Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

"Whatewer else think abomt the revoltions or 1989 the demand for private property was at the heart or them

Socialist Organiser no. 510, 5 December 1991 · scan pp. 10–11 · about 1,762 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

From page 9 socialism because it was taken over (in his language) by a counterrevolution of Stalinist bureaucrats.

Now, I am not a historian, but I think if you were really interested in what went on in 1917 - most of you have socialist leanings, you ought to be — you should read the book by Heller and Neffs, Utopia in Power. It will prove to you, if you have an open mind, that the things that are normally blamed on Stalin had been consciously initiated by Lenin.

In particular, the founding of the Cheka, which was to have allencompassing power over the social processes. That is the sort of think which was the most sinister development of the Russian Revolution. But it happened before Stalin and it happened in Lenin's thinking as part of the process of seizing power from the remnants of the bourgeoisie - from people like me, I suppose.

Now, people on the left ought to feel some conscience about this. As I have said, the left-wing attitude is natural, and will always remain, but it is also necessary to feel some conscience about what has been done in the name of it.

If people like myself start saying of any particular conservative or reactionary regime which you disapprove of — perhaps it's not real conservatism, you would all be, rightly, disapproving. You would say, come on, take some responsibility for things done in the name of your philosophy; show how you would separate yourself from it. You must give concrete historical detail and show you are aware of the evils and the dangers.

If anything should be learned from Stalinism, as Mr O'Mahony called it - what I refer to as Leninism - it is that, whatever the future of socialism, whatever it is that you socialists think you should be doing, you must look at the past and take some responsibility for it. At least for having sympathised with it, for feeling it is going along the right lines. See how things went wrong and how you, seriously, would avoid the errors.

believe that many on the left, in Britain at least, have gone through this examination of conscience. I feel people, on the whole, agree about certain conclusions about the Great Socialist Experiment, as it was called.

First, and I think Mr O'Mahony would probably agree with this, most people are sceptical about centralised planning. But their scepticism, - believe, does not go tar enough. In particular, we should ask ourselves the question as to why centralised planning was thought of in the first place. It was instituted by Lenin as an instrument for equalising people, for destroying that old class structure and giving opportunities at the lower end of society.

Is centralised planning in itself wrong, or is it only wrong when it is not used for the purpose of eg ing people? If you car equalise, how far can yo go? What liberties would yourself to trample on in order to achieve human equality? This is the real question. I think all socialists - or rather all those with the leftwing attitude I have described -should ask themselves.

Most on the left have come to see that state control in itself is not a good thing. As Mr O'Mahony said, what socialists, and in particular Marxists, have always argued for it not for control of the economy by the state but rather something else - collective ownership, what the 19th century Marxists used to call social ownership, ownership by the people, not by the state. "To the people who constantly manifest their desires for something which has the form of a capitalis economy, do you tell them that they are wrong and that their votes should be cancelled, or do you go along with it and accept the result?"

The problem, I think, is that the onus falls on you to define just what you mean by that. Is, for example, a modern capitalist form, in which the workers can all acquire shares, social ownership or not? I see, from vibrations on my left, no.

This is the kind of question you need to discuss. Just how do you bring it about? At a certain period people thought that Yugoslavia was an ideal of social ownership, one that combined social ownership with a market economy. No-one would want to wish the destiny of Yugoslavia on the rest of the world. But, alas, the economic and social facts of Yugoslavia do not give a good record to that type of socialism either.

Let me say one thing further. I do not, again, want to give a definite view because it is for you, in your hearts, to decide. Mr O'Mahony said that for him the idea of socialism was collective ownership, not state ownership, but ownership by the people or workers, based on political democracy. This raises for me the major question which all socialists have to confront in the post-Leninist world.

Suppose it came to a choice between socialism, or collective ownership, and democracy - which way are you going to go?

To the people who constantly manifest their desires for something which has the form of a capitalist economy, do you tell them that they are wrong and that their votes will be cancelled, or do you go along with it and accept the result? I think this is a paradox?

All socialists I have known, not only my own father, believe that their doctrine, if understood, would have the spontaneous consent of all the people. But suppose it had the spontaneous dissent of all people, what then? Which way do you go?

Nevertheless, as 1 say, the leftng, state of mind will remain Jimes fra a force in which a force we The right to private property would be welcomed by cannot deliver!

should try to understand. My own view is that it is a type of residue of religious feelings surviving into a secular age. But these are feelings which all of us share to some extent. The socialist way of conscripting them will always be with us.

But what are the lessons which must be learned from the collapse of Leninism? The first, and the most important, think is this.

What Lenin did in Russia was to destroy all the Russian institutions which made it possible to recognise their mistakes and to correct them.

He destroyed parliaments, he destroyed law, he destroyed open discussion and opposition. This process was initiated by Lenin and brought to fruition by Stalin. But it is only through these sort of things that people can come to see that they have made a mistake and take measures to correct it.

In my view the greatest mistake that humanity can make is to destroy the means to rectify mistakes. That is the mistake which was made. Therefore we must remember that we need institutions which enable us, collectively, to come to see where we have gone wrong. That means we need parliaments, above all, legal opposition and free opinions.

Another point, and Mr O'Mahony agreed, the rule of law really matters. Lenin in November 1918 issued a decree on courts which abolished the entire legal system of the Soviet Union. All the consequences which we see flowing from that are too horrendous to relate. We know that, whatever else we do, we must maintain the rule of aw - a continuous structure of egal authority and impartial courts, insofar as we can achieve them. All human institutions are imperfect, and there will always be mistakes, nevertheless, just to abolish law is one of the primary errors of revolutionary socialism in the Leninist mould.

Another lesson we should learn, although I think Mr O'Mahony would disagree with this, is that private property is a primary right of the individual. I do not know the Soviet Union very well, but I do know Eastern Europe. I know from the experience of my friends there that the one thing that would have helped them more than anything else was the right to be able to shut their door in someone's face, particularly the face of the secret police. The right to have that piece of territory of your own. Without private property it seems to me there is no such right.

"Another lesson which you should draw the collapse of Leninism... [is] human institutions are more easy to destroy than create. In destroying them you do not always know what you are losing. It was very easy for Lenin to destroy the rule of law in Russia...

Private property is the thing that gives someone control over his own life. Whatever else we think about the revolutions of 1989 the demand for private property was at the heart of them. And anyone who knows Poland and Czechoslovakia will recognise this. You might think people were wrong to demand that right, that there is some ideal socialist world where it would not be necessary, but in the actually existing situation private property Is one of the best institutions which has ever evolved, to protect us from the bullying of others.

Another lesson which you should draw from the collapse of Leninism is slightly more philosophical. It is: human institutions are more easy to destroy than to create. In destroying them you do not always know what you are losing. It was very easy for Lenin to destroy the rule of law in Russia, to detroy the principles of a free economy, to destroy all the old academic institutions, the Orthodox church and so on.

All these things crumbled immediately. You only had to breathe on them. But what came in their place? In my view, nothing, organised nihilism. A moral, political and spiritual vacuum in which only power could reside. I believe we should learn that lesson. We should remember that even if we want to reform things - and reform is very different from destruction. Until we understand the function of an institution - be it parliament, a school, a university, or whatever - we should not arrogate to ourselves the right to cast it down. We should try to find what it does and try to reform it in the direction we want.

Finally, the last lesson from the collapse of Leninism is that they ought to inform themselves a little bit better about the history of our century and what has actually happened. Many, many millions of people have paid with their lives, freedom and happiness to the Great

Scan page 11

Socialist Organiser No. 510 page

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 510

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →