that this is not going to appeal to anyone. If this is what the Right believe, then the Right has no future.

Well, I would say that it is true tha the Right's future will always be precarious so long as it believes something as unexciting as the truth.

That is the problem for us. You on the left have this great advantage that you can propagate exciting myths which appeal directly to emotions and which we will never see, but nevertheless will always inspire a following. I am not in that happy position. I will only be able to rely on decency, com mon sense and scepticism.

I agree with you that perhaps on the those grounds the Right does not have much of a future. We have had a lucky run, but maybe we will have to go under. But I am a philosopher. I/ am only interested in the truth, not what the future may bring Someone said: why do I talk only about individuals whereas Mr O'Mahony was talking about social groups and classes? Do I not believe that there are classes? Are they not economically determined? Do they have contradictions? If so, how are they resolved? This is straight from the heart of Marxist theory.

I do not believe that classes are the most important form of association between people. I believe that there are other forms of association that come about in completely different ways such as this, a debating club, a corporation, a church, a school, a university. All these bring people together and establish their collective and social nature a lot more firmly than classes do.

I do not know what class I belong to. But I do know something about clubs and discussion groups and other things I belong to - not all of which some of the people in this room would approve of. And the same is true of most of you. Many people here have spoken loudly of their situation as workers, but I wonder how many here are really confident that you as oppos ed to me are the genuine item when it comes to being a worker or not?

Perhaps we are all workers. Perhaps none of us are. I sit in front of a VDU, just like the lady here, for quite a bit of the day too.

This question also belongs to the 19th century. It has a dusty air to it.

The most important question for us today is not the question of what we are as individuals, but what groups, clubs, social units, we would like to belong to. My only point is this:

whatever we belong to, we ought to bi free to belong to it, or not. We shoule not be blamed for belonging to things which it was never our choice to belong to in the first place.

Perhaps I am, objectively speaking, as the Marxists used to say, a member of the bourgeoisie. But that does not mean 1 am a fat spiv as one gentleman referred to that class. I know a lot of people who you could classify as owners of the means of pro duction who are neither fat nor spivs.

order. But it is a necessary protection the individual against the state. "

Put on one side all this mythmaking about class and talk about real social entities! I agree that if conservatism as a philosophy confines itself to advocating the rights of individuals, as Mrs Thatcher and her ideologues used to do, it dissolves into another kind of 19th century nonsense, a John Stuart Mill-type of individualism which also, today, has no credibility.

All of us are anxious for some type of social belonging. This goes as much for people on the Right as those on the Left. This is what we must try to define and identify. All this talk about classes is a myth and an illusion.

Now, the lady here accused me of believing that sympathy for the underdog was misguided, recommending me to read Hume. I do not think it is misguided. I think it is a natural human instinct.

Again, one person said this feeling made him into a socialist. It made me into a socialist too, for a short while, admittedly under some fairly severe tuition. If I had confessed something else, I would have been out on my ear.

Nevertheless, I also believe it is quite possible to be like me and think there has to be an underdog, because there has to be an overdog, and yet also feel sympathy for the underdog.

I am just sceptical about the socialist plans that have been propagated for rectifying the situation the underdog.

Someone said, quite rightly, that Marxist sympathy for the underdog was irrelevant to the argument. Marx was presenting an objective, scientific description of the material basis of society, its basis in human labour. From that description certain things folfowed. I agree that this is what he said he was doing. But I disagree that it was objective and scientific.

The proof of its wrongness comes from the disasters of the attempts to implement it. I know that this is a deep question, and that we were not assembled to discuss it, but all that I would say is that for me the division between material base and social superstructure is untenable, the labour theory of value is untenable. The idea that certain social forms succeed each other according to the laws of motion declared in Das Kapital is also untenable. I reject all these three crucial theses. So I do not accept that there is anything remaining of an objective theory to replace what I described as the instinctive feeling we have for the underdog, which will always remain.

Someone went on to say that democracy takes priority over socialism. She said it is what people want that matters. You rebutted my suggestion that socialists are in a quan dary as to whether they should have democracy or socialism. I think her very language went on to reveal exact ly why I am worried. "The majority of the working class will take power for themselves. That will show that socialism is achieved by democracy"

Firstly, you use a violent language of "taking power" , not the language of constitutional process, where people vote and display their wants. You talk about a particular class, the working.

class. What about the rest? They have no say.

What if it turns out that the majority are middle class, as in my view they may well be? Do you say they have no rights?

You go on to defend Leninism, saying the invention of the Cheka was a tactical, short-term measure designed to protect the workers' revolution against people like me. I was specifically cited as the type of person who does need to be dealt with quite severely in these transitional periods.

I fully agree. If you go in that direc tion you will have to deal severely witt people like me. But I think there are a lot more people like me than you think. I think you may find that there are 20 million of them. You have to make the moral choice: what to do with them? This is a choice that Lenin made, and we are living with the consequences.

Someone said I should look at Eastern Europe — the gentleman from Pakistan, or somewhere like that; oh, I am not allowed to say things like that - before the Communist takeover. Well, I agree. But we should look at what was possible in Eastern Europe. Eastern Europe is very important. They have been through what we have not been through.

They suffered Nazism and Communism in rapid succession. It is a big question why that happened, and what went wrong with the settlement after the First World War. Maybe that settlement was in itself wrong. But everyone knows that at least the Austrian part of the Austro-Hungarian empire had introduced some kind of democracy, at least universal adult male suffrage, in 1903. That was working quite well.

Something went wrong. What went wrong is something, fortunately, we have escaped in this country. So we de not know all the forces that went first of all to make Nazism and then Communism in that part of the world.

We must concentrate on the actual history of these events and try to see whether they are relevant to us at all. Maybe they went through this tragic succession of events because of the peculiar circumstances they were in after the First World War. Maybe we don't have to think about this in the same way. Maybe we don't have to worry about whether Marxism contains anything relevant to our condition at all.

Why did I say so many positive things about private property? Someone mentioned Chile under Pinochet. Surely, private property doe not guarantee democracy, it was said.

It is not sufficient for introducing an ideal order. But it is a necessary protection for the individual against the state. It is one thing which defines for the individual some sphere of sovereignty of his own, something he can give away if he wants, something he can exchange.

Marx himself said that the condition of the proletariat was miserable because the proletarian has nothing to exchange but his own labour power. Surely you would want the proletarians to have something more than that to exchange if you want to liberate them. That "more" must their own property.

Marxism: based mpathy for the underdog?

Scan page 12

O'Mahony he last speech by Mr 1 Scruton was hypocritical.

Stalinism in the Soviet Union really was socialist and massacres.

In actuality, the massacres have largely been massacres of our people. The history of capitalism has been a history of massacres of our people. In Paris in 1871, something in the region of 10,000 of our people were murderes in cold blood after they had been captured. There are many, many other ex amples.

It is not a matter of whether we are willing, if we had the chance, to murder 20 million Roger Scrutons. It is matter of a struggle which goes on.

No Marxist socialist would seriously argue you can get socialism without the majority of the population wanting it. The whole idea that socialism can be imposed by a minority is absurd! The attempt would lead to all sorts of convulsions.

The argument is whether or not, if socialists have a majority, the ruling class will submit to that majority. The evidence of history is that if we came anywhere near to a majority the ruling class would disrupt bourgeois democratic procedures.

Take Chile in 1970-73, for example. A left-wing government - not particularly left-wing, in fact — but a left government was elected; and then it was smashed by a military regime backed by the CIA. This military regime had many of the features of The issue is not properly posed in terms of the massacre of the ruling class or of Roger Scrutons. It is posed in terms of the fact of history: they massacred us.

What do I mean by "democracy"?! mean real, collective self-rule of the essential features of the lives of the people making the decisions. In reality you do not have this under capitalism. For example, much of what happens in Britain is determined by a stable civil service. Most of what happens in the lives of ordinary people is determined by capitalist monopolies who are not subject to any sort of democracy at all. They are like the petty kings of the Dark Ages, the big capitalists now, ruling their economic kingdoms as autocrats!

I would not say that democracy for shareholders is any type of democracy where a company employs a vast number of people who have absolutely no say in what happens. So democracy is not real, except within certain narrow, formal, political limits. It is not what it promises to be.

In America, for example, less than half the people vote. A vast number of things are decided by the Supreme Court. In reality, democracy in America or in Britain is very, very shallow. We want to deepen democracy. We want to give political, social, and economic substance to the bourgeois shadow of democracy.

I do not know about whether human nature is evil or not. If you look at what the Nazis did, when normal family men - some of whom were vegetarians for humanitarian reasons — went home to their kids after organising the gassings, then you can argue that human nature is capable of awful, awful things when the internal and social inhibitions break down.

The whole notion that Lean totalitarian planning is not true What socialists want to do is to create a set of social institutions and conditions where human beings who begin as animals with all the possibilities of animals, and who are capable of relapsing into bestiality — can rise, and rise on a stable basis and continue to rise above that level.

It is irrelevant how you define basic human nature. It seems to me you can define it very negatively, but that is an argument for better social institutions. After all, the good family men who murdered people in the Nazi concentration camps only did these things in conditions where German capitalism licensed a legion of savages to take control. These savages took control to such an extent that when the German bourgeoisie wanted to stop what they were doing in the early '40s they could not stop them. They brought Germany down to complete disaster.

We want to change the sort of conditions where the bestiality which sometimes emerges in people can emerge in that way or to that extent.

Now, should we drop being called socialist? Well, in a way, yes. But that is the desire to escape from a whole series of associations which really are very difficult to escape from. What do we call ourselves? The best thing I can think of is "democratic collectivists". But then people would not know what we were talking about, or where we came from politically.

We have to fight our way out of the situation we are in. So l agree, socialist is a lousy word, so is communism; but therefore let us try to define the ideas we are talking about.

Social Democracy, has it vanquished Leninism? Well, it depends on how you evaluate what Social Democracy has achieved. Nowhere has Social Democracy achieved anything better than a welfare state. It may have alleviated, over time, the conditions rampant red-in-tooth-and-claw capitalism. That is good. It did not achieve the socialist goals of eliminating capitalism and going on to something higher. Therefore it is not vindicated.

Classes don't exist? Again, you can take every given thing, break it down to all its particulars and its components, and deny that any whole greater than those components exists. Does society exist? Thatcher says, no only individuals exist. You know the old argument: is a river the same river as it was five minutes ago? It is not, it is flowing. Yet we work normally on the assumption that the river exists.

If you de-structure everything around you, it becomes impossible to make sense of anything. When you do this ideologically, as Roger Scruton is doing, you do it to avoid facing the fact that there are classes.

Fundamentally, there are groups of people, whatever the differences between them as individuals - and there are many — with a similar relationship to the means of production. For example, there are a vast number of people in this country who can only live by selling their labour power.

According to Roger Scruton, private property is a good thing. Well, on a certain level that is true. But if workers have houses as well as labour power, they can not live on the sale of their houses. They have to continue to sell their labour power.

Classes do exist. Some people live by selling their labour power; other people own the means of production. Again, there are divisions within this categorisation, but the categorisation tries to make sense of society. Breaking things down to atoms is simply an. ideological evasion of thinking about the composite reality.

What about Roger Scruton's own identity, his "upwards" migration from class to class? It's become relatively easier to do this in Britain in the last 40 years. Other countries have a far less structured class system — Australia and America, for instance. Individuals can change place. But at any given time there is a vast and stable number of people who have to sell their labour power and who can not and will not escape from that condition. There is an inherent limitto the mber of individuals who can Rate as Roger Scruton says he has. ple can change their classes, but loes not tell you anything. In anRome people could go from to being very rich. One even on to become emperor. But it did alter the system of slavery. Most eves remained slaves.

Lenin did found the Cheka. I agree with the comrade who argued that the The struggle does continue Russian revolution was right to defend tself by whatever means it found lecessary.

In a calm, friendly discussion you could discuss whether the setting up of i lawless Cheka, which on a day to lay basis was out of political control, vas the right thing to do. You could isk whether or not, in retrospect, it eally was the right thing to do, and whether it was not a serious mistake.

But before I would discuss that in an argument with Roger Scruton, I would insist on discussing the reality in which the Cheka was created. The Bolsheviks did not begin by starting. the terror; the Bolsheviks began by abolishing the death penalty. Then the Bolsheviks were faced by the revolt of the old ruling class. They were faced with the invasion of no less than 14 states, including Britain. One of the consequences of this was that a society which was backward to start with was driven much further back.

A large part of the working class was destroyed. They were physically destroyed and driven back into the countryside. You can not talk about the Cheka or condemn what Lenin and company did to defend themselves without taking all this into account.

This is an example of what I started out with: the ruling class resists. Lenin did not decree that there would be civil war. The first thing the Bolsheviks did when they took power - on 8 November 1917 — was to produce an appeal for peace. It was a sane, sensible, reasonable document in a world gone mad, where millions of people were being slaughtered in a mad capitalist war.

The Bolsheviks did not begin as peo ple who recklessly killed Roger Scruton's adopted class in Russia, thes began as people who wanted a peaceful revolution. They were stopped, not by their own ill-will or their own evil natures, but by the nature of the resistance to them, and by the nature of serious political struggle in class society.

Are elites necessary? Much of what Roger Scruton said here about elites and private property is largely sophism. What are we talking about in terms of elites? Well, of course, there are and always will be differences among human beings. You will almost certainly get elites in particular fields. You will get people who are an elite in terms of knowledge, for example. I am prepared to accept that this is so and that it should be so, and I am prepared to pay due respect to someone who has a great deal of knowledge. There are all sorts of ways people can be elites. No-one with any sense is going to tell you that you can equalise people on that level.

What we want to do in terms of equality is to get rid of a system whereby there is inbuilt inequality, grotesque inequality, rooted not in the special human qualities some people may have but in their ownership of the means of life, and where others have to work to live, submitting to the exploitation of the owners.

I don't have any objection to people owning houses. If Mrs Thatcher's selling of council houses had not meant the destruction of the social housing stock there would not have been a particular problem from a socialist point of view. Under a socialist system perhaps they would not want to own houses, but if people did then that would have little bearing on the socialist project.

But we are not arguing with you on this level about property. We are arguing against the right to own, and exploit, other people's labour power. That is what is wrong here. Yes, and the prohibition of such property rights - in the means of production and in the buying and exploiting of labour power — is the limit we would put on "freedom" in order to achieve equality — equality as I have defined it, not as Roger Scruton has defined it. The rule of law is a good thing, other things being equal. But the rule of law is frequently developed through disruptions of the rule of law. The question is: whose law?"

There are constraints on robbery. I think a society could exist in a condition of liberty which placed all sorts of basic legal, constitutional restraints on the right to exploit other people and the right to own the means of production. I mean large-scale production, / am not talking here about artisan workshops or the corner shop.

No Marxist advocated the sort of wholesale, pauperising collectivisation that Stalin carried out. Trotsky criticis ed him. This was no Marxist programme. It actually corresponded to the drive of the Stalinist bureaucracy to become the sole master of the surplus product. This was the way Trotsky described it.

No Marxist is in favour of barrackroom equality. On the contrary, the whole point we make about bourgeois society is that bourgeois society, haying created the possibility of a high degree of individualisation of people, Socialist Organiser No. 510 page 12 actually limits the realisation of that possibility to a very small number. Wi are the individualists here, in the proper sense of the word. If you like, we want mass individualism!

We want te create a whole, stable social system in which there will be a vast increase in individualism in the sense 1 have defined it. The whole argument here, in terms of what Marxists say, is skewed by Stalinism and utterly confused.

Marxists never advocated the sort of things the Maoists or the Khmer Rouge did. That is not and never has been our programme. It was not the programme of Marx, nor the programme of Lenin either. If someone who has read Marx and Lenin pretends to believe that Marxism and barrack-room Maoism are the same thing, I take that as proof that they can not deal with the arguments of the real Marxists. They hide behind Stalinism from real Marxism.

So we are against private ownership of the means of production and against the right to exploit people. Beyond that there are all sorts of possibilities for the ownership of property. We are not against people owning property - the whole idea is absurd.

Lenin at various times tried to organise planning, for instance, during the civil war under War Communism. Lenin in 1921 created a system whereby they allowed a limited but quite extensive revival of capitalism and the bourgeoisie under the control of the state. The whole notion that Lenin created what has become known as totalitarian planning is not true to history. All of that was carried through by Stalin after 1928, when he broke with the reviving bourgeoisie and the bureaucracy became the sole master of the surplus product.

It was then that you got the whole absurd notion of totalitarian planning. It would have been pretty absurd in a highly advanced country with a developed civilisation. It was utterly harmful in the USSR, and was said to be so at the time by Marxist critics of Stalinism, many of whom were in Stalin's jails and camps.

What about the rule of law? I did not claim, did not mean to claim, that. the workers created the rule of law. If you look at the evolution of the rule of law in England you can't just place it back in the Middle Ages and present it as a continuous, flowing, evolutionary development - and then forget about the 17th century bourgeois revolution! You cannot talk about the stable evolution of the rule of law without revolutionary disruption. It would not be true.

What I claimed was that the workers, by their struggles, expanded the possibilities of democracy. They forced acceptance of this on the ruling The rule of law is a good thing, other things being equal. But the rule of law is frequenily developed through disruptions of the rule of law. The question is: whose law? Right now the law of this country is very different from the law at the time of Cromwell, not to speak of the time which Roger Scruton mentioned.

We are in favour of the rule of law. But the rule of better law - law which, for example, outlaws exploitafion - must be established. We are in favour of breaking the law of the bourgeoisie, if necessary to achieve that. For example, Yeltsin and the Russian parliament went against the legalities of the system when they opposed the coup. Yeltsin broke the rule of law when, for instance, he banned the Communist Party. Was it right to do that? Of course, it was right. But Yeltsin did.not act as someone who represented the naturally evolving, growing, expanding parliament-based rule of law. He was someone who acted as a revolutionary. And he was right to act as a revolutionary.

Finally, I repeat: between Roger Scruton and Stalinism there is a great common bond, a common acceptance of elites. He wants a civilised elite, but he wants an elite. We do not want elites: we want self-ruling democracy. And you cannot get self-ruling democracy unless you have some form of collective ownership of the basic means of production, otherwise you get gross inequality under formal equality.

Roger Scruton, in terms of where he stands in history, has more in common with Stalinism - I make all the necessary qualifications here than we socialists have. Much more!

Scan page 13

HE CULTURAL FRON

----- pull-quotes -----

"Is Mr O'Mahony a worker? Am I a worker?

"...[Private propertyl... is not sufficient for introducing the ideal

working class, then you can reasonably go on about the

UNION HE FOUGHT TO THE LAST.. • RUGGLE CONTINUES

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 510

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →