Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

"Stalinist statification was the very opposite of socialism

Socialist Organiser no. 510, 5 December 1991 · scan pp. 8–10 · about 3,073 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

page Russia than in, Britain? they were not.

I repudiate the idea that statification is socialism. Stalinist statifica tion was the very opposite of socialism. All the conquests of the last few hundred years of human history - human rights, the slow spreading downwards of civilisation — were wiped away. They were not disposed of by socialism but by the Stalinist bureaucrats, behaving as ruling classes always do in material conditions as backward and primitive as they were in the USSR.

Therefore, the collapse of Stalinism does not mean the collapse of socialism. On the contrary.

For decades, the notion of socialism, which I have broadly defined, has been encrusted by a series of ideas which are alien to socialism. There are no shortage of quotes. James Connolly, for exampie, commenting on middle-class socialists like the Fabians, put it sharply: if state property is socialist property then the jails and enterprises like the Post Office are all socialist institutions; and the jailers, the hangmen and the police are all socialist officials.

Socialism has been encrusted with all sorts of statist ideas alien to socialism.

Not all these ideas have come from Stalinism. During the last hundred years a collectivist wing of bourgeois liberalism — in this country in the past represented by the Fabians and the Labour Party -has grown up. These people also want statification. For example, Bismarck's state was the first attempt at a modern welfare state. He was not a socialist.

I want to take a different tack. We can all - Tories included! -agree that Stalinism is a bad thing. We will disagree when it comes to defining why Stalinism was a bad thing, what exactly was wrong with Socialists believe that there should be collective ownership of the means of production - I mean the basic means of production, rather than every single property -on the basis of a political democracy. Only on the basis of collective ownership of the means of production can there be a real, self-determining, self-controlling democracy• From this point of view, what was wrong with Stalinism? GOVERNMENI The police ve y often :

formal equa ity before Stalinism could be seen as a grotesque caricature of every society which ever existed. A state with unbridled power beat down the people. The state had such power that it could turn over the lives of tens of millions of peasants, wipe out millions of them, turn natural calamity to its advantage, and artificially intensify famine in the Ukraine to break the peasants.

That state dominated the population in the interests of an elite. The elite, unlike the British elite, did not have private ownership of the means of production. The state had ownership of the means of production - but the Stalinists owned the You had exactly what you have in this country, in a different form! Stalinism had too many points in common - taken to a ridiculous caricature - with countries like Britain for people of Roger Scruton's persuasion to have a right to say: "That was the socialist future, and it did not work" , It was the past of human history, in class society, encapsulated and intensified!

In Britain there is a ruling class which controls the lives of the people, not in a totalitarian fashion, not by direct force, but nevertheless for goals similar to those of Stalinism, and with immense powers of repression in reserve. Stalinism, in this respect, is a grotesque caricature of what exists in Britain.

In the Stalinist states, for example, education was formally accessible to the entire population, but in fact was semi-monopolised by the bureaucracy and their children. Exactly the situation that exists in Britain. Only the mechanisms of control differ.

Now Mr Scruton would think this is a good idea, or something you have to live with because there Is nothing better.

Socialists want neither Stalinism nor the system that Mr Scruton champions! We believe that we live in a world where objectively it is possible that elites can be dispensed with whether they are Stalinist elites or British Tories and the class they represent.

We believe we live in a world where it is now possible to realise democracy. Although capitalism has been progressive, and did create possibilities for human beings thai have not existed before, capitalisn has raised possibilities that it cannot realise. Democracy is perhaps the clearest example. Dan be iberated imes they emocracy is necessary because cannot be liberated unless they can rule themselves democratically.

If you are an elitist you believe democracy is not necessary. Desirable or useful, perhaps; necessary, no. But democracy necessary if you believe in the rights of the vast majority of the people, that is, if you are a socialist.

The various political formations which developed capitalism - in Holland, Britain, France and America — put forward the idea of democracy. But at the very best this has only been realised in part, realised fully only for a section of the population.

"Capitalism has the possibility to create a real abundance on the basis of real self-rule. But what do we get? We get the rule of savages! An elite rules on the back of the mass of the people and exploits the people".

For example, in this country democracy is only a rough approximation to what democracy should be. It is not real, self-controlling political democracy. It is obviously better than that which exists under Stalinism. But there is not real self-rule in Britain.

In capitalism there is only formal democracy and formal equality: formal equality before the law where some people are a lot more equal than others because they have property, and therefore, in fact, massively greater rights.

Without qualification, it is a good thing there are formal rules. The rule of law means that, most of the time, there are certain rules and certain rights. This is good and worth defending. Democratic socialists will defend these conquests and achievements of bourgeois society (which were often achieved through mass action). We will defend these democratic gains against people like Mr Scruton! Nevertheless, those who are serious about liberty and democracy must realise that capitalism has failed to deliver what is possible.

Right now you have a situation in Britain, after ten years of Thatcher, where a vast number of people sleep in doorways in central London.

Capitalism has the possibility to create a real abundance on the basis of real self-rule. But what do we get? We get the rule of savages! This is a savage system. An elite rules on the back of the mass of the people and exploits the people. The bourgeois intellectuals act as sheepherders of the people, detending the official ideological les which lubricate the rule of the moneyed in the interests of the moneyed.

I do not know if Roger Scruton would say this, but certain critics of democracy from the right say that there are certain in-built features in bourgeois democracy which inevitably make it a system of lying. I think they are right. This system needs to lie. "Democracy" is its official ideology, in some ways now its religion; but democracy - real self-rule - is not its day-to-day reality.

It is to a serious extent based on falsification. It has to be. It can only survive on the sort of trickery we have seen lately where the Tory government has, in the last few days, exempted students from the council tax because students form a sizeable part of a number of key marginal seats. This is blatant bribery!

Our political world is comprehensively corrupt. It must depend on lies because it cannot deliver the democracy it promises, or be what it says it is.

Within British democracy we have the actual rule of the minority through their control of the means of production.

Socialism says: this is wrong. Socialists have said that for 2000 years. Marxist socialists say it is now unnecessary. We do not need it. The people who do need it are the ruling class and their intellectuals, who defend their system and accept its unavoidable spiritual and cultural corruption.

This is what it comes down to. One of the most awful things about modern Britain is the cultural exploitation and degradation inflicted on the people, by some of the tabloid papers, for example.

Stalinism's fall changes none of this! And the collapse of Stalinism allows real socialists, at least in the medium term, to be more likely to receive a hearing.

For a long time it was a legitimate response to ask many socialists: what do you think of Russia? Do you want to create a Russia? That is no longer a question which, after this current burst of bourgeois triumphalism dies down, will dominate political life. socialism dead?" is no, because the short answer to "Is capitalism is not dead. Socialism is reaction to the realities of capitalism that I have talked about. It is a reaction rooted in the class struggle of the workers; and that struggle will go on as long as capitalism goes on.

One of the reasons why we now ask "Is socialism dead?" is because for ten years the workers have been defeated in' the British class struggle.

•The labour movement will revive! It may reviveinitially by way of the When it revives, the renovated socialism, a socialism which has purged itself from the statist encrustations taken from bourgeois liberalism and Stalinist totalitarianism".

We have been defeated before There have been downturns before The labour movement will revive! I may revive initially by way of the election of a Labour governmen: and what happens afterwards When it revives, the possibility wil exist for the spread of a renovated socialism, a socialism which har purged itself of the statist encrusta tions taken from bourgeoi liberalism and Stalinis! totalitarianism.

Socialism will revive. Despite the pressure socialists feel now, and the fashionable talk about thr "bankruptcy of socialism" , wha we are seeing is the beginning of the rebirth of socialism. Roger Scrutos knows that, I think, and he fears it

Scan page 9

res are the peaceful by-products of beam society. Roger Scruton replies Or O'Mahony was eloquent and forceful, covering a great deal of ground. 1 can not reply to everything he said, but when he spoke of "the cry of triumph" from the bourgeoisie which we have been hearing for the last ten years, I thought of my own childhood.

I asked myself, not for the first time, whether I am a member of that class or not. When he spoke about the ruling class, in my father's accent and with all the venom it was said to me when I was a child by my tather, 1 once again ask: do I really belong to that class! The answer, of course, is that I do not know.

I thought then that I heard a voice from my own past, from my father, lecturing me, as he always did, on the injustices of the English class system. How he himself had been a victim and how I was destined to be a victim too - not having the money and the opportunities which only the upper class could enI have always borne in my heart the little thought that I am a member of the proletariat after all, despite all the accidents of circumstance which have followed. It is with that authority which I speak to you.

I do not accept the title of this debate, in the sense that I do not accept the phrase "collapse of Stalinism". What I think has collapsed in Eastern Europe at least, and in the Soviet Union too, is Leninism. I agree with Ken Minogue, insofar as I understand what Ken Minogue said to Mr O'Mahony in a previous debate, that the roots of the evil we have seen are not in the personality of Stalin, but they go deeper into a project which Lenin himself introduced into Russia in 1917.

But / do believe that there is something which does have a future... That is the le1 wing attitude... it is part of human natur will always exist."

This project has been introduced into many other parts of the world, by others unconnected with Lenin, and almost always with the same results. I am thinking of Ho Chi Minh, Mao Zedong, Pol Pot and a whole series of other people whose names perhaps one should not mention quite in the same breath as Lenin, but nevertheless had the same project in mind.

I am not sure whether socialism has a future. But I do believe that there is something else which does have a future which I want to define before beginning. This is: the leftwing attitude. I do not want to disparage it because I think it is a part of human nature, it will always exist. I was brought up in a family in which it was dominant.

would like to say psychologically what I think this attitude is, and why I think it will persist. I believe it is founded in sympathy for the underdog. Everyone recognises that there are people who lose out. The sight of them losing out is always heartrending and in decent people it gives rise to the question: what shall I do about it? Capitalism brings war. It is the rule of savages!

The easiest thing to think in the light of this experience, of seeing people lose out, is that the underdog is a victim of the "overdog"; that wherever there is an underdog there is also an overdog that is doing him down. The ubermensch, or uberhund, rather.

This overdog is a person who gets the good pay-off, the successful member of society, perhaps someone like myself, who, having started out in life as an underdog, has now enough money to drink a bottle of wine with my dinner.

So, if one can believe that the fate of the underdog is somehow caused by the overdog, one has a political programme unfolding before one. Namely, to get rid of the distinction between underdog and overdog. Somehow, by whatever means, introduce a condition of equality, so there is no underdog any more, because there is no overdog ruling over him. Equality, then, becomes the primary goal.

"Of course, one simple way of making everyone equal is to deprive everyone of everything. It is no exaggeration to say that this was the method adopted in the Soviet Union under Stalin".

Now, of course, one simple way of making everyone equal is to deprive everyone of everything. It is no exaggeration to say that this was the method adopted in the Soviet Union under Stalin. Almost everybody, as Mr O'Mahony rightly said, not the elite who were doing the depriving. But even they were unsafe. From day to day they risked falling into just the same trap that they had built for the rest of mankind. Even Stalin himself never felt wholly secure - and rightly.

So, we all recognise that there are ways of aiming at equality that threaten us all. I would simply say, without arguing for it, because this is a debate about other things, that I believe that the goal of equality is unachievable and that it would not be worth achieving if you could achieve it.

I actually think, and Mr O'Mahony rightly accuses me of this, that elites are necessary. They are also, in my view, the peaceful by-products of human society. They are not necessarily the evil and repulsive things that he believes they are.

want to talk about the future of socialism, in particular this "left wing attitude" that I have identified.

It is obvious that the idea that the misery of the underdog is caused by the triumph of the overdog has a peculiar tenacity — not just intellectually. It has survived ever since the French Revolution, and of course had its origins long before that in medieval thinking. It is not just an intellectual tenacity, it is a moral tenacity.

People believe that if you deny such rights you are condoning the situation of those who lose out. You are part of the machinery of oppression which has caused them to be sleeping in that tin shed in Lincoln's Inn Fields.

As a result, as all of you know, it does become very difficult to be open and honest about this very natter. If you are open and honest und say human equality is not achievable and not desirable, you can be the target of abuse. It is thought morally wrong even to think this. However, in my view, this is self-evidently true, as long as you clear your mind of the emotional need to think the opposite.

This emotional need will survive because of human sympathy with the situation of those who lose out. I believe one should have that sympathy. But one should not take it to the extent of destroying the possibility of elites emerging. Because, in my view, it is only by the emergence of elites that the situation of everyone gets better.

But elites have to emerge in the right way. Not by imposing themselves on others, but by the process once called by Adam Smith "the invisible hand".

Marxism, to which Mr O'Mahony gave a very neat and elegant introduction, appeals not just because it conscripts this feeling of sympathy for the underdog, but for reasons he stated: it seems to give a scientific account of how that condition arose and how it will be bettered. It will be bettered by the natural processes of history, passing through capitalism to a socialist future. As he rightly said, that socialist future turned out after 1917 to have been betrayed. Well, he would say betrayed, I would say that was what it actually really was. At least it was not what was expected.

Ever since 1917 people on the left have been exercised by what happened in Russia. Thev have wanted to explain it in a way which would enable them to maintain their own system of beliefs. The usual way out is the way out taken by Mr O'Mahony, namely, that this was not real socialism. It was not real Continued on pages

Scan page 10

Organiser

----- pull-quotes -----

election of a Labour government and what happens afterwards.

possibility will exist fo the spread of a

"I am not sure whethe socialism has a future.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 510

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →