Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Has socialism a future?

Socialist Organiser no. 510, 5 December 1991 · scan p. 7 · about 900 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

John O'Mahony from AWL debated Roger Scruton (Philosophy Department, Birkbeck College, and edito of Salisbury Review) in London last month. John O'Mahony spoke first.

Then, recently, I debated • Protessor Kenneth Minogue, one important point he made against me was this: if you pin down a socialist about a particular regime in a particular country you invariably get the reply: this was not real socialism.

Minogue made the point that it is very hard to know what we are arguing about. Ours is an idea which is never realised and therefore can never be criticised.

On a certain level that is a reasonable point to make. So I will try to define what I mean by socialism.

Obviously, socialism is one of those words with a vast number of different meanings. Hitler was a socialist in his own designation, so was Clement Attlee. So was Ben Gurion. So was Nasser.

What follows is that they cannot all be socialists. The people 1 mentioned are to a high degree mutually exclusive. You might try to find some socialist "essence" shared by them all - statism or whatever -but it strikes me that the word is so vague that it is best to start out by defining it.

Socialism I understand to be the ideas that Marx and Engels developed. This is one of the ways of defining what real socialism Is. According to Marx, socialism will grow out of capitalism, as capitalism grew out of the womb of feudalism. Socialism is being created inside capitalism by the spontaneous socialisation of the means of production under capitalism, ultimately leading to a rationalisation on a political level: the social property, now capitalistowned, would become collectively owned social property.

According to Marx, this socialism would differ from all previous socialisms, because it was not just based on a wish for a perfect, ideal world. It was based on the natural development of our existing world.

Socialism was the necessary outgrowth of advanced, developed capitalism.

Throughout history

was keen to admit this — ruling

classes have emerged for particular reasons. Ruling classes have played progressive roles. The Communist Manifesto is full of praise for the bourgeoisie because capitalism had developed the means of production. Throughout history ruling classes have been necessary, because human beings have lived in a world of scarcity. That is the root of the class struggle.

According to Marx capitalism had created, or was in the process of creating, a situation where there was no need for the struggle of classes, no longer a need for some people to rise to the top and create some sort of civilisation on the basis of exploitation.

Marx said socialism came out of advanced capitalism. This was Lenin's view also.

So why did Lenin — who was the first to insist that socialism was not possible in backward Russia -make a revolution there? Why did Lenin and Trotsky make a revolution in a country where, though it was politically possible for the workers to take power, socialism was not possible because the coun try was so backward?

Lenin saw the Russian revolution as the first of a chain of revolutions in which the workers would take power in places like Germany and,

eventually: America. The

Bolsheviks did not see the Russian revolution as a socialist revolution in the sense that in Russia it was possible to create a better world than the world of advanced capitalism. The revolution was socialists only in so far as it was the beginning of an international working-class revolution.

This is fundamental. When Marxists insist that what happened in Russia from the '20s was not socialism, it is not a way of saying that we do not like it — we are saying that it was an historical abortion, an historical cul-de-sac. If you look at what Lenin and the Bolsheviks said, nothing else could have been expected according to the bedrock ideas of Marxism. An historical abortion is what Lenin and Trotsky said whould happen if the workers' power in the old Tsarist empire remained isolated. They did not foresee Stalinism; they expected that an isolated Russian workers' state would be overthrown by bourgeois forces; but the point here is that socialism could not have been the result of the October 1917 Revolution unless October was the beginning of a series of victorious proletarian revolutions. And it was not.

Socialism is the seizure of power the working class in the advanced countries. It takes as its starting point the best that capitalism has achieved. From this point of view Russia was not socialist, and could not be socialist.

1 am not repudiating the revolution. Socialist Organiser defends and stands by the Russian revolution. But the revolution was defeated by a bureaucratic, Stalinist counter-revolution - that is, a counter-revolution made by the state bureaucracy who came under the sway of the scarcity and backwardness which has dominated human history.

The Stalinists created a totalitarian collectivism which most people take to be socialist.

From the Marxist point of view, Russia was the opposite of socialism. In many ways it was further from socialism than the advanced capitalism we have in Western Europe is. Areal socialism an aleged second way of judging what what does an alleged "socialism" mean to the working Did the workers rule in Russia? No! Were the workers better off in Continued on pages 8 and 9

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 510

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →