Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Discipline and pun I problems stewards fa

Socialist Organiser no. 509, 29 November 1991 · scan p. 15 · about 1,531 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 15 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 15

By Conway major national posts he left took 2 out of 5 during the recent national officer elections - its best result ever. Although failing to win either of the two vice-president posts, the left retained one of the Examiners of Accounts, Joan Ivens of Coventry, and gained the important post of National Treasurer.

The successful candidate, lan Murch, a long-standing thorn in the side of the right wing, ran an excellent campiagn. He ousted the sitting Treasurer Gordon Green, one of the idles, mean idols, of the so-called "Broad Left".

Ian gained 17,000 votes, the highest in all the elections. I asked him how he viewed the result. Firstly, why such a large vote?

"An aspect of it is an acknowledgement that the union is in financial difficulties. Green was bland about the fact that he was going to put things right. Yet in pursuit of doing that he had been to Trinidad and Tobago over the past 2 years.

The union's attempts to straighten out the finances were a threat to union democracy. That struck a chord with members. I stood firmly on the point that money shouldn't be taken away from local NUT branches. I also pointed to some simple priorities for the union related to the defence of members rather than engaging in the kind of public relations activities which the union has gone in for over the past 2 years, costing us a lot of money"

Given that there are 2 left groups inside the union (lan is a member of both, although mainly active inside the Campaign for a Democratic, Fighting Union), / asked lan how important this result was for the left.

"It's quite important as a bridgehead. It will make it much harder for the right to secretively manipulate things in the way they have done in the past.

The right will, of course, try to tactically manoeuvre their way around it, to see, for example, how many things the Treasurer has to be on and how many things they can remove him from. But it's very unlikely that they will bring any further changes to the structure of the union to next year's conference, something they have been considering recently.

Their morale has taken a blow. Ideologically, they are much weaker now. Some of their best people are gone. The younger ones have never put up a fight over anything. They made their names by trying to put a brake on things during the last national dispute"

So what about the prospects for the year ahead considering that the election result comes at a time of low morale and little action within the union?

*The state of the union mirrors the national picture with most unions. A number have "lan is quite right. There needs to be realignment". tried to fight the Government and have failed. Others, like the NUT, have had a fight of sorts which they've been headed off from by their leadership.

And when you've had a major struggle and lost you know that it may be some time before people regain their confidence in order to fight another one.

in that context, the General Election may well be a watershed because whoever wins, it will force people to concentrate their minds on what they are going to do next. If there's a Labour Government, there will be an upsurge in union activity because pople will expect things of a Labour Government that it's very unlikely to deliver. If the Tories win, it's a very serious situation for teachers because it's pretty certain that they will break up local authority control of education and we'll see the opting out of virtually all secondary schools. The union will have to organise in completely different circumstances. It will mean the break up of national pay rates and we will be back to the sort of struggles that led to the NUT being set up. But people will fight it as they did then".

How will this result affect next year's executive elections?

*It does prove that apparently secure and watertight people can be defeated. In the last elections, 2 years ago, Gordon Green won by a margin of 2 to 1 and this time he was defeated. So it is possible to fight a campaign and overturn somebody"

Finally, how does this result affect the future shape of the left in the union?

"It's tied up with a lot of other things. The reason that I'm a member of the Socialist Teachers' Alliance, but not an active member of it, is because the STA has found it hard to have a coherent role in the union because of the disputes within itself.

The CDFU isn't, in a sense, an alternative to the STA, because some people belong to both. It's a pressure group with fairly simple objectives in relation to the union and it has proved its worth in that respect.

I don't see things in the context of a kind of sectarian, factional struggle, but there quite possibly will be some degree of realignment in the future"

Ian is quite right. There needs to be a realignment. The fact that the CDFU and STA could not agree a joint slate for the vice-presidential elections might have cost us one of those posts. McAvoy won't be pleased with lan Murch's victory Murch's high vote shows what can be done in a straight fight against the right wing "Broad Left".

But it also shows how important it is to direct your campaign material primarily at the immediate concerns of the members. Some of the STA candidates in these elections seemed unaware of that fact. Their material was vague and illfocussed and out of step with the current consciousness of the members.

For a realignment to take place, the STA must recognise that it exists primarily as a left opposition to the right wing in the union. Too many in the STA will say that Murch won because his message was right wing and too non-political. This is nonsense. His message was sharply focussed on how to reinvigorate the membershipTheoretical politics are hot air unless we can rebuild the confidence of the membership and prepare them for action again in the future.

Murch and the CDFU are not always right but they can teach the STA some of these simple truths. Unfortunately, the STA is increasingly influenced by the intolerance and blatant sect builders of the SWP. Before the STA criticises the CDFU as being too right wing, it should put its own house in order by settling accounts with these directionless wreckers.

One of the major in representing their members is the issue of discipline.

Employers use a multitude reasons such as abusive language, poor work performance, lateness, refusing to do certain jobs and, of course, union activity.

Eventually disciplinary measures can lead to dismissal. It is an issue therefore that we need to take seriously, and it is essential that we learn to deal with it effectively and ensure our members are protected from management.

Over the years unions have generally achieved this through agreeing disciplinary procedures with management. Some trade unionists say, however, that by agreeing procedures we accept management's right to disciplin workers.

The reality is that management do discipline workers; therefore it is better to have procedures and agreements which help protect our member from being arbitrarily disciplined. But it is also important that stewards and members recognis that while good procedures can help, it also follows that management can and do use these procedures for their own ends.

Victimisation is the most common. But they also use it tr strike fear and uncertainty amongst the workforce. The lis of them doing this is endless. For example, last year at a frozen food factory in Southampton the workforce, who were employed on a packing line on double day shift, derobed a young apprentice as part of an initiation ceremony, which all previous new apprentices underwent.

After this particular incident the young apprentice, traumatised by the experience, refused to return to work. His supervisor (a member of the GMB) reported the incident to Fraser convinced the AEU of the need for a joint approach to bring management back to the negotiating table. Eventually they met management with their united front tactic and extracted an agreement based on the following:

(1) That the supervisor should be reinstated and all disciplinary charges removed.

(2) A recognition from management that they had breached procedures.

(3) That the apprentice be reinstated on the other shift with no loss of rights or pay.

(4) A joint unionmanagement meeting with the workforce to explain why initia tion ceremonies would never be tolerated again.

(5) That a full workplace inspection be carried out immediately to identify hazards and that relevant action would be taken.

(6) Both unions would be looking to renegotiate the disciplinary procedure for any improvements that all parties see as desirable.

Clearly the unions won a victory, but it could have been a different story. The lessons learned were clear. When managements discipline workers there is usually other issues at stake. Central for stewards is

----- pull-quotes -----

STEWARD'S CORNER By Alan

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 509

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →